Do humans have "free will" at all or is the Universe (including human action/choices) entirely deterministic?

Do humans have "free will" at all or is the Universe (including human action/choices) entirely deterministic?
by

1 Answer

Answer :

No. Our decisions are all a product of something. There’s nothing “free” about our “will”. We have certain dispositions as biological organisms, and the culture imposes certain values on us.
by

Related questions

How much do experts understand about the nature of instinct in animals and in humans?

Description : How much do experts understand about the nature of instinct in animals and in humans?

Last Answer : answer:Fascinating topic and I have no learned answers for most of it except possibly: Last question-How can I get that damn song out of my head now?? You can replace it with something else ... vacuum into which it can easily slide back in. Looking forward to others' insights on the main topic!

Why would a herd of deer cross a major highway during rush hour?

Description : Why would a herd of deer cross a major highway during rush hour?

Last Answer : Well, herds of deer tend not to wear wristwatches, os they may not have known it was rush hour. Herds are herds - and deer are not particularly smart animals. They have a leader, and the others just follow. ... a large object is a tree or rock - neither of them move. Cars don't fit their world view.

How can I get my horse to drink water in the pasture?

Description : How can I get my horse to drink water in the pasture?

Last Answer : My dogs would always eat or drink out of my hands, even when they turned their noses up at everything else. My male dogs last meal was eaten completely off of my hand. He wouldn’t touch the food otherwise. He died the next morning. Sorry, a little morbid, but try the hand thing.

Can a quadruped (such as a dog) jog in place or will they always move forward?

Description : Can a quadruped (such as a dog) jog in place or will they always move forward?

Last Answer : Springer spaniels don’t exactly jog but they certainly spring in place, using lots of energy and going absolutely nowhere but up and down.

What would explain this odd animal behavior?

Description : What would explain this odd animal behavior?

Last Answer : There may have been a hawk or some other type of predator that you weren’t able to see. Many species will have a sentinel that calls an alarm, as well as an “all clear”. (Hoofbeats and zebras, you know.)

Blackbirds death revisited. Does the fireworks explanation make sense?

Description : Blackbirds death revisited. Does the fireworks explanation make sense?

Last Answer : I found this article. 2 years in a row seems mighty coincidental, that is, unless someone deliberately set off fireworks in a roost as it says happened here. http://www.disclose.tv/forum/animal-deaths-2012-t65145.html Supposedly reported on ABC. Sick people.

Why is my guinea pig doing this?

Description : Why is my guinea pig doing this?

Last Answer : Most animals are guided by smell. My guess is that something didn’t smell “right” to your guinea pig. Can you remove the stuffing from the old toy and wash the skin in a mild detergent with no scent? It might retain enough of the old smell that your pet will want to go back to its old habits.

How would you rate this animal video's shock value?

Description : How would you rate this animal video's shock value?

Last Answer : answer:I’ve seen Battle at Kruger many times. I even burned it to a dvd so I can watch it on my television. It’s damn incredible :) I’m obsessed with lions, so it’s especially fascinating to me.

Do female animals know when they are pregnant?

Description : Do female animals know when they are pregnant?

Last Answer : My mother in law said she had a “sense”. I say she had none XD I really don’t know what they know…hmmm…abstract thought in animals….;)

How do I get my pug dog to stop hiking his leg inside?

Description : How do I get my pug dog to stop hiking his leg inside?

Last Answer : answer:Is he neutered? Neutering will help with territory marking. Is he well-exercised? Pugs don't need really long walks, but regular outside play will help stop the in-house peeing. Crate training also works ... consider having the dog re-homed. Outside is NOT a safe option for a dog like a Pug.

The German octopus, the cross-eyed possum - do you think there's anything to animals picking winners?

Description : The German octopus, the cross-eyed possum - do you think there's anything to animals picking winners?

Last Answer : answer:Nothing at all. Paul probably just recognized that Spain was the best team and that they were going to win. viva espana ~

Why do birds always nest in my garage?

