Why don't dogs (animals) have minds?

Why don't dogs (animals) have minds?
by

1 Answer

Answer :

She is starting on an unfounded assumption, namely the assumption that animals do not have minds. Other apes certainly have minds, so do elephants and dolphins. Also you can not with certainty exclude dogs or sea lions.
by

Related questions

What effects do you think it would have on you, and on the world, if everyone were granted the ability to read minds?

Description : What effects do you think it would have on you, and on the world, if everyone were granted the ability to read minds?

Last Answer : Disaster, everywhere.

I've been having dreams of two dogs what do they mean? (details inside on them).

Description : I've been having dreams of two dogs what do they mean? (details inside on them).

Last Answer : I THINK that your just really touched by the death of one of them and your brains unconciously thinking about it.maybe even about how the other one died.

Do you think animal's are stronger than humans?

Description : Do you think animal's are stronger than humans?

Last Answer : Are you sleepy? There’s no apostrophe needed in your question. I won’t mention the other grammatical problems. Many animals are stronger than humans. The human advantage is intelligence.

Don't people have power over their own minds?

Description : Don't people have power over their own minds?

Last Answer : Do some research and get 2nd and 3rd opinions. Most of all though, become your daughters best friend. Best friends listen more than talk.

Do you think that Advertisers are abusing kids' minds by making it so that if they don't buy an app they will hurt their new “Friends” feelings?

Description : Do you think that Advertisers are abusing kids' minds by making it so that if they don't buy an app they will hurt their new “Friends” feelings?

Last Answer : Yes i agree. Have you ever wondered what ads do to children's minds at the age of 12 and younger? Well it makes them sad and depressed because the ads are emotionally manipulating the children. Many children ... sitting on the couch and watching more TV. At the age 10 - 16 kids are at their most im

Why don't they remove some of these older questions?

Description : Why don't they remove some of these older questions?

Last Answer : I know I’m not the sharpest tool in the shed, but still….

How do we teach people to be able to admit, "I don't know."?

Description : How do we teach people to be able to admit, "I don't know."?

Last Answer : I make it a point to say so when it is so, especially around my children. I also make it a point to say that: a) let’s find out and b) let’s talk to someone who might know.

What's wrong with telling a child, "I don't know, but we can look it up."?

Description : What's wrong with telling a child, "I don't know, but we can look it up."?

Last Answer : answer:There’s nothing wrong at all, and it educates the child that (1) the parent is not omniscient, and (2) the parent is open to learning more. My teenage kids ask me questions all the time, and I often say “let’s look it up.”

If fluther thinks I will lurve a question but I don't and just hit the not interested button does it get its feeling hurt?

Description : If fluther thinks I will lurve a question but I don't and just hit the not interested button does it get its feeling hurt?

Last Answer : I think there should be some difference between the Remove and Not Interested button. Intuitively, I’d think Remove means remove this question from my queue, whereas Not Interested means “whatever logical steps you made to think I’d be interested, don’t do that again”

Are there types of Fluther questions you don't even bother to read?

Description : Are there types of Fluther questions you don't even bother to read?

Last Answer : Yes, anything to do with relationships. Other people’s relationship problems are something that I don’t care to get caught up in.

Why don't they ask questions on Facebook?

Description : Why don't they ask questions on Facebook?

Last Answer : Isn’t that what Q+A sites are for?

Have you ever wondered about some of these kinds of things that just don't make sense?

Description : Have you ever wondered about some of these kinds of things that just don't make sense?

Last Answer : Why a golfer gets almost absolute silence when he has all day to hit a ball that’s just lying on the ground, when OTOH, thousands of spectators get to yell at a ball player who has to hit a baseball traveling almost 100 MPH right at him.

Could you help someone figure out how to continue a behavior you don't approve of?

Description : Could you help someone figure out how to continue a behavior you don't approve of?

Last Answer : I would tell them that I can not, in good conscious, support a poor decision. When my words can affect a situation I'm not directly involved with, I take the Switzerland approach- ... . child, student, apprentice, employee), I would make sure they understood the implications of the situation.

Don't you hate it when people feel a need to answer rhetorical questions?

Description : Don't you hate it when people feel a need to answer rhetorical questions?

Last Answer : Nope. I kind of hate it when people ask rhetorical questions. What’s the point of opening your mouth if you didn’t want a response anyway? But I think we all do it, but I’m more on the side of not asking them than hating that they were answered.

How do angels groom their wings if they don't have beaks?

Description : How do angels groom their wings if they don't have beaks?

Last Answer : No dirt in heaven?

