How would you figure out if a Panic Disorder is caused by previous traumatic experiences or a chemical imbalance?

How would you figure out if a Panic Disorder is caused by previous traumatic experiences or a chemical imbalance?
by

1 Answer

Answer :

If a chemical imbalance is diagnosed then meds are prescribed. I personally hate taking pills, so I would opt for counseling first. If that does not help or begin to uncover underlying psychological reasons for the feelings then I would go to the next step which I guess would be a psychiatrist and meds. Try reading Claire Weekes books, Hope and Help for my Jangled Nerves is one which is very good. They teach you how to deal with the panic feelings and that for me is preferable to medicating them or denying they exist. I should add, I don’t think there is a right or wrong way to address this, you just have to find what works best for you. So explore the alternatives before you decide what route to take.
by

Related questions

My Mom thinks that my Panic Disorder is not caused from my past traumatic experience because she has had traumatic experiences as well but does not have panic disorder, is it possible that different people react differently?

Description : My Mom thinks that my Panic Disorder is not caused from my past traumatic experience because she has had traumatic experiences as well but does not have panic disorder, is it possible that different people react differently?

Last Answer : 1. All people react differently, its natural. 2. Yes, its possible for one person to have a mental disorder, but the other to not. Individual person and personality naturally result in different ... realize about violation, and they realize that something needs to be done for the sake of recovery.

Is it possible for traumatic events to create a pseudo-seasonal affected disorder?

Description : Is it possible for traumatic events to create a pseudo-seasonal affected disorder?

Last Answer : No specialist, I believe, can tell you whether this is exactly true or not - people are so varied in their emotional response, in how their bodies deal with trauma. All I can say is that ... less safe and your coping around traumatic events gets affected more during the times you feel less safe.

How much worse does "victim blaming" make a traumatic experience such as rape?

Description : How much worse does "victim blaming" make a traumatic experience such as rape?

Last Answer : Maybe you can Google, “Rape Cases.” That’ll get you some hits.

Have adults who speak in very childish voices had something traumatic happen to them in their childhood ?

Description : Have adults who speak in very childish voices had something traumatic happen to them in their childhood ?

Last Answer : Um ...... yeah? It's possible. It could totally be a way in which more aggravated dissociative states present themselves (as could all voices - like, gruff and deep and male on a teeny, high ... various vernacular (eg baby talk, LOLspeak) than a soft voice, though they could easily combine the two.

Do fish get PTSD (post traumatic stess disorder) after being picked up from a waterspout?

Description : Do fish get PTSD (post traumatic stess disorder) after being picked up from a waterspout?

Last Answer : I doubt it. They don't seem to think like us. I would opine that I think most wild animals live in a constant state of fear, and anxiety. It is relevant to note, that many lakes are stocked by ... a plane, I suspect that they get over a tornado. Nature has gifted most fish, with a short memory.

Do soliders who get Post Traumatic Stress Disorder on duty (PTSD) get a purple heart medal ?

Description : Do soliders who get Post Traumatic Stress Disorder on duty (PTSD) get a purple heart medal ?

Last Answer : No, they pretty well just get fucked over.

Can you get Post Traumatic Stress Disorder from watching Television or movies?

Description : Can you get Post Traumatic Stress Disorder from watching Television or movies?

Last Answer : Dying from cancer does it for me. I’m talking about the last moments.

Are blackouts and crying fits common with post traumatic stress disorder?

Description : Are blackouts and crying fits common with post traumatic stress disorder?

Last Answer : Someone hit you while you were at the gym? I’m confused.

What's a good way to go about finding a therapist to help with post-traumatic stress disorder?

Description : What's a good way to go about finding a therapist to help with post-traumatic stress disorder?

Last Answer : For USians. Good luck!

Is Post Traumatic Stress Disorder something that would qualify someone for social security disability?

Description : Is Post Traumatic Stress Disorder something that would qualify someone for social security disability?

Last Answer : To receive social security disability for post traumatic stress disorder, it could vary from state to state. To find out if your eligible for social security disability, you should first contact your local social security services.

