What do these experiments say about free will?

What do these experiments say about free will?
by

1 Answer

Answer :

To answer this, one really needs to define what constitutes “Free Will”. Theologically, Free Will means that a higher power or deity does not interfere with the actions of an entity. While the conscious mind may not have formulated a thought prior to an action, the entity, the individual and its nervous system, is still generating the impulses that cause the action. Because the entity is a whole being, it is (when not wired up by the good doctor) free to express its own volition.
by

Related questions

What do you think of these psych experiments?

Description : What do you think of these psych experiments?

Last Answer : Unethical.

How many people would say they are influenced by advertising?

Description : How many people would say they are influenced by advertising?

Last Answer : Interesting wording of your Q. I know a lot of who claim that they are not influenced by advertising at all, but I think they have missed the mark by a mile. We are influenced by everything. ... , a color combo, they got you. It takes an astonishingly aware person to resist altogether the influence.

What would you think of if your Sister says that you have “offended” her but won’t say why?

Description : What would you think of if your Sister says that you have “offended” her but won’t say why?

Last Answer : It sounds like she is ignoring your committment to your club and thinks you should be at the wedding. $12k is a pretty hefty wedding gift, so she sounds a little unreasonable. But the sibling dynamic is foreign to me, maybe call and talk it out?

Does your favorite extinct animal choice say something very basic about your personality?

Description : Does your favorite extinct animal choice say something very basic about your personality?

Last Answer : I always liked Steller’s sea cows (and their living cousins, manatees). And passenger pigeons – I always thought they were pretty cool.

Why is it that I have such intelligent conversations with myself in my head that actually make sense but am never able to say them out loud?

Description : Why is it that I have such intelligent conversations with myself in my head that actually make sense but am never able to say them out loud?

Last Answer : I'm not in your head to be able to comment with actual knowledge of your case, but a few things come to mind. 1) The mind has incredible capacity to do huge amounts of complex parallel processing with ... by the time you got them into words). 5) Probably other things. :-) 6) Welcome to Fluther!

Are the things people routinely say to lessen grief actually making it worse?

Description : Are the things people routinely say to lessen grief actually making it worse?

Last Answer : I agree with you. Saying things like “She’s in a better place now” presupposes that the mourner believes in an after-life which may or may not be true. I think quiet empathy without pushing one’s beliefs is much more helpful.

Does it make sense to say teens who don't do the following are more mature?

Description : Does it make sense to say teens who don't do the following are more mature?

Last Answer : By the way, inspite of the “Does it make sense… part of my OP, it doesn’t mean I think it doesn’t make sense.

Should I say something or should I just leave the group?

Description : Should I say something or should I just leave the group?

Last Answer : In this case, your impatience is a response to someone else not having respect for the dignity and worth of everyone else in the group (including you). And criticism, when aimed at improving someone's ... it is the act of a friend. An enemy would just leave someone to their ignorance and vice.

Do you often say things you later on wish you hadn't?

Description : Do you often say things you later on wish you hadn't?

Last Answer : Not “often.” It’s a painful lesson to learn, and I’ve learned it.

What does it mean when scientists say parts of your brain are "closed"?

Description : What does it mean when scientists say parts of your brain are "closed"?

Last Answer : answer:Much of learning is from building neural pathways in the brain to expedite processing. That is much more rapid when we are younger, and makes learning much faster. To use an analogy to a ... still has room, but finding fresh spaces on the disk to write information to becomes more difficult.

Does voice of a person say anything to you about his/her personality?

Description : Does voice of a person say anything to you about his/her personality?

Last Answer : Nope

Why would your friend secretly write down things you say?

Description : Why would your friend secretly write down things you say?

Last Answer : answer:Is this hypothetical or are you describing a real-life scenario? In either case. how would you know if someone is doing that if he is writing secretly? In an earlier question you mentioned that you ... at the moment. If this person is bugging you, carry on with the plan of making new friends.

When we are very reactive to certain people, does it say more about us or them?

Description : When we are very reactive to certain people, does it say more about us or them?

Last Answer : I agree, the deeper the wound the harder to recover, if at all. When we have these issues, obviously you have to look at yourself. We must have self esteem and insecurity issues to let these people hurt ... seem to be insensitive souls with no love in their hearts. I don't want to be like that.

What has your kid done lately that made you say - "Yup, that's my kid?"?

Description : What has your kid done lately that made you say - "Yup, that's my kid?"?

Last Answer : I don’t have any kids, but my brother and I share a lot of traits. I was helping one of his kids fill out a FASFA and as I started writing stuff out she laughed and said “He writes just like Daddy.” We both have lousy handwriting. Or as my stepfather says, You plant a potato you get a potato.