Description : Why do birds always nest in my garage?

Last Answer : answer:Oh, I would love to have swallows! Yes, the same birds do come back year after year. And their offspring learn the location and return, too. You may not like the mess, but keep in mind that a single Barn Swallow can consume 60 insects per hour or a whopping 850 per day

How smart are rats?

Description : How smart are rats?

Last Answer : very smart

Why doesn't my bunny hop?

Description : Why doesn't my bunny hop?

Last Answer : He's a baby. Keep an eye on him though. I rescued a kitten once who had a birth defect that left him with two totally crippled back legs. He was never able to walk and I had to have him put down. ... are you sure the mother isn't around any more? It might be too late anyway. Take good care of him.

Why does my siamese do this?

Description : Why does my siamese do this?

Last Answer : He’s merely being a cat. Feline behavior encompasses a wide array of affection shown, you merely have a very affectionate cat. Siamese are known for being very attached to their people. If this is a change in behavior, has something changed in his environment?

Why aren't cartoon animals anatomically correct?

Description : Why aren't cartoon animals anatomically correct?

Last Answer : I would go with the last thing you said. Also no one wants to look at Scooby Doo’s balls.

Do chimps suffer post tramtic stres disorder?

Description : Do chimps suffer post tramtic stres disorder?

Last Answer : My friend, this is the first hit when you Google your exact question (and correct the two typos): Chimpanzees used for medical testing show signs of torture. You might want to do some basic research before asking questions like these. Google is your friend.

Do sperm whales from Greece migrate between boston and bermuda?

Description : Do sperm whales from Greece migrate between boston and bermuda?

Last Answer : Not quite sure what you’re asking, but here goes: Sperm Whales are active in all oceans, and the Mediterranean sea. So it is possible for you to have seen a sperm whale in Greece, Boston, Bermuda, as well as California and the Philippines. (Source: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Sperm_whale )

Do bull sharks congragate?

Description : Do bull sharks congragate?

Last Answer : http://www.magazine.noaa.gov/stories/mag36.htm

What would it take for you to accept ours as a deterministic universe and reject the notion of free will?

Description : What would it take for you to accept ours as a deterministic universe and reject the notion of free will?

Last Answer : I will never accept our actions as predetermined. I can determine my own actions at any time. It’s nonsensical to assume that some supreme being is dictating my writing this response right now, only because I can’t prove that a supreme being isn’t dictating my current actions.

A small indoor greenhouse (herbarium) is made entirely of glass panes (including base) held together with tape. It is 30cm long, 25 cm wide and 25 cm high. -Maths 9th

Description : A small indoor greenhouse (herbarium) is made entirely of glass panes (including base) held together with tape. It is 30cm long, 25 cm wide and 25 cm high. -Maths 9th

Last Answer : Length of greenhouse, say l = 30cm Breadth of greenhouse, say b = 25 cm Height of greenhouse, say h = 25 cm (i) Total surface area of greenhouse = Area of the glass = 2[lb+lh+bh] = [2(30 ... (30+25+25)] (after substituting the values) = 320 Therefore, 320 cm tape is required for all the 12 edges.

Is human thought deterministic or probabilistic?

Description : Is human thought deterministic or probabilistic?

Last Answer : answer:False dichotomy. Even if a series of events is probabilistic, there's still no room for agency' under the current understanding of Physics (yes; capital P). Therefore, the problem of ... by invoking quantum theory. We're still just along for the ride, except the ride is unpredictable.

Given the following two statements: A. L = {w|na(w) = nb(w)} is deterministic context free language, but not linear B. L = {an bn} U {an b2n} is linear, but not deterministic context free language. Which of the following options is correct? (1) Both (A) and (B) are false. (2) Both (A) and (B) are true. (3) (A) is true, (B) is false. (4) (A) is false, (B) is true.

Description : Given the following two statements: A. L = {w|na(w) = nb(w)} is deterministic context free language, but not linear B. L = {an bn} U {an b2n} is linear, but not deterministic context free language. Which of the following ... are true. (3) (A) is true, (B) is false. (4) (A) is false, (B) is true.