Are there Questions You Don't Want to Hear the Answer To?

Description : Are there Questions You Don't Want to Hear the Answer To?

Last Answer : How and when I am going to die.

Do you ever start to answer a question and then think: honestly, who really gives a rat's ass what I think? I don't even care what I think anymore, so you just blow it off?

Description : Do you ever start to answer a question and then think: honestly, who really gives a rat's ass what I think? I don't even care what I think anymore, so you just blow it off?

Last Answer : People care when you’re radical [hint: double meaning]. The Wikipedia quoting crap don’t cut it.

I don't know how to ask a question in Ubuntu Geek?

Description : I don't know how to ask a question in Ubuntu Geek?

Last Answer : Oh, you said Geek. Σορρυ.

Would going to hang out with someone at their house with a ton of random ppl you don't know make u feel awkward?

Description : Would going to hang out with someone at their house with a ton of random ppl you don't know make u feel awkward?

Last Answer : Nope. I LOVE being in that position, starting conversation, meeting new people! LOVE IT

Why don't PETA throw paint at bikers who wear leather?

Description : Why don't PETA throw paint at bikers who wear leather?

Last Answer : _ The red paint activism campaign is aimed against fur not leather.

Have we as Americans, lost our collective minds?

Description : Have we as Americans, lost our collective minds?

Last Answer : Concealed?

Do you think photos of immigrant children crying, on floors, dead at the side of a river are going to change minds about immigration?

Description : Do you think photos of immigrant children crying, on floors, dead at the side of a river are going to change minds about immigration?

Last Answer : No, it won't change minds at all. The Trumpists and immigration hawks will say this is great - this is what should happen to all of them . The humanists will say this is awful . So ... . Repeat this over and over: This situation is all Trump's responsibility and a results of his asinine policies

Is criminal minds still good after Mandy Patinkin leaves?

Description : Is criminal minds still good after Mandy Patinkin leaves?

Last Answer : I’ve seen a dozen episodes and honestly I think it’s laughably cheesy with poor filmmaking. But Patinkin was definitely the best part of the show

Inquiring minds want to know - what does Hillary Clinton think about yesterday's Manafort decision and Cohen pleading?

Description : Inquiring minds want to know - what does Hillary Clinton think about yesterday's Manafort decision and Cohen pleading?

Last Answer : I am trying to imagine what the more conservative jellies are going to say. No doubt something along the lines of how she is feeling so relieved that it is Trump's team that is being ... all his campaign workers, the first two congressional Trump supporters have been brought up on criminal charges.

What is it about hormonal shift during menstruation that messes up with our minds?

Description : What is it about hormonal shift during menstruation that messes up with our minds?

Last Answer : I wish I knew, but I’ll be back to see if anyone does! I’m with ya!

Do you clear your minds daily?

Description : Do you clear your minds daily?

Last Answer : answer:I don’t cope with it. It is almost scary how distracted I get. I can’t focus at all. I tried meditating, but it doesn’t work. I’ve no idea how to deal with this, I wish I knew as much as you.

What do you think of Michelle Pfeiffer's character in the movie "Dangerous Minds"?

Description : What do you think of Michelle Pfeiffer's character in the movie "Dangerous Minds"?

Last Answer : I haven’t seen the movie, but if part of the plot is showing how she adapts to the tough environment, she certainly has the acting skills to develop the character throughout the movie.

Do you know of any mind-boggling ways to influence others' minds?

Description : Do you know of any mind-boggling ways to influence others' minds?

Last Answer : No. Sounds like manipulation and I despise manipulative people.

Have we just lost our minds over cell phones?

Description : Have we just lost our minds over cell phones?

Last Answer : To avoid rushing out of the bathroom with my pants around my knees, I just bring my phone in with me. Yes, I’m a toilet texter. lol Im totally ok with my addiction.

Would you rather have the power to be invisible and teleport at will or the power to read minds and fly?

Description : Would you rather have the power to be invisible and teleport at will or the power to read minds and fly?

Last Answer : I would love any of these powers, but teleporting and being invisible would be the best. I would call myself Commander American Spirit, but most people would just call me Perv.

•Would you want to be able to read minds?

Description : •Would you want to be able to read minds?

Last Answer : Maybe if I could pick and choose. It might have made a lot of difference in certain choices I made.

If you had the power to read the minds of other people, would you use this power for good or evil?

Description : If you had the power to read the minds of other people, would you use this power for good or evil?

Last Answer : I would use it for teleportation. You tell me. Is that good or evil?

What if machines could read our minds?

Description : What if machines could read our minds?