What tells you more about a persons motivations: what they say they believe or how they behave?

Description : What tells you more about a persons motivations: what they say they believe or how they behave?

Last Answer : answer:How they behave, duh! For example, a typical corporate CEO will give a speech, ”...we care about the quality of life of all people, and give generously to the United Way…” and then lay off thousands of employees so they add another Lamborghini to their collection.

Can a person truly not care what an entire society has to say?

Description : Can a person truly not care what an entire society has to say?

Last Answer : People are sensitive to ostracization. That’s why it works. We are social animals.

You end up handcuffed together with someone. Using ONLY 3 words what would you say?

Description : You end up handcuffed together with someone. Using ONLY 3 words what would you say?

Last Answer : Megan Fox. “Need to pee?”

Why do people say they are open-minded?

Description : Why do people say they are open-minded?

Last Answer : It’s just a saying like “I’m outgoing”. It’s up to you to decide who really is open minded, and it also depends on what you want them to be open minded about. If you’re trying to get people to see the other side to ruthlessly murdering kittens, they’re not going to be open minded.

What do you think you are saying when you say "I'm bored"?

Description : What do you think you are saying when you say "I'm bored"?

Last Answer : I don’t know this as I am very seldom (if ever) bored.

Do you find that people who tend to boast about their accomplishments and continually say how wonderful they are, are overcompensating? That they're lacking in some other area?

Description : Do you find that people who tend to boast about their accomplishments and continually say how wonderful they are, are overcompensating? That they're lacking in some other area?

Last Answer : answer:Usually, but not necessarily the rule. Depends on how the boasting is being applied. And usually it is an insecurity of some sort.

What do you say to a seven and a half year old when they ask you why their parents fight?

Description : What do you say to a seven and a half year old when they ask you why their parents fight?

Last Answer : “some people love each other but have a hard time getting along. And it is between Mom and Dad, and not about you. They each love you in their own way.”

What am I supposed to say?

Description : What am I supposed to say?

Last Answer : I don't know what a normal person would say either, but I think in sentiment they would tend to agree with you. If my friend said that to me, I would respond with something like this: It ... while putting it in a way that might actually help the other person to see the matter in different terms.

What do we mean when we say "me"? A thought experiment.

Description : What do we mean when we say "me"? A thought experiment.

Last Answer : What does this have to do with the word ‘me’?

WHY do people refuse to say excuse me and then get annoyed with you for not moving...

Description : WHY do people refuse to say excuse me and then get annoyed with you for not moving...

Last Answer : I think the overall reason is a feeling of self-importance. Who am I, that I have to tell you what I'm doing? You should be moving for me! You are less important than I am, so step ... People are just plain rude these days. This is the same reason no one uses indicators to change lanes anymore.

Can I use Arduino for scientific experiments?

Description : Can I use Arduino for scientific experiments?

Last Answer : Yes, Arduino can be used for scientific experiments by interfacing with various sensors, data loggers, and other components to collect and analyze data in a wide range of scientific fields.

Which fiction books talk a lot about thought experiments?

Description : Which fiction books talk a lot about thought experiments?

Last Answer : The one that immediately comes to mind is Lewis Carroll s novels like Alice in Wonderland. The guy was an academic and logician and made significant scholarly contributions to ... whimsical, they are filled with puzzles, logical absurdities, and other thought experiment-related inclusions.

Can you name some social engineering experiments that worked?

Description : Can you name some social engineering experiments that worked?

Last Answer : Hawthorne effect studied this in college.

What are some long, tedious chemistry lab experiments you had to do for freshman year of college?

Description : What are some long, tedious chemistry lab experiments you had to do for freshman year of college?

Last Answer : Can you go and ask the Proff or TA for ideas? Or else ask for the various class syllabus outlines. Question- if you make it too technical, as with later coursework, you may be hurting ... having something go south via differentials in the chemicals used, shipment differences, or the like. Good luck.

Will the subjects of psychological experiments eventually try to second guess what is going on?

Description : Will the subjects of psychological experiments eventually try to second guess what is going on?

Last Answer : I think that would explain lots of my life.

What are the implications of these educational experiments?

Description : What are the implications of these educational experiments?

Last Answer : answer:I home school and I have seen a marked positive difference in how much my kids learn and seek out themselves when I stand back, or, out of the way. School is a different beast though. Very mythological.

Does anyone have any ideas for experiments I can do involving Food Chemistry (proteins, carbs, fats)?

Description : Does anyone have any ideas for experiments I can do involving Food Chemistry (proteins, carbs, fats)?

Last Answer : Brewing beer

Why don't all these factors affect experiments?