Currently, the selective serotonin reuptake inhibitors are the preferred drugs for the following psychiatric disorder/disorders: A. Phobias B. Obsessive-compulsive disorder C. Post-traumatic stress disorder D. All of the above

Description : Currently, the selective serotonin reuptake inhibitors are the preferred drugs for the following psychiatric disorder/disorders: A. Phobias B. Obsessive-compulsive disorder C. Post-traumatic stress disorder D. All of the above

Last Answer : D. All of the above

How To Treat Post- Traumatic Stress Disorder

Description : How To Treat Post- Traumatic Stress Disorder

Last Answer : How To Treat Post- Traumatic Stress Disorder Unexpected and traumatic events affect people in different ways. While some are able to handle these situations properly and eventually get over them, some ... , a traumatized individual will eventually be able to learn how to cope with his struggles.

What type of electrolyte imbalance can be caused by diuretics?

Description : What type of electrolyte imbalance can be caused by diuretics?

Last Answer : Feel Free to Answer

The paradigm that explains the cause of illness as an imbalance in the forces of nature is the a) holistic perspective. The naturalist or holistic perspective believes that health exists when all aspects of a persona are in perfect balance or harmony. b) magico-religious view. The magico-religious view holds that illness is caused by forces of evil. c) biomedical view. The biomedical view holds life events as cause and effect and incorporates the bacterial or viral explanation of communicable disease. d) scientific view. The scientific view holds life events as cause and effect and incorporates the bacterial or viral explanation of communicable disease.

Description : The paradigm that explains the cause of illness as an imbalance in the forces of nature is the a) holistic perspective. The naturalist or holistic perspective believes that health exists when ... events as cause and effect and incorporates the bacterial or viral explanation of communicable disease.

Last Answer : a) holistic perspective. The naturalist or holistic perspective believes that health exists when all aspects of a persona are in perfect balance or harmony.

Which of the following is true regarding gingivosis (Desquamative gingivitis) A. It is caused by hormononal imbalance B. Is seen only at or after menopause C. Is frequently caused by lichen planus D. Is a variant pregnancy gingivitis E. Is related to nutritional disturbance

Description : Which of the following is true regarding gingivosis (Desquamative gingivitis) A. It is caused by hormononal imbalance B. Is seen only at or after menopause C. Is frequently caused by lichen planus D. Is a variant pregnancy gingivitis E. Is related to nutritional disturbance

Last Answer : C. Is frequently caused by lichen planus

How do you (or, 'how does one') overcome the severe effects of a panic attack or phobia?

Description : How do you (or, 'how does one') overcome the severe effects of a panic attack or phobia?

Last Answer : I'm confused. You mention panic attacks and phobias in the question, but sharp pain and nausea in the description. I realize you don't want to go into the details of your situation, but I ... . Regardless, I wish you well and hope you can find a solution to your ongoing medical conditions.

Panic attacks or something else?

Description : Panic attacks or something else?

Last Answer : My cousin’s wife gets panic attacks and those are the symptoms almost exactly. Hang on till Monday.

Have you ever had a panic attack?

Description : Have you ever had a panic attack?

Last Answer : I have had a panic attack. I don’t remember what started it. I only remember grabbing my list of things to do and trying breathing, giving up on taking a hot bath, and finally calling someone who talked me down.

Whats wrong with me ? ( anxiety, panic attacks, and the unknown)

Description : Whats wrong with me ? ( anxiety, panic attacks, and the unknown)

Last Answer : Talk to your doctor. If you can’t get the results desired than maybe its time to find another dr. Hope you find a solution.

Do Anxiety and Panic Disorders (specifcally Depersonalization) have genetic roots to them?

Description : Do Anxiety and Panic Disorders (specifcally Depersonalization) have genetic roots to them?

Last Answer : (Keep in mind that you mean “its genetic roots.” It’s = it is.)

What are some good ways to deal with panic disorder and unatural fear of dying?

Description : What are some good ways to deal with panic disorder and unatural fear of dying?

Last Answer : answer:Immediately? Take at least 10 deep, long breaths. Count to four while you're breathing in, and then again while breathing out. The counting takes your mind off the other stuff, and the breathing helps ... They can help you figure out how best to deal with this fear in ways the internet can't.

Has anybody ever taken Zoloft for a panic disorder?

Description : Has anybody ever taken Zoloft for a panic disorder?

Last Answer : answer:i took zoloft…no side effects. so does my mom.

Suffering from severe panic disorder and derealization disorder. Can anybody relate?

Description : Suffering from severe panic disorder and derealization disorder. Can anybody relate?

Last Answer : Looks like you need some professional help.

21 weeks pregnant, panic disorder, and needing 2 root canals...

Description : 21 weeks pregnant, panic disorder, and needing 2 root canals...

