Why is there controversy between the Sunni and Shiites Muslims?

1 Answer

Answer :

Shia and Sunni have mostly same beliefs and both believe infundamental beliefs of Islam. Today there is up to 260 sects inIslam that are in two main categories of shia and sunni.Shia believes in Allah, prophet and all fundamentals ofIslam.Shia pray 5 times a day but usually do the 2, 3 and 4, 5 praytogether and so may seem they do only 3 pray a day. there is somedifferences in details of pray like genuflect (for shia should beon a stone or part of earth and for sunni on carpet or floor ).shia believe after death of prophet God selected the successivefor prophet who is the political leader of Muslim community andpeople can not and does not the right to selected it.Shia believes the Caliph (Representative of God in earth) isselected only by God and can not be selected by people because Godsaid in Koran: "Indeed, I will make upon the earth a successiveauthority" (Quran 2:30) or "O David! We did indeed make thee avicegerent on earth" (Quran 38:26) also other verses.Shia believes such verses means only God can select an Islamicpolitical leader (Caliph).In Shia Islam Caliphs after prophet are 12 Imams and all of themare the same and have no mistake and have the knowledge ofeverything (not absolute knowledge like knowledge of God) and theyhear all sayings and even thinks of all humans after even aftertheir death by permission of God and they are intermediates betweenGod and human Shia Muslims always support them and forgive theirlives for them.Shia Muslims do not consider selection of Abubakr as Caliph bypeople valid because God did not select him. They believe Godordered prophet to declare people that Ali is selected as successorof prophet and prophet did this mission many times during hisprophet-hood and mainly in Ghadir event after last Hajj of his lifeat a 3-4 hour speech in front of 120,000 Muslims at Ghadir in hotdesert after 2 days stop of long caravan for gathering and 3 daysafter speech for congratulations and homage of Muslims to Ali.Islam at that time had high power in world and Some companions hadhigh interest in leadership position after prophet. Muslims knewthat it is the final Hajj of prophet (predicted by prophet) andwere going along with prophet to hear what prophet says at end ofhis life. Shia believes Ghadir event is the most important event ofIslam and is mentioned in Koran in many verses like "Today" (اليوم)in verse 5:3 of Quran is the day of Ghadir. Or Verse 5:67 (OMessenger! proclaim the (message) which hath been sent to thee fromthy ****. If thou didst not, thou wouldst not have fulfilled andproclaimed His mission. And Allah will defend thee from men (whomean mischief). For Allah guideth not those who reject Faith) isrevealed at Ghadir day and is about declaring political leadershipof Ali after prophet.Both Sunni and Shia Muslims accept happening of Ghadir event Butdifferent interpret. Some Sunni writers tried to reject the eventof Ghadir as declare of leadership of Ali and said at Ghadirprophet only wanted to say Ali is my friend and no one shouldbother him. Ali had 3 different missions to Yemen by prophet during10 years and in 2 of them some companions of prophet had someconflicts with Ali and and prophet said some sayings about Ali tosolve conflicts and some sunni writers have mixed stories ofmissions of Ali to Yemen with story of Ghadir to prove Ghadir eventis not about Leadership of Ali and is not important.Shia scholars believe some Sunni writers have changed anddeviated historical evidences about political leadership of Ali inold historical books and republished them to destroy evidences ofleadership of Ali from old Sunni books.The famous Shia book Al-Ghadir (الغدير) by Allameh Amini is acollection of evidences and proofs for Ghadir Events written afterreferring to 100,000 Sunni books and full reading of 10,000 sunnybooks. Allameh Amini is a famous Shia scholar and spent 40 years ofhis life in travelling to access original old Sunni books inlibraries in different countries to write this 20 volume book onlyfrom Sunni books and not using any Shia book. Some Sunni scholarstried to reply this book but then said if we want to reply thisbook we should first destroy all books of ourselves.Shia doctrine have root in Karbala tragedy. When tragedy ofKarbala happened most of Iranians understood there is two differentkinds of Islam and after happening of Karbala tragedy most ofIranians became followers of "Ahl al-Bayt" and forgive their livesfor them like what they did in Iranian Revolution and Iran-IraqWar. Shia Muslims have at least 120,000 Hadith (saying) from TheFourteen Infallibles that is the base of Shia Islam along withQuran. Shia believes according to " Hadith of the two weightythings" The Fourteen Infallibles are the only valid interpreters ofQuran and sayings of them are from God because they areRepresentative of God in earth and they do not say anything fromthemselves. Shia believes 12th of them (Mahdi) is alive and becausepeople have killed all 11 Imams before him, he is in hide likeJesus and will come out of hide toghether with Jesus when peoplebecome ready and want to accept his leadership. All 11 Imams havebeen killed and during their life thy all have been in prison orunder hard control of government to not have any political action.They never had enough serious followers to can get political power.Among them only the sixth Imam Ja'far al-Sadiq was relatively freein his life to have only scientific activities (but banned from anypolitical action) and so only he is known in west because heestablished university and had students from all over the world.Westerns know him as a polymath: an astronomer, alchemist, Imam,Islamic scholar, Islamic theologian, writer, philosopher,physician, physicist and scientist. He was also the teacher of thefamous chemist, Jābir ibn Hayyān (Geber), and of Abū Ḥanīfa, thefounder of the Hanafi school of Sunni Islamic jurisprudence. Henever wanted be a famous man and only shared his knowledge with whowanted to learn. Some researchers consider his teachings the rootcause of renaissance.Sunni Muslims also accept Mahdi and his worldwide leadership asCaliph of God in earth at end of world. There is a famous Hadithfrom prophet Muhammad (PBUH) that Mahdi at hide is like sun behindcloud, he is hidden from people but people receive his benefits.Shia Muslims say some faithful believers have connection with Mahdiand use his knowledge. Shia Muslims believe that it is proved atleast 1000 persons have had connection and talk with Mahdi duringhis hide period but Any one having relation with Mahdi keep it anddoes not declare it in public until is alive.the conflict of shia and sunni has been always amplified byworld Imperialism to prevent Islam from gaining power.

