What does the government owe to the descendants of slaves?

1 Answer

Answer :

answer:First, we (the citizens of the US)owe them nothing. If anyone owes anything, it is the descendants of the slave owners (i.e. Thomas Jefferson’s great-great-great grandson). But even that is a hard case to make. Slavery was not unusual back then. WHat makes a 20th century person liable for 19th century culture? No reparations are due. And “we” in general have no obligation to “heal the wounds” of slavery. We are now siz or more generations past the time of “healing wounds”, Any slave who was alive in 1850 has been dead for 110 years. Their descendants – generation 6 or 7 – are owed nothing. Reparations and playing the ‘slavery’ card are just more of deciding, even volunteering – to be a victim. It’s a copout, and dishonest. At worst, it’s an excuse for failure.

Related questions

Description : In this Twilight Zone scenario where present-day white Americans wake up one day owning black slaves again, what do you think will happen?

Last Answer : Instant uprising?

Description : What is your opinion on the issue of reparations?

Last Answer : As I have stated before, we should offer a free ticket to their homeland to anyone who wants it.

Description : Should voluntary slavery be legalised?

Last Answer : Voluntary slavery already exists. It’s called volunteering and work experience. People choosing to work for nothing.

Description : How important is the issue of slavery to understanding racial attitudes in the United States?

Last Answer : Extremely. No other immigrant group has been brought here forcibly against their will and kept as slaves for hundreds of years.

Description : How does Santa Claus procure all the presents for the billions of children?

Last Answer : Santa Claus is actually the CEO of Amazon.

Description : If you are tattoed with bar code, are you saying "I have no value as a human being", "Human beings should not value themselves",or something else? If something else, what are you saying?

Last Answer : Personal preference. That’s what he/she likes?

Description : Would you, could you, work any harder if enslaved?

Last Answer : Probably. My “current job” is a Master’s thesis, and incidentally, I’m supposed to be working on it right now. I don’t think my slave keeper would let me procrastinate on the Fluthernets while there’s science to be done.

Description : What do you think of the idea of paying reparations to the descendants of slaves?

Last Answer : First - this will never pass. @LostInParadise: Are they going to give money to all slave descendants, including the wealthy? Besides not happening, the idea of what form reparations would take is ... just another injustice. Slavery is not history. It's the foundation that we all walk on today.

Description : Could the goverment retroactively pay slaves descendants for damages and for pay while working on the plantations and farms ?

Last Answer : Could the government? Sure, if they wanted to. But there are some pretty big issues to deal with. 1) where would the money come from? Why should taxpayers in 2018 pay for something that happened in the ... It would be a wild-assed guess at best. Bottom line - it's utterly unrealistic in every way.

Description : Whatever happened to the descendants from Mary and Joseph of biblical fame?

Last Answer : Wow, more humans than are estimated to have ever existed. That’s pretty impressive.

Description : Would you become more aware of your present actions and take good care of your character if you realized that it would affect your descendants further into the future?

Last Answer : answer:They likely were far more occupied by immediate practical concerns Maybe this was a decision they had to make to get a job, or legal papers, or welfare How often do you think of the effects ... ancestors if you go back far enough I don't know about my roots any earlier than 3 generations.

Description : What became of Lincoln's descendants?

Last Answer : Well, I can’t vouch for the reliability of the data, but here’s what the Wikipedia article has to say: the direct family line died out in 1985.

Description : How do I find the descendants (or family) of a US Navy sailor murdered by the Japanese in Cabanatuan, Phillipines POW camp?

Last Answer : answer:The first place to start would be to look up the ship he served on, if he was assigned to a ship. Just google the ship name (and number if you get it) and you'll probably find several ... and its new namesake, because a lot of names are recycled) and that might be enough to get you started.

Description : Is it reasonable for Palestine to expect all descendants of refugees to be allowed to migrate to Israel?

Last Answer : answer:I wish both sides nothing but success in this process and hope that a settlement can be reached for the worlds sake, for Isreal's sake, and for the palastinians sake. When I heard Netenyahu on ... that have the right to exsist but that would be Christlike and we wouldn't want that would we.

Description : I can be old or new, big or small, thick or thin. I contain information about all that is present in the entire world. I contain links to countless minds, worlds, adventures, universes, mysteries, ... wait for me enthusiastically and when done with me, waits for my descendants. What am I? -Riddles

Last Answer : Books! Come on, who doesn't love to curl up with a good book beside the fireplace?!

Description : what two groups of present-day vertebrates are the descendants of reptiles?

Last Answer : are alligator and snakes

Description : How are the descendants of the Prophet ?

Last Answer : The descendants of the Prophet are holy.

Description : How are the descendants of the prophets ?

Last Answer : The descendants of the prophets are holy.

Description : Santals No Of the nation Descendants ?

Last Answer : Santals Negrito Of the nation Descendants .

Description : Bengali No Of the nation Descendants ?

Last Answer : Bengalis Negrito, Nordic Of the nation Combined Descendants.

Description : In India Mongol Of the nation Descendants Who ?

Last Answer : Asami , Nepali , Bhutia , etc. Mongol Of the nation Descendants .

Description : South Of India Residents No Of the nation Descendants ?

Last Answer : South Of India Residents Dravidian Of the nation Descendants .

Description : Who is the main character in descendants?

Last Answer : Need answer

Description : Which people are the descendants of people who were brought to the Americas against their will?

Last Answer : Slaves were brought to the colonies.

Description : Who are the descendants of the ancient Romans?