Last Answer : answer:1. breathe now. 2. Talk to your dentist. Modern medicine has come a long way, and it's completely possible to do magical things with local anaesthesia. Honestly, if it's that bad I'd ... would hurt your kid a lot less than a jaw infection, a course of antibiotics, and emergency dental surgery

Does anybody on here suffer from panic disorder, PTSD, derealization or other anxiety disorders?

Description : Does anybody on here suffer from panic disorder, PTSD, derealization or other anxiety disorders?

Last Answer : My first psychiatrist visit took place when I was 4 years old. My grandparents took me because I had night terrors, and was terrified of dolls and mannequins (a child's version of they're out to get me ). ... least for now). And none of those were my fault, dammit! Damn, that felt good to say :)

Marijuana and panic disorder?

Description : Marijuana and panic disorder?

Last Answer : Seems to me it would mellow a person out that was prone to panic attacks. Then again, it makes me personally kind of paranoid, so probably not a good idea.

Who cures your panic disorder?

Description : drugs, vitamins

Last Answer : I'd be curious about that, too. I read a lot afterwards but I haven't gotten any further.

Panic disorder with agoraphobia?

Description : Panic disorder with agoraphobia?

Last Answer : DefinitionPanic disorder with agoraphobia is an anxiety disorder in which there are repeated attacks of intense fear and anxiety, and a fear of being in places where escape might be difficult, or where ... behavior. Agoraphobia sometimes occurs when a person has had a panic attack and begins to fe

can i get a grant for being disabled and not having enough money to pay my bills or pay my rent i live on 832 dollars a month i also take care of my mom who is very ill and cant get paid for it because of severe depression and panic disorder ?

Description : can i get a grant for being disabled and not having enough money to pay my bills or pay my rent i live on 832 dollars a month i also take care of my mom who is very ill and cant get paid for it because of severe depression and panic disorder ?

Last Answer : could i please get an answer for the above question can i get a grant for being disabled and not having enough money to pay my bills i live on 837 dollars a month and try my hardest to take ... very ill because of my disability i can not get paid for this i have severe depression and panic disorder

Indications of tricyclic antidepressants include the following except: A. Attention deficit-hyperactive disorder in children B. Mania C. Prophylaxis of migraine D. Panic disorder

Description : Indications of tricyclic antidepressants include the following except: A. Attention deficit-hyperactive disorder in children B. Mania C. Prophylaxis of migraine D. Panic disorder

Last Answer : B. Mania

The preferred class of drugs for long term treatment of severe anxiety disorder with intermittent panic attacks is: A. Phenothiazine (chlorpromazine like) B. Azapirone (buspirone like) C. β-blocker (propranolol like) D. Selective serotonin reuptake inhibitor (sertraline like)

Description : The preferred class of drugs for long term treatment of severe anxiety disorder with intermittent panic attacks is: A. Phenothiazine (chlorpromazine like) B. Azapirone (buspirone like) C. β-blocker (propranolol like) D. Selective serotonin reuptake inhibitor (sertraline like)

Last Answer : DD. Selective serotonin reuptake inhibitor (sertraline like)

Has the standard I Q bell curve shifted as this comment from a previous question states?

Description : Has the standard I Q bell curve shifted as this comment from a previous question states?

Last Answer : IQs seem to be steadily going up, but by how much depends on what kind of IQ test you’re looking at and the population you measure. This is called The Flynn Effect.

Does anyone have any experiences of hearing voices inside their heads?

Description : Does anyone have any experiences of hearing voices inside their heads?

Last Answer : Not since I had this demonic possessioGRJKAJFDJHKJFDSFA I AM COMING FOR YOU

How should I interperate these experiences of altered perception and heightened imagery?

Description : How should I interperate these experiences of altered perception and heightened imagery?

Last Answer : First through martial arts I learned of Chi and the pressure point and meridians of the human body. I further was exposed to the Chakras and energy paths ways of the body through Yoga. Meditation ... in and around our bodies. This has allowed for some mind blowing experiences to say the least.

Life changing experiences?

Description : Life changing experiences?

Last Answer : I've had two major life changing experiences thus far in my 23 years of life. The first was getting clean. I was doing speed on a daily basis, and when I became clean, I realized many things that I ... 've had is having my daughter. For obvious reasons - she is the only thing that matters to me now.

Is there anyone here who can help me figure out this Ebola panic?

Description : Is there anyone here who can help me figure out this Ebola panic?

Last Answer : If you turn on the tv, you will get no facts. Here is the CDC’s (Centers for Disease Control and Infection) fact sheet on Ebola.

