I like a very brief description of the atmosphere, just so I know the general feel of the place (am I dressing up? Kids running around? etc.). Mostly for me it’s about the food though. The review should absolutely focus on the flavors of the food. Does it taste fresh? are they using locally sourced ingredients? do things taste like they’re from a can? how’s the sweetness, tartness, bitterness, saltines, heat, acidity, etc. Are there unusual pairings of ingredients that surprisingly work well together?