Why should we Americans care whether or not a murderer is considered insane in the eyes of the court?

Why should we Americans care whether or not a murderer is considered insane in the eyes of the court?
by

1 Answer

Answer :

insanity = reduced culpability really simple
by

Related questions

John Hinckley (Reagan's would-be assassin) is being released. Good idea or bad idea?

Description : John Hinckley (Reagan's would-be assassin) is being released. Good idea or bad idea?

Last Answer : Let me check with Jodie Foster on that one. Her opinion matters more than mine.

In D&D could ability score damage mimic some types of mental illness in real life?

Description : In D&D could ability score damage mimic some types of mental illness in real life?

Last Answer : The role playing game Kult, and the Chaosium game Call of Cthulhu are both examples of this. But as you go insane you also reality as it truly is, and not the illusion or lie that most ... since 1999 and not sure if my library and sources are obsolete. But you have developed an excellent system.

Can all psychopaths' become murders?

Description : Can all psychopaths' become murders?

Last Answer : I had a thought in grade school. If one of a hundred people are psychopaths’ and they each kill one hundred people then the human race would become extinct. Except if they killed eachother instead than the statistics would be favorable.

Ever know anyone with a split personality?

Description : Ever know anyone with a split personality?

Last Answer : Yes, but worked at a psychiatric hospital in college. Only saw two of her three personalities.

Is being habitually honest a mental illness or a sign that one is developmently delayed?

Description : Is being habitually honest a mental illness or a sign that one is developmently delayed?

Last Answer : Neither, quite the opposite is true.

Could hearing voices or thoughts be caused by telepathy?

Description : Could hearing voices or thoughts be caused by telepathy?

Last Answer : Nope, No and NADA ! “Voices in your head” are just that hallucinations

Is affluenza a real disorder?

Description : Is affluenza a real disorder?

Last Answer : No, it is not a real disorder. It is a buzzword. It is an excuse for patriarchal judges to excuse behavior that would land anyone else in prison for a long time.

How does one find out if they are lazy or stupid?

Description : How does one find out if they are lazy or stupid?

Last Answer : One finds out one is lazy when things stop working in one’s life, but problems could have been avoided if one had done the small but necessary things.

Can you name some famous psychopaths or sociopaths?

Description : Can you name some famous psychopaths or sociopaths?

Last Answer : Well yeah. Of course. Manson, Bundy, Hitler, Son of Sam, The Greenriver killer, The Zodiac killer, Donald trump.

What is the difference between a fanatic extremist, and mental illness?

Description : What is the difference between a fanatic extremist, and mental illness?

Last Answer : One is learned behaviour, the other is caused by biology or chemistry.

Do you think paranoia and other mental illnesses help people survive extreme circumstances?

Description : Do you think paranoia and other mental illnesses help people survive extreme circumstances?

Last Answer : answer:I would say mental illness is usually caused by traumatic events that don't get processed and healed. People definitely shut down their emotional reactions at the time of trauma in order to survive them ... that matters and goes on to form patterns around it for the rest of the person's life.

Has anyone blamed you for being sick?

Description : Has anyone blamed you for being sick?

Last Answer : In school, yes. My parents were fine with my taking days off even when I was not quite at death’s door. Made some classmates very angry.

Do you have to be mentally ill to kill people?

Description : Do you have to be mentally ill to kill people?

Last Answer : answer:Not necessarily. Being a self absorbed narcissist that feels like a victim because he is not getting what he thinks he deserves from his over inflated sense of entitlement is enough for some ... chicks sent him into a murderous rage. When adult children have temper tantrums people can die.

Why would a person continually try to take a dig at someone with every interaction they have?

Description : Why would a person continually try to take a dig at someone with every interaction they have?

Last Answer : answer:I would guess because they are afraid of being direct either because they think it isn't nice to not be, or because they are hoping the person will get a clue. It's fairly passive ... are convinced how they behave is civilized. They seem to not realize just his hostile their behavior is.

I think I may have Factitious Disorder?

Description : I think I may have Factitious Disorder?

Last Answer : No matter what anyone here tells you, we can't help you. You really, really, really need the help of a professional; more than that, a highly reputable specialist. The wrong person(s) can cause damage beyond ... I wish you good luck. Feel free to send me a private message any time you want to talk.

How much should you weight up the other parent's mental health and insist visits be limited or postponed, for the welfare of the child?

Description : How much should you weight up the other parent's mental health and insist visits be limited or postponed, for the welfare of the child?

Last Answer : That does not sound healthy, or safe. If it were my choice he’d never get anywhere near your son. I’d even be nervous with supervised visits.

What is residual schizophrenia?

Description : What is residual schizophrenia?