Speaking your thoughts out loud without realizing it. What is this disorder called?

Description : Speaking your thoughts out loud without realizing it. What is this disorder called?

Last Answer : verbal filter control problem, poor impulse control, autism, and bi-polar disorder come up when I search for what you describe.

What is the difference between delusional disorder, and dissociative disorder?

Description : What is the difference between delusional disorder, and dissociative disorder?

Last Answer : I’ve never heard of delusional disorder. Delusions are a symptom of other disorders. Dissociative disorder is one in which a person has a break with reality and also loses a grip on their own sense of self.

Does anyone have experience with bipolar disorder?

Description : Does anyone have experience with bipolar disorder?

Last Answer : I've experienced 1st and 2nd hand relationships with bipolar people. My ex took some different medications for it and ended up having some pretty severe effects which don't sound at all like ... to the paranoia than the bipolar, I would say) keeping supportive friends was challenging. Best wishes!

Do blind people suffer from Seasonal Affective Disorder?

Description : Do blind people suffer from Seasonal Affective Disorder?

Last Answer : answer:The answer is “Yes!” Your question intrigued me. I didn’t know the answer, so I did a little research. I found this article on a Scientific American Q&A page.

How do you deal with someone who has Narcissistic Personality Disorder ?

Description : How do you deal with someone who has Narcissistic Personality Disorder ?

Last Answer : answer:Ooh, that's a tough situation. My mother has a personality disorder (she's Borderline), and it's hard to treat - even if the patient is willing. For this and other reasons, eventually ... . Rely on your own therapy to give you some coping strategies for those times when you must interact.

Is Body Integrity Identity Disorder as genuine in your mind Gender Identity Disorder?

Description : Is Body Integrity Identity Disorder as genuine in your mind Gender Identity Disorder?

Last Answer : I'm the same as you though I'm not really sure why. I'm quick with sympathizing for people with GID but for some reason I just can't wrap my mind around BIID. I just watched a movie that ... called Armless. As the title implies he wanted both his arms amputated in order to feel whole .weird movie .

Has anyone ever suffered from a Social Phobia or Social Anxiety Disorder?

Description : Has anyone ever suffered from a Social Phobia or Social Anxiety Disorder?

Last Answer : I have trouble being in crowds. I cannot go to large parties. Shopping on Black Friday scares the hell out of me. I began to panic while in Costco last weekend, because it was simply too crowded. I haven’t done any kind of therapy for this.

Where does personality end and disorder begin?

Description : Where does personality end and disorder begin?

Last Answer : When one faces some crisis or unpredictable accidents in life…

What are some books/blogs/references for obsessive–compulsive personality disorder?

Description : What are some books/blogs/references for obsessive–compulsive personality disorder?

Last Answer : answer:Bashing Perfect – author has OCPD endthegame’s Blog & Journal at Experience Project (spouse of OCPD) A listing of OCPD-related sites Short anecdotes, one and two.

Why isn't there a disorder for, well, disorder?

Description : Why isn't there a disorder for, well, disorder?

Last Answer : OCD isn’t just manifested by cleaning, though…ohhhh no….not at all.

How do you treat children with R.A.D. (Reactive Attachment Disorder)

Description : How do you treat children with R.A.D. (Reactive Attachment Disorder)

Last Answer : I’d treat ‘em like any other kids, but then I’m just some schmoe on ask-public, and not anyone with training in the field and worthy of consultation.

Have you ever experienced the manic side of bipolar disorder?

Description : Have you ever experienced the manic side of bipolar disorder?

Last Answer : I have no personal experience with it but I do have a mother with bi-polar so I've experienced it from that side of things. It always seemed it was easier for us to detect her ups and downs ... overworks herself during the manic. We are trying to help her make use of the manic without overdoing it.

Is it possible that certain cases of general anxiety disorder require mediction?

Description : Is it possible that certain cases of general anxiety disorder require mediction?

Last Answer : I have GAD with acute panic attacks. After much experimentation, I will never go off my meds again. I've come to accept that I will be taking it for the rest of my life, and that's ok. (I' ... and the right dose for you. I am in complete agreement with your last statement. Best of luck to you!

What's the name of the disorder when adult people leave poop in public places?

Description : What's the name of the disorder when adult people leave poop in public places?

Last Answer : answer:Encopresis? I had no idea there was such a thing… I googled for “disorder feces” and it was the first hit.