Related questions

Description : What is the difference between the Shia Muslims and the Sunni Muslims?

Last Answer : The most significant difference is just historical. Shia believethat the first Caliph entitled to rule after death of prophetMuhammad was his cousin Ali Ibn Abou Taleb and the husband of theprophet daughter. ... to Islam, to be the first caliph. No other crucialdifferences. Refer to question below.

Description : What is the difference between the Shia Muslims and the Sunni Muslims?

Last Answer : The most significant difference is just historical. Shia believethat the first Caliph entitled to rule after death of prophetMuhammad was his cousin Ali Ibn Abou Taleb and the husband of theprophet daughter. ... to Islam, to be the first caliph. No other crucialdifferences. Refer to question below.

Description : Who was Sunni Ali?

Last Answer : Madogo, the tenth si of Gao, was the father of Sunni Ali, the founder of the Songhay Empire in West Africa.

Description : Which is a major source of argument between Sunni and Shia Muslim?

Last Answer : Historically, the schism involved who would lead Islam after Muhammad, as the rightful leader of the faith. Subsequently there have been defining sifferences, such as how many pillars of faith are recognized.

Description : What do you make of the controversy over Dave Chappelle?

Last Answer : I haven’t seen the Netflix special. I do know he can be raw but he’s a comedian. That’s what they do.

Description : What are your thoughts on latest controversy in US Open final?

Last Answer : I think it was unfair to Serena. I also don't understand the coaching rule. I'm not very familiar with tennis rules. I don't see why a pro needs coaching during a match, but I also don't understand why ... crowd and comforting Osaka. I felt badly for Osaka, she didn't want to win that way I'm sure.

Description : UN Ambassador Nikki Haley announced that the US will be "taking names" of countries that vote against the US in the Jerusalem embassy move controversy. Is this a smart foreign policy move by the US?

Last Answer : Well, it’s pretty easy for her. Just take a list of U.N. Security Council member states, cross the US off the list, and there are all the names. The US has renounced diplomacy and openly said there is no foreign policy other than the US economy.

Description : How do you feel about the controversy over a woman's image on the ten dollar bill?

Last Answer : answer:Fighting over which one is just wasting time. As long as it's a $5, $10, or $20 I'm fine with it. Not because of who is on it now, but because those bills are used a lot. Why just ... bet the majority of people don't even know who is on what bill except for maybe Washington on the $1 bill.

Description : What is your opinion on the Sad Puppies controversy that is happening in the Hugo nomination process?

Last Answer : I have a couple of friends who are Fantasy writers and they are embarrassed by it all. Seems to me to be no more than a bid for publicity to A) boost sales, and B) hopefully boost votes which ... A. Social media (where I have seen the Sad Puppy stuff) is an outstanding, inexpensive, marketing tool.

Description : Abortion: what's with all the controversy?

Last Answer : answer:Some people believe that abortion ends a tiny possible life and that possibility should be treated as a person. Some believe people should be in control of their own bodies and decisions ... people involved. Both positions make sense and are exclusive of the other, so there's controversy.