Description : Why don't all these factors affect experiments?

Last Answer : answer:The effect of micro-organism DNA in a regular DNA sample would be minute, if not non-existent. The millions of DNA that are fed through the system are what give you your results ... microscope that allows you to see the individual neurons, they're probably far out-numbering the contaminants.

What are some experiments or research we could do that would yield informative and useful results, but may be quite unethical?

Description : What are some experiments or research we could do that would yield informative and useful results, but may be quite unethical?

Last Answer : Send all the world’s top athletes (track & field) to Afghanistan & see if they qualify for the next Paralympics? Ouch, that stings a little!

What chemistry experiments did you do in school ?

Description : What chemistry experiments did you do in school ?

Last Answer : answer:The ones I remember best are the ones we were not supposed to do. I have no idea how, but we produced a green flame in one of our spontaneous experiments. I have no idea what all we ... never be added to a gallon of distilled water. Even if you put it in a timed release capsule first.

What would be plausible control variables for these experiments?

Description : What would be plausible control variables for these experiments?

Last Answer : I’d go with an orthogonal Taguchi array. See Taguchi method It will tell you which factor is dominant.

Cool, safe science experiments?

Description : Cool, safe science experiments?

Last Answer : Take a look at this lecture at about 20 minutes in to the lecture, they use gyroscopic forces to “defy gravity”. quite cool stuff indeed.

I was doing some private experiments with the Large Hadron Collider in my spare time and accidentally created a singularity. Now it's getting bigger. What are the specific dangers of an enlarging singularity?

Description : I was doing some private experiments with the Large Hadron Collider in my spare time and accidentally created a singularity. Now it's getting bigger. What are the specific dangers of an enlarging singularity?

Last Answer : lol nahhhhh its just a hole.

Are there any genetics experiments that prove evolution?

Description : Are there any genetics experiments that prove evolution?

Last Answer : If you Google “maternal mitochondria”, you’ll find study after study after study.

What were some of the scariest scientific experiments that people don't know about?

Description : What were some of the scariest scientific experiments that people don't know about?

Last Answer : My birth.

as a result of his puzzle box experiments, edward l. thorndike proposed the -General Knowledge

Description : as a result of his puzzle box experiments, edward l. thorndike proposed the -General Knowledge

Last Answer : As a result of his puzzle box experiments, Edward L. Thorndike proposed the law of effect.

Whose experiments proved that the speed of light was always the same? -Do You Know?

Description : Whose experiments proved that the speed of light was always the same? -Do You Know?

Last Answer : answer:

Who was the author of the book 'My Experiments with Truth'? -General Knowledge

Description : Who was the author of the book 'My Experiments with Truth'? -General Knowledge

Last Answer : Mahatma Gandhi

In which generation were recessive traits hidden in all the plants in Mendel’s experiments?

Description : In which generation were recessive traits hidden in all the plants in Mendel’s experiments?

Last Answer : f2 generation

What was the purpose of Mendel’s experiments with dihybrid crosses?

Description : What was the purpose of Mendel’s experiments with dihybrid crosses?

Last Answer : He wanted to determine if traits affected each other, andconcluded (based on his observations) that they did not.+ To find out if traits could affect the inheritance of othertraits.to determine if traits affected each other

How did Mendel make the F1 generation for his experiments?

Description : How did Mendel make the F1 generation for his experiments?

Last Answer : he crossed two pure lines

Who proved the religion of light waves through experiments ?

Description : Who proved the religion of light waves through experiments ?

Last Answer : Young proved.

Which one of the following experiments suggests that simplest living organisms could not have originated spontaneously from non-living matter

Description : Which one of the following experiments suggests that simplest living organisms could not have originated spontaneously from non-living matter

Last Answer : Which one of the following experiments suggests that simplest living organisms could not have ... . Microbes appeared from unsterilized organic matter

Taylor conducted the experiments to provide semiconcervative mode of chromosome replication on

Description : Taylor conducted the experiments to provide semiconcervative mode of chromosome replication on

Last Answer : Taylor conducted the experiments to provide semiconcervative mode of chromosome replication on A. Drosophila ... coli C. Vinca rosea D. Vicia faba

i. List out various real-life examples of Charles’ law. ii. Refer and watch Charles’ law experiments.

Description : i. List out various real-life examples of Charles’ law. ii. Refer and watch Charles’ law experiments.

Last Answer : i. List out various real-life examples of Charles’ law. ii. Refer and watch Charles’ law experiments.

In which generation were recessive traits hidden in all the plants in Mendel and his experiments?

Description : In which generation were recessive traits hidden in all the plants in Mendel and his experiments?

Last Answer : Need answer