Last Answer : Both (A) and (B) are true. 

Ramesh is a student of standard X. He organized many activities in his school to convey the students about the various advantages and disadvantages of using renewable and non-renewable sources of energy. Many students of the school took part and concluded about the best choices of energy sources on this basis. Answer the following questions: (i) What activities Ramesh might have had assigned for the students? (ii) Name any two renewable sources of energy. (in) Which two values are reflected in Ramesh’s thought and action? -Science

Description : Ramesh is a student of standard X. He organized many activities in his school to convey the students about the various advantages and disadvantages of using renewable and non-renewable sources of energy. Many ... of energy. (in) Which two values are reflected in Ramesh's thought and action? -Science

Last Answer : (i) Activities that Ramesh have had assigned for the students are: (a) Hands on projects related to renewable and non-renewable sources of energy. (b) Photograph exhibitions on the topic ... of renewable source of energy. Ramesh’s action: Concern for community advantage and good management.

In the Exploring Strategy Model, what Heading is used to cover Environment, Capability, Goals and Culture ? A. Strategic Planning B. Strategic Choices C. Strategy in Action D. Strategic Position

Description : In the Exploring Strategy Model, what Heading is used to cover Environment, Capability, Goals and Culture ? A. Strategic Planning B. Strategic Choices C. Strategy in Action D. Strategic Position

Last Answer : Strategic Position

In a game, the alternatives or courses of action available to each player are called _____ a. Options b. Choices c. Actions d. strategies

Description : In a game, the alternatives or courses of action available to each player are called _____ a. Options b. Choices c. Actions d. strategies

Last Answer : d. strategies

1. What is the range of Prithvi III, the naval version of Prithvi ? 2. What is the oxidation number and covalency-of sulphur in S8? 3. What is the life of RBC in human blood? 4. The emission of which greenhouse gase of which entirely anthropogenic? 5. Who sent Hienu-Tsang as an envoy to Harsha’s’ court?

Description : 1. What is the range of Prithvi III, the naval version of Prithvi ? 2. What is the oxidation number and covalency-of sulphur in S8? 3. What is the life of RBC in human blood? 4. ... What is the approximate diameter of the earth? 20. Which is the source of information about early Vedic period?

Last Answer : Answer : 1. 250 km-300 km 2. 0, 2 3. 120 days 4. Chlorofluorocarbons 5. Tai Tsung 6. Consolidated Fund of India 7. Increase in prices 8. Trishul 9. Ecotone 10. Anantvarman 11. Real, inverted and magnified ... dark plain on the moon 15. Lion 16. May 1 17. Money 18. Poison 19. 12,800 Km 20. Rigveda 

How do humans use the sea as a resource including for fishing and tourism?

Description : How do humans use the sea as a resource including for fishing and tourism?

Last Answer : Feel Free to Answer

Columns of given length, cross-section and material have different values of buckling loads for different end conditions. The strongest column is one whose (A) One end is fixed and other end is hinged (B) Both ends are hinged or pin jointed (C) One end is fixed and the other end entirely free (D) Both the ends are fixed

Description : Columns of given length, cross-section and material have different values of buckling loads for different end conditions. The strongest column is one whose (A) One end is fixed and other end is hinged (B) Both ... (C) One end is fixed and the other end entirely free (D) Both the ends are fixed

Last Answer : (D) Both the ends are fixed

Columns of given length, cross-section and material have different values of buckling loads for different end conditions. The strongest column is one whose (a) One end is fixed and other end is hinged (b) Both ends are hinged or pin jointed (c) One end is fixed and the other end entirely free (d) Both the ends are fixed

Description : Columns of given length, cross-section and material have different values of buckling loads for different end conditions. The strongest column is one whose (a) One end is fixed and other end is hinged (b) ... (c) One end is fixed and the other end entirely free (d) Both the ends are fixed

Last Answer : (d) Both the ends are fixed

Could there be a parallel universe where intelligent animals are at the top of the food chain and eat humans on Thanksgiving?