Description : In the Chilly D's "fat girls" controversy, is it the problem that the girls are fat (I assume that they actually are), or that someone recognized that they were fat and wrote it down. Or perhaps both?

Last Answer : The problem is that it is innappropriate and unprofessional for an employee to call a customer a fat girl to their face, and if it is there in plain writing on their bill it is essentially the same ... fat people in the restaurant? Maybe they live in a skinny city and there aren't many fat people.

Description : So! Mature cells may be reprogrammed into stem cells. Does this put the stem cell controversy to rest?

Last Answer : It will still be political due to different facilities scrapping over the same funding?

Description : How do you feel about the Daniel Tosh rape joke controversy?

Last Answer : I’m not even sure what the joke was, ut rape jokes aren’t really funny, that being said he’s paid to push boundries wih comedy. He failed.

Description : What's the latest info on the "pink slime" in beef controversy?

Last Answer : Don’t have a link but I read an article saying that a good number of the factories that are producing it have closed and that the FDA is considering banning it from school lunch meats.

Description : In the wake of the Zimmerman/Martin controversy, who is sure they themselves are are not subconsciously biased? Are Flutherites ready for the Bias Test?

Last Answer : My results: Your data suggest little to no difference in implicit preference between Rick Santorum and Barack Obama. Your data suggest a moderate implicit preference for White People compared to Black People.

Description : Bottled water controversy erupts again. How much of the issue is real and how much is environmentalist activism? And can/will anything change?

Last Answer : answer:Bottled water is stupid, because water is freely available via plumbing. There are reasonably cheap filters that can make your water taste better than what's available from bottled water. Also, bottled ... via plumbing, I would say the same thing for bottled beer as well (one can dream).

Description : Speakers of other languages: when someone asks a question about grammar in your language (please name it), does it incite as much controversy and produce as much heated disagreement as do English grammar questions here on Fluther?

Last Answer : It can, as Finnish grammar is extremely complicated (14 different cases and 7 different verb endings)

Description : Will a movie or book about the controversy around the tonight show in 2010 be created?

Last Answer : There doesn’t seem to be any interest in it so far.

Description : Quran burning controversy - How do America's ultra-conservatives feel about flag burning?

Last Answer : answer:I can't speak to the motives or feelings of ultra conservatives; however, I recognize that in many ways I lean that way, so If we ever pass an amendment or law that prohibits burning of the flag ... , no matter how abhorrent it is to me. It's what this country was founded upon, after all.

Description : As you get older, do you find it best to stay away from controversy?

Last Answer : Yeah, I avoid controversy like the plague. :). I love issues that get the blood going. I just respect opposing viewpoints. Differences are what makes the world go around.

Description : What are the true facts behind the "pump/tube vs. jar" skincare controversy? (Details follow)

Last Answer : answer:The main advantage to the pumps is that it is more protected from contamination from your fingers. By putting a product in a tube or pump, you're not dipping your fingers in them, introducing ... of products, I suggest Paula the Cosmetic Cop'. Very no-nonsense. http://www.cosmeticscop.com/

Description : What is your take on the controversy surrounding "black face"?

Last Answer : I see it as a costume. Much like Halloween. I was considering being young black Michael Jackson for Halloween…racism did not enter my mind at all. No, in my opinion this isn’t racist, I don’t see why EVERYTHING has to be offensive to someone now.

Description : Are you ready for an evoltionary controversy?

Last Answer : No, I’m not ready. Seriously. STOP IT.

Description : Controversy on Chiropractic?

Last Answer : answer:They don't go to a tradirtional med school and therefor have no insight on other systems in the human body other then the spine and it's so called alighment. I think they are looked down ... They do and I'm sure many patients are better for it. What specific controversy you are refering to?

Description : [Serious]What’s the craziest controversy of the century?

Last Answer : Attention! [Serious] Tag Notice Jokes, puns, and off-topic comments are not permitted in any comment, parent or child. Parent comments that aren't from the target group will be removed, ... was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this sub if you have any questions or concerns.

Description : People who work at Spotify, what's the atmosphere like there surrounding the Joe Rogan controversy?

Last Answer : We scream FUCK NEIL YOUNG whenever someone brings up the topic

Description : People who work at Spotify, what's the atmosphere like there surrounding the Joe Rogan controversy?

Last Answer : We scream FUCK NEIL YOUNG whenever someone brings up the topic

Description : In what way did the Hindi-Urdu Controversy (1900) strain the relations between the two communities in India? -SST 10th

Last Answer : Urdu was the court language in Uttar Pradesh. The Hindu community, protested and demanded that they should be allowed to submit petitions in Hindi in Devanagri script. The Government granted ... request. Thus, the Hindi-Urdu controversy further strained the relations between the Hindus and Muslims.