Last Answer : Residual Schizophrenia. This article seems to say that it is a phase of schizophrenia where the symtoms of schizophrenia have lessened somewhat but are still there. That would by extension seem to indicate that it is less severe.

How do I convince a friend that he needs treatment?

Description : How do I convince a friend that he needs treatment?

Last Answer : Well..I don't know what kind of therapist he saw, but his symptoms are not those of an adjustment disorder, they are delusional, paranoid and schizophrenic. Nothing you can do except try to alert the ... to see him get treatment and I wouldn't keep his location a secret. Good luck, tough situation.

Does pretending to be something you are not hurt people who actually are what you pretend to be?

Description : Does pretending to be something you are not hurt people who actually are what you pretend to be?

Last Answer : …how? Did they explain how? I can’t really see how it would have any effect, shy of doing something horrendous while pretending to be part of a group of people.

How do you deal with someone in your family having mental illness?

Description : How do you deal with someone in your family having mental illness?

Last Answer : answer:There's only so much you can do. Back around 1958, my cousin was placed in a home as a young teenager because his parents couldn't handle his mental illness. He never left the facility ... away for a time. But then, this could happen in a relationship with a person without mental illness.

When you say "mental illness", which disorders are you specifically refering to?

Description : When you say "mental illness", which disorders are you specifically refering to?

Last Answer : Mood and/or personality disorders, usually.

Did you ever ask someone like a waitress for something like a glass of water and get snapped at?

Description : Did you ever ask someone like a waitress for something like a glass of water and get snapped at?

Last Answer : She’s having a bad day. I’d go somewhere else.

Bipolar II- anyone find yourselves to be mostly depressed with episodes of quick to anger?

Description : Bipolar II- anyone find yourselves to be mostly depressed with episodes of quick to anger?

Last Answer : answer:I'm also bipolar. Like you, I rarely get manic episodes. I tend to get depressed more often. I don't have problems with anger now, but I have in the past. I think learning to be calm ... . I hold nothing back. This gives them the best stuff to work with in determining my course of treatment.

What type of person makes up grand stories and at times has erratic behavior?

Description : What type of person makes up grand stories and at times has erratic behavior?

Last Answer : They could be a pathological liar or a compulsive liar. This person sounds like they lie out of habit, which would make them more of a compulsive liar. Here’s the difference. I don’t know what to tell you about the erratic behavior because you aren’t specific, but I hope this helps some.

How is sociopathy diagnosed, and what makes a person recognizable as a sociopath?

Description : How is sociopathy diagnosed, and what makes a person recognizable as a sociopath?

Last Answer : I am thinking anyone can call another a sociopath and the definitions would vary greatly and would be according to the person that utters this and their ideas of what the proper' thing to do is - I ... an word that's a last resort, a word to describe a person whose actions aren't easily explained

Mental breakdown?

Description : Mental breakdown?

Last Answer : Being non-functional. Unable to meet your obligations.

There are five acquaintances. One of them shot and killed one of the other five. Which man is the murderer? 1. Dan ran in the NY City marathon yesterday with one of the innocent men. 2. Mike considered being a farmer before he moved to the city. 3. Jeff is a top-notch computer consultant and wants to install Ben's new computer next week. 4. The murderer had his leg amputated last month. 5. Ben met Jack for the first time six months ago. 6. Jack has been in seclusion since the crime. 7. Dan used to drink heavily. 8. Ben and Jeff built their last computers together. 9. The murderer is Jack's brother; they grew up together in Seattle. -Riddles

Description : There are five acquaintances. One of them shot and killed one of the other five. Which man is the murderer? 1. Dan ran in the NY City marathon yesterday with one of the innocent men. 2. Mike ... last computers together. 9. The murderer is Jack's brother; they grew up together in Seattle. -Riddles

Last Answer : 1. Jack is not the murderer, because he is the brother of the murderer. 2. Dan can't be the murderer since he ran a marathon, and the murderer recently had his leg amputated, and wouldn't ... must also be alive since Jeff plans to install Ben's computer next week. This means that Jeff killed Mike.

If Elizabeth Bathory was caught today, would she be declared criminally insane by an American court of law?

Description : If Elizabeth Bathory was caught today, would she be declared criminally insane by an American court of law?

Last Answer : Probably not, judging by the work of Dietz.

The Code of Ethics states that the nurse’s primary commitment is to the client whether an individual of family, group or community. Which nursing activity would best demonstrate the ethical principle called justice? A. The nurse providing care on a “first come – first served” basis B. Referring the client for evaluation to the social worker on duty regarding her socio-economic status C. The client’s preference is least considered D. The nurse’s providing care to maximize health according to available resources

Description : The Code of Ethics states that the nurse's primary commitment is to the client whether an individual of family, group or community. Which nursing activity would best demonstrate the ethical ... is least considered D. The nurse's providing care to maximize health according to available resources

Last Answer : A. The nurse providing care on a “first come – first served” basis

You see a catalytic-converter thief under your jacked-up car. You shake the car and kick the jack, killing the thief. Are you a hero, or a murderer?