Last Answer : From my understanding their was so much intermixing over the years it is hard to tell. Ethnic Romans were descendants of Indo-European Italic peoples and non-Indo-European Mediterranean peoples (myths ... and intermixed with the Gallo-Romans, Hispano-Romans, Roman-Romans, etc. producing the French

Description : In their fiduciary role, the professional accountants owe their primary loyalty to: a. The accounting profession b. The general public c. The client d. Government regulatory agencies

Last Answer : The client

Description : All those people who want to be heard: do you think you owe them a hearing?

Last Answer : Good question.

Description : What happens to people who owe money to drug dealers?

Last Answer : answer:Bad choices, no matter the age, can shorten the lifespan. Drug dealers are not likely to cut them loose. The bad debts with a dealer can become statistics. That is how the dealer collect from the ... I'm sorry you are in the position you are in and sorry for the person you are asking about.

Description : Do you think people with specific beliefs owe an explanation to others?

Last Answer : answer:If people present something as a fact/truth, I want evidence. If it’s a belief, I’m curious where it comes from but I don’t expect evidence. I may ask, but I won’t care as much as if someone’s trying to tell me something is true without providing evidence.

Description : When you buy a business is it typical for the loan to say if you are late 15 days you owe the entire balance in full?

Last Answer : answer:I know literally nothing about business law. Logically, I have to wonder how it would benefit the seller to sell their business, turn it over to whoever to do the gods know what to it, run it into ... the loan. They don't want it back after the buyer has messed with it; they want their money.

Description : How much do I owe?

Last Answer : answer:Nobody here can guess the amount of your payments, how often you make them, or whether your outstanding liability has been accruing interest over the years. We don't even know whether you' ... ve reached the right party, you should get the information quickly. Please let us know what happens.

Description : Confused: Why would I owe taxes?

Last Answer : answer:In my head, glancing at the EZ form and the tax table it looks like you owe $963. I could easily wrong. Hopefully someone who has a pen and paper can do a better calculation for you. I didn't ... it's that simple then it looks like you owe $388. Not sure? What number did you come up with?

Description : Do we all owe "Little Johnny" a collective apology?

Last Answer : answer:Why is Johnny come lately the undesired guest? It’s not Billy… not Jack, not Davey… It’s Johnny who is Rotten. … practically onomatopoeic.

Description : If a person you owe money to has died, and the deceased DID NOT have a will, do you still have to pay back the loan?

Last Answer : You still owe the estate. The court will decide who gets the money but the debt is property of the estate.

Description : What do we owe our friends?

Last Answer : answer:You don't want to get into enabling behavior of self-destructive acts. So you don't lend money to a friend who is an alcoholic or a drug addict, for example, even though you might freely lend money ... me , and that might be if he / she mistreated someone else that I knew about, or an animal.

Description : Can I immigrate to the UK if I owe student loans in the US?

Last Answer : What @FutureMemory is trying to say is that you need a WORK permit, you cannot just go to the UK to look for work. There about 2.5 million unemployed in the UK, looking for work.

Description : What happens to the things you owe money on when you are in jail?

Last Answer : Pretty sure you’re not given any sort of pass by your creditors if you end up in jail.

Description : If the person I owe money to dies, do I still owe the debt?

Last Answer : I think the money is still owed even after death. This person is probably the executor of the estate, to put a face on things.

Description : Do you owe favours or others owe you ?

Last Answer : I don’t owe nothing to nobody.

Description : Why do think some people still feel like white people owe black people something for what white people did to black peoples ancestors?

Last Answer : answer:No. The past is just that, the past, and true justice means paying once, and only once for a mistake. Paying for the ‘sins of the fathers’ is an archaic and outdated ‘moral’ code.

Description : Do you owe someone an apology?

Last Answer : I generally have to apologize to my wife several times a week. For some reason my ego forbids me from just a straightforward apology, so I just sort of beat around the bush, imply one, then insist it was as good as a real one. Since it isn’t as good as a real apology, this affects me adversely.

Description : Do you think you owe the world or do you believe that the world owes you?

Last Answer : Why would the world owe you? You are of the world…and by world, do you mean people- or the actual World? You consume so you owe to replace….

Description : Does my landlord owe me compensation?

Last Answer : I am not sure about his legal recourse, but renters insurance probably would have covered it.

Description : Just How Much Attention Do We Owe Our Dogs?

Last Answer : As long as you love them and they feel loved then that is all that matters, and I am sure they are loved.

Description : How do i Save money to Move out of My Parents' when i owe Loans and Car?

Last Answer : Could you not join a commune? or share an apartment. Over here we have what is termed granny cottage living, but it is an outhouse or guest-house made into a mini apartment. They are cheaper and ... garden. I guess we could all stay at home because of cost, you just have to jump, and fly!

Description : How do I find out exactly how much I will owe in taxes next year?

Last Answer : For me, when I claim 1, I end up with a sizable refund. I don't like getting a refund because that means the government withheld money that is rightfully mine that I could have invested ... they start asking questions and requiring documentation - this year I owe $240 so it worked out rather fine.

Description : Have you ever been in a bind between two people you owe your life to?

Last Answer : May you find some peace around your choices.

Description : Do children owe their parents anything?

Last Answer : More of that same unconditional love and acceptance of what their parents decide to do with their lives after the children are off on their own. In a perfect world the roles would gradually ... and crumble, their children will make sure they have adequate housing, food, clothing and medical care.

Description : Do parents owe their children anything?

Last Answer : You don’t have any children do you?

Description : How much do other countries owe the US?

Last Answer : I dont know, i sadily want to say zero, because of our national debt and it being so out of control. Stupid U.S.