If spiritual healing is false, how come stress is related to many illnesses?

1 Answer

Answer :

I think Dawkins is a smart guy, but he is so devoted to science that he fails to identify those areas of science that aren’t set in stone. For instance, there have been many, many studies on the mind’s ability to control things in the body. Placebo effects are one example, controlling allergic responses is another. But science doesn’t fully understand how that happens. Stress’ impact on a person’s health is another example. Science recognizes the statistical impact…high stress people frequently have a litany of health issues….but they don’t fully understand why mental or emotional stress impact a person’s physical health. Spiritual healing is nothing more than a way to try triggering these mental conditions that might help your body heal itself. It isn’t scientific and it is a shot in the dark, but that is what it is trying to do. Now rain triggering chronic pains may have a physical aspect that is at play. Rain happens when barometric pressure drops. You are now changing a physical parameter on the body. Same with certain “healing waters”. You are either soaking in a liquid that is at a different temperature or consuming a liquid that has certain chemical properties that may be beneficial for some physiological issues.

Related questions

Description : Is belief in a "higher power" a "spiritual strength"?

Last Answer : Regardless of the existence of a deity, I think that belief makes people stronger. It’s not a “reliance”.. more like a foundation.

Description : How would one begin to form a non-profit spiritual organization eligible for grants and government assistance?

Last Answer : Step 1: Get people behind you who will support you and maybe even finance you.

Description : Did you ever have a spiritual experience that changed your life?

Last Answer : Yes.Amazing.I wish I could tell you about it but I cant.:)

Description : What's your spiritual practice?

Last Answer : sleeping…

Description : Does betrayal come from above?

Last Answer : answer:Welcome! No. God is in the mind.

Description : When they say there is no tomorrow as a fact, aren't they wrong?

Last Answer : Tomorrow does not exist, because nobody will ever occupy it. Now exists because people, animals, and all our activities are occupying it. The past exists because all of it has been occupied. Tomorrow can be thought of, and referenced, but it is in fact, a myth.

Description : What is your opinion on astral projection?

Last Answer : People have all kinds of ways of pulling stunts like this.

Description : What is your opinion of the concept of numerology?

Last Answer : Big. Loud. Fart.

Description : Where does the belief in karma originate from?

Last Answer : I always think Buddism was the creator of such. Karma was the centre of their belief anyway. Or did they adapt it from another belief system?

Description : What subject/struggles touches most of us?

Last Answer : Climate change, overpopulation, water shortages, air and water pollution, the biological threat from sickness, disease, and declining efficiency of antibiotics.

Description : Why does the etheric body awaken spontaneously suddenly?

Last Answer : answer:As one evolves their consciousness, they become aware of spiritual dimensions never known before. While this new experience attracts one's attention, it is as important as noting a mile marker ... 's self will create eddies in this energy that becomes a source for suffering from illusions.

Description : Is there a connection between my readings and my life ?

Last Answer : answer:I had a dream last night that I was in a school, peer-editing about a hundred creative writing documents. When I woke up, I still felt tired, like I had spent the whole night working instead of ... got a good solid sleep. What exactly is this energy you're feeling ? What is producing it?

Description : What do you see when your third eye is open?

Last Answer : There is no such thing.

Description : Why do you think I have to prepare myself mentally for a new day before it begins?

Last Answer : I work from home and could be ready to start in half an hour but I always allow an hour at least just to get myself ‘into the zone’. I need to prepare myself for the day ahead I can’t just rush into it.

Description : Is there a strong or weak connection between spirituality and organization?

Last Answer : I think the two are totally unconnected.

Description : Is this statement a sign of insanity, spirituality, drugs or what?

Last Answer : answer:I would say it indicates magical thinking. Magical thinking is usually the result of living in a very chaotic and unpredictable world. Such a perception of the world can come from being abused in childhood. ... , then she is not so far off. Her flute playing did cause the house to burn down.