Description : You see a catalytic-converter thief under your jacked-up car. You shake the car and kick the jack, killing the thief. Are you a hero, or a murderer?

Last Answer : They will probably charge you with man slaughter ,BUT!! Pretend you didn’t notice the idiot under the car jump in and drive away thus killing the slime you might get away with it.

Whitey Bulger, 89-year old mobster and multiple murderer, was killed yesterday in prison. Is this frontier justice or is it evil?

Description : Whitey Bulger, 89-year old mobster and multiple murderer, was killed yesterday in prison. Is this frontier justice or is it evil?

Last Answer : I'm not sure he would've gotten out of prison eventually since he was 89 years old when he died. I find it kinda odd they would transfer him to a prison in WV. I read a couple of ... lived the life of luxury near a beach in California for 15 years after murdering several people for no reason.

If you were given a beautiful work of art (for free) that was created by a mass murderer or rapist, would you still keep it?

Description : If you were given a beautiful work of art (for free) that was created by a mass murderer or rapist, would you still keep it?

Last Answer : For a time. Just long enough until I find a fan devoted enough to pay a lot of money for it. Though I doubt that Bush’s dog paintings qualify as “beautiful work of art”.

Have you watched the 6 part HBO documentary about real estate heir/alleged murderer Robert Durst?

Description : Have you watched the 6 part HBO documentary about real estate heir/alleged murderer Robert Durst?

Last Answer : No. I have zero interest in learning more about this man and his ugly doings.

Is not giving the Norwegian mass murderer, Anders Breivik , a ps4 grounds to declare for cruel and unusual punishment?

Description : Is not giving the Norwegian mass murderer, Anders Breivik , a ps4 grounds to declare for cruel and unusual punishment?

Last Answer : Could you please post a link supporting this story?

When the smoke clears, what will be the real explanation why American intelligence and law enforcement authorities did not act on the Russian's tip about (Boston murderer) Tamerlan Tsarnaev?

Description : When the smoke clears, what will be the real explanation why American intelligence and law enforcement authorities did not act on the Russian's tip about (Boston murderer) Tamerlan Tsarnaev?

Last Answer : The Sequester.

What do you think about this convicted murderer suing his victim's widow?

Description : What do you think about this convicted murderer suing his victim's widow?

Last Answer : What is he sueing for?

Would you read a book about a mass-murderer?

Description : Would you read a book about a mass-murderer?

Last Answer : answer:First of all, I don't believe Dahmer was a mass murderer. A serial killer, certainly, but he killed one at a time. Semantics, I know, but I thought I'd point it out. As for your question, I'd ... books all the time. Does the fact that it's a true story make it more sick to read it? Nah.

If you snapped what type of killer would you be, a mass murderer, or a serial killer?

Description : If you snapped what type of killer would you be, a mass murderer, or a serial killer?

Last Answer : Let’s just say, hypothetically I do snap one day, I’m not capable of murder. Bat-shit nuts or not.

Why are they talking about exile for a murderer like Colonel Gadhafi?

Description : Why are they talking about exile for a murderer like Colonel Gadhafi?

Last Answer : He seems right now to be so entrenched that he would rather go down in a hail of bullets than move away and lose all of what has made him who he is, and face some kind of murder trial that could drag ... he calls dignity, ( and a whole lot of money to live the way he has been accustomed). But where?

How do you think a murderer would react to someone that wanted to die?

Description : How do you think a murderer would react to someone that wanted to die?

Last Answer : If they are stoned out of their minds they might just shoot, no matter what. If they are scared that you have seen them and can identify them, they might just shoot no matter what. That’s not a surefire technique, I’m afraid.

People related to a very bad person (terrorist, murderer etc.) If so, who and was it harder to do things like make friends?

Description : People related to a very bad person (terrorist, murderer etc.) If so, who and was it harder to do things like make friends?

Last Answer : It definitely made my life harder but not because of like people knowing who he was or anything, just because of the trauma he caused. My uncle murdered his father (as a teenager. Was never convicted) and ... never have done what she did so it was hard to trust new friends in case they'd be sketchy

A detective in training is called to a room on his first day in, once there his instructor greets him and tells him he has a deck of fish cards. Alongside the instructor are two men who hold three cards from the same deck. He was given a paper reexplaining the prompt which had written on top: 'Each man will say what he has, yet one man is lying... This man is the murderer.' The first man began, he stated he held a shark, a shrimp, and a catfish. The second man stated he held two goldfish and a lion. Who is the murderer? -Riddles

Description : A detective in training is called to a room on his first day in, once there his instructor greets him and tells him he has a deck of fish cards. Alongside the instructor are two men who hold three ... a catfish. The second man stated he held two goldfish and a lion. Who is the murderer? -Riddles

Last Answer : A common first answer is the second man, whereas a shrimp is not considered a fish in this case either... You can look over this again if you'd like now. The The instructor There was only ... to the prompt. Meaning the only way the statement could be true is if the instructor was the murderer.