Description : Explain in one word- "about which there is no debate (or non-controversy)" ?

Last Answer : About which there is no debate (or non-controversy) - "undisputed".

Description : What modern day controversy best relates to Roosevelt's theme of freedom from fear?

Last Answer : Military defense spending- apex

Description : How did the Compromise set off a storm of political controversy between 1849 and 1850.?

Last Answer : Feel Free to Answer

Description : Why did Patton's comments on the Soviet Union cause controversy?

Last Answer : What is the answer ?

Description : Why has Machiavelli and The Prince evoked so much discussion and controversy?

Last Answer : What is the answer ?

Description : What modern day controversy best relates to Roosevelt's theme of freedom from fear?

Last Answer : Military defense spending- apex

Description : Why is there such a controversy on stem cell therapy?

Last Answer : The controversy isn't over stem cell therapy, it is over embrionic stem cell therapy. Stem cell therapy usually refers to stem cells extracted from the patients own body. Embrionic stem cells are ... is therefore unethical to destroy this for the stem cells as it is supposedly akin to murder.

Description : Why do you think Bleeding Kansas produced intense controversy among many Americans?

Last Answer : It was to decide if Kansas was to be a free state or a slave state so people flooded into the in the territory to sway the vote. This vote was against the principle of the Missouri compromise.

Description : What issue in the Democratic platform of 1864 became a point of controversy?

Last Answer : In the Fall of 1864, the US Civil War raged on. There was no certainty concerning the final outcome of the war. For example, when General US Grant was named the Union's general in chief ... was that there could be no negotiations unless the Southern states first agreed to return to the Union.

Description : The Nullification Controversy showed how strongly Southerners felt about ___________.?

Last Answer : right

Description : The Nullification Controversy showed how strongly Southerners felt about ___________.?

Last Answer : right

Description : controversy over the phylogeny of C. megalodon still persists.[5][63] Several shark researchers (e.g. J. E. Randall

Last Answer : A. P. Klimley

Description : The Hindus had laucnhed “Swadeshi Movement” (to boycott goods made in England) in the wake of: 118 A. The Urdu-Hindi controversy 1867 B. Partition of Bengal 1905 C. Jalilanwala Bagh tragedy 1919 D. All of the above

Last Answer : ANSWER: B

Description : The Hindus had laucnhed “Swadeshi Movement” (to boycott goods made in England) in the wake of: A. The Urdu-Hindi controversy 1867 B. Partition of Bengal 1905 C. Jalilanwala Bagh tragedy 1919 D. All of the above

Last Answer : ANSWER: B

Description : The Hindus had laucnhed “Swadeshi Movement” (to boycott goods made in England) in the wake of: A. The Urdu-Hindi controversy 1867 B. Partition of Bengal 1905 C. Jalilanwala Bagh tragedy 1919 D. All of the above

Last Answer : ANSWER: B

Description : What is the controversy surrounding Bt corn and the monarch butterfly?

Last Answer : Bt corn was specifically engineered to control the European corn borer, which in 2003 caused an estimated $1 billion worth of damage to U.S. farmers. In 1999 a study was ... to increase the probability of female monarchs encountering milkweed plants that are uncontaminated with corn pollen. 

Description : Which one of the following Fundamental rights has been the subject of maximum litigation and controversy? a) Right to property b) Right to equality c) Right to freedom d) Right to freedom of religion

Last Answer : a) Right to property

Description : The current through a metallic conductor is due to the motion of a. free electrons b. Protons c. Neutrons d. still under controversy

Last Answer : a. free electrons

Description : Which animal is the center of the timber-harvest controversy in the Pacific Northwest? w) blackfooted ferret x) California condor y) northern spotted owl z) gray wolf

Last Answer : ANSWER: Y -- NORTHERN SPOTTED OWL

Description : What do communicated words carry in a classroom situation ? (A) Inspiration, controversy and introspection (B) Diversion, criticism and irrationality (C) Insipidity, irrationality, and non-acceptance (D) Power, structure and tradition

Last Answer : (D) Power, structure and tradition

Description : Interaction inside the classroom should generate (A) Argument (B) Information (C) Ideas (D) Controversy

Last Answer : (C) Ideas

Description : Why don't they have homeless shelters across the planet for Muslims?

Last Answer : Do you know that they don’t? Since there are Muslims in many countries, I would think there might be different provisions in different countries. Do you have any sources to cite to back up your assertions?