Last Answer : That’s amazing….that there has already been minor success with this. The ripple effect that could occur…? Wow. Think of coma patients and their families, stroke patients, etc. Amazing world we live in. =)

Is there more to life than we can see with our natural eyes or know with our finite minds?

Description : Is there more to life than we can see with our natural eyes or know with our finite minds?

Last Answer : answer:I always like to think there are colours that we are not capable of seeing because of any biological restrictions. I mean if there are sounds that we can't hear because they are not ... feeling new emotions which we cannot imagine until we go throught them. So that's something similar.

What is changing our minds regarding Homosexual rights?

Description : What is changing our minds regarding Homosexual rights?

Last Answer : I think coming out is a big part of it. Also, like advertising, when people here something enough times it becomes normal. Cities continue to become more diverse around the country as people move ... , but my guess is that overall our numbers in America have declined when It comes to religiosity.

Why did scientists in 1944 change their minds regarding the existence of psi?

Description : Why did scientists in 1944 change their minds regarding the existence of psi?

Last Answer : More details, please. Which psi are you speaking of?

Do you think Juliette Lewis minds that she is always cast as a bit of a skank?

Description : Do you think Juliette Lewis minds that she is always cast as a bit of a skank?

Last Answer : Why do you (or should I) care?

Are flu shots really some kind of government or big pharma plot to control minds?

Description : Are flu shots really some kind of government or big pharma plot to control minds?

Last Answer : Yes..it is they have you now

You discover you can read minds and influence thought, do you use the ability?

Description : You discover you can read minds and influence thought, do you use the ability?

Last Answer : Yes…in a heart beat. I would walk right over and “wish” my next door neighbor set his own house on fire then hop in my car and pay a visit to my MIL next. I would be very busy that first full moon.

Is the Internet changing the way human minds think?

Description : Is the Internet changing the way human minds think?

Last Answer : No, I don’t think so. I usually use it for research.

Where do we go while our minds are dreaming?

Description : Where do we go while our minds are dreaming?

Last Answer : I have no idea, but welcome to ask-public..and I starred it because it was a very good question. :P

How can we fix our kids brains? Do media control their minds?

Description : How can we fix our kids brains? Do media control their minds?

Last Answer : What you need to do is teach kids critical thinking skills. How to analyze the information that comes into their purview and where it comes from.

Do we live in the physical world or the one we create in our minds?

Description : Do we live in the physical world or the one we create in our minds?

Last Answer : Since I did not imagine that tree limb that bashed me in the forehead when I wasn’t looking where I was going…I’m going to say we live in the physical world.

How can i see the season finale of criminal minds legally?

Description : How can i see the season finale of criminal minds legally?

Last Answer : The season finale is this Wednesday (5/26), so you haven’t missed it yet. If there are episodes you have missed that you want to see, they are available on iTunes.

Criminal Minds: Can they be rehabilitated?

Description : Criminal Minds: Can they be rehabilitated?

Last Answer : First of all criminal activity and criminal minded are both vague. Theres hundreds of things you can do to get locked up, not all make you a bad person. people are in prison right now for selling ... even needing to change at all. and always best not to be judgmental. just go with your instinct.

If you could read minds, would you use it against people?

Description : If you could read minds, would you use it against people?

Last Answer : I don’t think I’d use it at all. Imagining all of the negative things you could hear… No way, dude. I don’t think I’d ever leave my house.

Why the saying "great minds think alike"?

Description : Why the saying "great minds think alike"?

Last Answer : Well I’ll be damned, I think you’re right. Although, one could argue that truly great minds would be set on doing great things, and are thinking of ways to change the world for the better (or greatly for the worse); that would be a common way of thinking.

I need help from the devious minds of the collective for a prank!

Description : I need help from the devious minds of the collective for a prank!

Last Answer : You could prank her like the movie Juno, like the scene where Juno writes in chalk on the sidewalk to check the mailbox and when Bleek opens it, hundreds of boxes of tic tacs come cascading out ... you could write something on each ping-pong ball.. mwahahaha I need to find someone to prank now.

If you had the ability to read minds, would you be able to read the mind of someone that spoke a different language?

Description : If you had the ability to read minds, would you be able to read the mind of someone that spoke a different language?

Last Answer : This is purely hypothetical so without an real explanation to how we are reading people’s minds it’s not possible to give a definitive answer, though I don’t understand why not.

I need a very inspiration quote, that says, "More minds are smarter than one,"?

Description : I need a very inspiration quote, that says, "More minds are smarter than one,"?

Last Answer : My grandmother used to say, “Two heads are better than one, except when they’re both stupid.”