A famous chemist was murdered in his own lab. There was no evidence except for a piece of paper with the names of chemical substances on it. On the day he was murdered, the chemist had only 3 visitors: his wife, Mary, his nephew Nicolas, and his friend Johnathan. The police arrested the murderer right away. How did they know who it was? -Riddles

Description : A famous chemist was murdered in his own lab. There was no evidence except for a piece of paper with the names of chemical substances on it. On the day he was murdered, the chemist had only ... his friend Johnathan. The police arrested the murderer right away. How did they know who it was? -Riddles

Last Answer : The piece of paper had a clue on it. If you combine the short names of the chemical substances on the paper, you’ll get a name: Ni-C-O-La-S.

A murderer was condemned to death. He had to choose between three rooms. The first room was full of raging fires,the second room was full of assassins with loaded guns and the third room was full of lions that haven't eaten in three years. Which room was safest for him? -Riddles

Description : A murderer was condemned to death. He had to choose between three rooms. The first room was full of raging fires,the second room was full of assassins with loaded guns and the third room was full of lions that haven't eaten in three years. Which room was safest for him? -Riddles

Last Answer : The third room. Lions that haven't eaten in three years are dead.

Every month someone dies, there are five suspects. The suspects are, Jason, Lily, Nathan, Elizabeth, and Erin, and the months of the murders are, July, August, September, October, and November. Who's the murderer? -Riddles

Description : Every month someone dies, there are five suspects. The suspects are, Jason, Lily, Nathan, Elizabeth, and Erin, and the months of the murders are, July, August, September, October, and November. Who's the murderer? -Riddles

Last Answer : Jason. J, July. A, August. S, September. O, October. N, November.

A man was found murdered in his own house on a Sunday morning. His wife called the police. The police questioned the wife and got the following alibis: The wife said she was sleeping. The Cook said he was making breakfast. The gardener said he was picking vegetables. The maid said she was getting the post. The Butler (a personal assistant) said that he was cleaning the closet. The police instantly arrested the murderer. Who did it and how did they know? -Riddles

Description : A man was found murdered in his own house on a Sunday morning. His wife called the police. The police questioned the wife and got the following alibis: The wife said she was sleeping. The Cook ... the closet. The police instantly arrested the murderer. Who did it and how did they know? -Riddles

Last Answer : The maid. There is no post on Sunday.

A man was found murdered on Sunday morning. His wife immediately called the police. The police questioned the wife and staff and got these alibis: The Wife said she was sleeping. The Cook was cooking breakfast. The Gardener was picking vegetables. The Maid was getting the mail. The Butler was cleaning the closet. The police instantly arrested the murderer. Who did it and how did they know? -Riddles

Description : A man was found murdered on Sunday morning. His wife immediately called the police. The police questioned the wife and staff and got these alibis: The Wife said she was sleeping. The Cook was cooking ... closet. The police instantly arrested the murderer. Who did it and how did they know? -Riddles

Last Answer : It was the Maid. She said she was getting the mail. There is no mail on Sunday! (next day air and email doesn't count)

A man was found murdered on Sunday morning. His wife immediately called the police. The police questioned the wife and staff and got these alibis: The Wife said she was sleeping. The Cook was cooking breakfast. The Gardener was picking vegetables. The Maid was getting the mail. The Butler was cleaning the closet. The police instantly arrested the murderer. Who did it and how did they know? -Riddles

Description : A man was found murdered on Sunday morning. His wife immediately called the police. The police questioned the wife and staff and got these alibis: The Wife said she was sleeping. The Cook was cooking ... closet. The police instantly arrested the murderer. Who did it and how did they know? -Riddles

Last Answer : It was the Maid. She said she was getting the mail. There is no mail on Sunday!

A murderer is condemned to death. He has to choose between three rooms. The first is full of raging fires, the second is full of assassins with loaded guns, and the third is full of lions that haven't eaten in 3 years. Which room is safest for him? -Riddles

Description : A murderer is condemned to death. He has to choose between three rooms. The first is full of raging fires, the second is full of assassins with loaded guns, and the third is full of lions that haven't eaten in 3 years. Which room is safest for him? -Riddles

Last Answer : The third. Lions that haven't eaten in three years are dead.