Description : Who are you with when you die?

Last Answer : Both. Heaven is what you make of it and everyone is peaceable.

Description : I know that some of you don't believe in the afterlife (or that the soul lives on when we die). But, for those that do? What happened to make you believe?

Last Answer : No. When I die I start life over again in the past, because I refuse to cross over.

Description : Do you really believe in Gemstones and Birth Stones? How do they bring blessing to us?

Last Answer : I do not.

Description : What is Your View on Pendulums?

Last Answer : I loved the one at the science museum when I was a kid. The tip moved through sand and the pendulum itself was huge.

Description : If you have a personal path, how do you stay on it?

Last Answer : I wander on and off it and all around it.

Description : For those of you who believe in the existance of souls & possibly reincarnation: Do souls have a gender?

Last Answer : Only post if you agree with me and the rest of you are full of bullshit. Nice.

Description : Do you read tarot cards?

Last Answer : No. I do like all the funky drawings on them though.

Description : What do you do to make yourself feel better?

Last Answer : I just got a comment from a friend I just reconnected with on Facebook. She told me that reading that I was working on a Masters degree in Atmospheric Science was the best thing she'd read in a long ... as it has been, and it continues to be, I followed my dreams, and they are slowly coming true.

Description : How can you explain infinity to a layman?

Last Answer : Have them point the reflective surface of a mirror toward the reflective surface of another mirror.

Description : Is there a difference between organized religions and Spirituality per se?

Last Answer : Organized religions often have rites that are reserved for a priesthood of some sort or other. Organized religions offer community. My problem with most organized religions practiced today is their patriarchal nature and the fact that most of them believe themselves to be the “one, true way.”

Description : In order to fully understand the I Ching does it help for one to be a little off their rocker?

Last Answer : To understand I Ching one must have an open mind. Mental instability is not an attribute that will help you understand.

Description : Where can I find a good site/books for the human chakra system?

Last Answer : Are you familiar with a site called Goodreads? It’s amazing! I just did a quick search with the word “chakra” and here’s what came up.

Description : What do you have faith in?

Last Answer : Myself.

Description : Can we learn from the handicapped, disabled & Special needs?

Last Answer : I would say yes. It is possible to learn from anyone, anywhere; especially the sick, handicapped, and elderly. I find that these people have more innocence and a better understanding of the ... because of their innocence. Or they are naturally gifted with big hearts that share love and compassion.

Description : Anyone had any experience with sungazing?

Last Answer : Looks like superstition to me. I don’t have seasonal affective disorder

Description : Are you ready to wake up? Do you consider yourself awake? Please explain how you are striving to find/connect with your higher self.

Last Answer : answer:I am awake, but I had to kill myself first. Not physically. My "self" had to be buried, that my new "self" might. And here it comes. The line you all have been dreading. I became "awake ... this is possible and why it was designed from the beginning. http://www.gnpcb.org/esv/mobile/?q=John 1

Description : Have you ever had an epiphany that led you towards or turned you away from spirituality?

Last Answer : Yes. But I was on drugs when it happened. Does that count?

Description : Do you think labelling psychological illnesses and disorders helps or hinders healing and recovery?

Last Answer : Things need labels and names. What would we call…everything? I think we could narrow this down and tackle the problem of people being misinformed about many things in general. Kate the Great asked a question similar to this about mental illness.

Description : What happens in spiritual healing classes?

Last Answer : It is well known that the mind can be an amazing healer. Many people think that time they spend in meditation improves their mental health, but this is not always the case. Many ... Arhanta yoga meditation course and start learning from experts. Visit the official website and know more details

Description : How do they determine secondhand smoke related illnesses?

Last Answer : They didn’t, it is just assumed and cannot be proven.

Description : Will spinning (indoor biking) aggravate, or delay the healing of, tibial stress fractures?

Last Answer : I should think it would depend on how hard you spin. Most exercises while you have a broken bone should be gentle, if you are allowed to do anything at all. In many cases, someone with a ... need to be done? Will internal fixation be required? What are the risks and complications of surgery?

Description : Choose the correct statement about H2 receptor blockers: A. They are the most efficacious drugs in inhibiting gastric acid secretion B. They cause fastest healing of duodenal ulcers C. They prevent stress ulcers in the stomach D. They afford most prompt relief of ulcer pain

Last Answer : C. They prevent stress ulcers in the stomach

Description : I have a sore throat , should I use nebanal powder ? My penis was sore ,,,, then I started using nebanal powder there ,,, !! Cos used to come out from the first wound, then it stopped because of ... it possible for me to get better ? Or should I change ? And what are the symptoms of wound healing ?

Last Answer : Yes, you can apply this powder on a regular basis. I hope you will find a solution. And do not water or soak the wound. Keep the wound dry and clean. If necessary, clean it with lukewarm ... day and give this nebanal powder. And take antibiotics as soon as possible with the advice of a doctor.

Description : What makes terminal illnesses like AIDS and terminal cancer incurable?

Last Answer : Can’t fix broke !! Doctors cannot fix terminal diseases !

Description : Are there any mental or physical illnesses that can be cured with wining big on the lotto?

Last Answer : The short answer is no. Money doesn’t cure illnesses. The long answer is that you answered in the negative by dreaming of a diet detrimental to your health along with an avoidance of exercise.

Description : Are there any mental or physical illnesses that can be caused or made worse with winning big on the lotto?

Last Answer : You can have these without having a lot of money as well so why not have the money instead? Spending too much money on lotto hoping that you’ll win jackpot won’t be a good idea though!!

Description : Do fish get mental illnesses?

Last Answer : Well. That’s why they call them fighting fish. They are highly territorial. It’s their instinct. That being said, many are probably inbred, in pet stores. All kinds of problems could sprout from that…

Description : Do you think paranoia and other mental illnesses help people survive extreme circumstances?

Last Answer : answer:I would say mental illness is usually caused by traumatic events that don't get processed and healed. People definitely shut down their emotional reactions at the time of trauma in order to survive them ... that matters and goes on to form patterns around it for the rest of the person's life.

Description : Should doctors add video game addiction to the medical encyclopedia of mental illnesses?

Last Answer : I’d say the more likely scenario is that your addictions listed here are rather a symptom of some other underlying mental illness.

Description : What is the general view of society about people with mental illnesses and/or disabilities?

Last Answer : I think it’s very different. It’s hard to have for example a child with mental illnesses. And I think that even if many people support this human and even if there is more acception then in earlier times it is really hard. There are still many people that do not accept people who are different.

Description : Final miserable question: Why do we bother to get treatment for terminal illnesses when our final destination is death anyway?

Last Answer : answer:Most terminal illnesses involve a lot of pain. Most of the treatments are to abate the pain. Would you prefer that we simply let someone who has a terminal illness and is gasping to breathe just ... misery so I'm going to take your word for it. Have you considered treatment for depression?

Description : Should people with personality disorders be given the same consideration as those with mental illnesses?

Last Answer : Personality disorders are a sub-category of mental illness. So I don’t quite understand; this is like saying “Should oranges be treated the same as fruit?”

Description : Should people with mental illnesses be given the same (or situationally comparable) consideration as the physically-handicapped?

Last Answer : answer:I think that society gives sufficient empathy for those impacted with severe mental illness who absolutely cannot garner a better standard of life through treatments available the same way ... become more exaggerated. Of course that is my personal opinion derived from personal experiences.

Description : Have you ever been plagued by multiple injuries/illnesses at one time?

Last Answer : Oh no…poor you, I hope you start to feel better soon and your luck starts to change! My daughter had her arm n plaster and chicken pox at the same time…she was only 3, and it was really itchy, poor thing :(