Description : Could there be a parallel universe where intelligent animals are at the top of the food chain and eat humans on Thanksgiving?

Last Answer : Sure there could. There isn’t but there could.

In a universe possibly created by accident/chance, how possible is it that each human's life is predetermined?

Description : In a universe possibly created by accident/chance, how possible is it that each human's life is predetermined?

Last Answer : My thought is that Life is an absolute crapshoot. We do what we do and then deal with whatever that deals us.

Is Imagination one of the most important aspects of the way humans have developed such high understanding and knowledge of the universe and the world around us?

Description : Is Imagination one of the most important aspects of the way humans have developed such high understanding and knowledge of the universe and the world around us?

Last Answer : I think motive is a greater factor for technological advancement than imagination itself ever has been.

Do you believe that there are other life forms than humans in the universe?

Description : Do you believe that there are other life forms than humans in the universe?

Last Answer : We want so badly for there to be other being more advanced that will come and peacefully solve our problems, or at least be interesting…what if WE are the most advanced beings out there so far? What if aliens came to us and needed help?

Does Deterministic Chaos ensure that there are certain phenomenon which will never be predictable?

Description : Does Deterministic Chaos ensure that there are certain phenomenon which will never be predictable?

Last Answer : A precise description of the solar system (location of planets, moons etc) in the more distant future.

How much does a deterministic philosophy affect your view of the world?

Description : How much does a deterministic philosophy affect your view of the world?

Last Answer : I am pretty deterministic. I think that, if we know all of the variables, it’s likely we can predict the system. My biggest uncertainty comes from the fact that I am no expert in quantum mechanics, which some have used as a method for discounting determinism.

Deterministic paradox? (Click to read more)

Description : Deterministic paradox? (Click to read more)

Last Answer : Of course it is ignoring Heisenberg uncertainty principle.

Is object destruction deterministic?

Description : Is object destruction deterministic?

Last Answer : No

Which of the following statements is true? A. PERT is considered as a deterministic approach and CPM is a probabilis t ic techniques. B. PERT is considered as a probabilistic techniques and CPM is considered as a deterministic approach. C. PERT and CPM are both probabilistic techniques. D. PERT and CPM are both considered as deterministic approachs

Description : Which of the following statements is true? A. PERT is considered as a deterministic approach and CPM is a probabilis t ic techniques. B. PERT is considered as a probabilistic techniques ... and CPM are both probabilistic techniques. D. PERT and CPM are both considered as deterministic approachs

Last Answer : B. PERT is considered as a probabilistic techniques and CPM is considered as a deterministic approach

Standard planning algorithms assumes environment to be ___________ a) Deterministic b) Fully observable c) Single agent d) Stochastic

Description : Standard planning algorithms assumes environment to be ___________ a) Deterministic b) Fully observable c) Single agent d) Stochastic

Last Answer : a) Deterministic

What kind of behavior does the stochastic environment posses? a) Local b) Deterministic c) Rational d) Primary

Description : What kind of behavior does the stochastic environment posses? a) Local b) Deterministic c) Rational d) Primary

Last Answer : a) Local

What kind of environment is strategic in artificial intelligence? a) Deterministic b) Rational c) Partial d) Stochastic

Description : What kind of environment is strategic in artificial intelligence? a) Deterministic b) Rational c) Partial d) Stochastic

Last Answer : a) Deterministic

What are deterministic vibrations? * (A)Vibrations caused due to known exciting force (B)Vibrations caused due to unknown exciting force (c) Vibrations which are aperiodic in nature (D) None of the above

Description : What are deterministic vibrations? * (A)Vibrations caused due to known exciting force (B)Vibrations caused due to unknown exciting force (c) Vibrations which are aperiodic in nature (D) None of the above

Last Answer : (A)Vibrations caused due to known exciting force

Deterministic vibrations are A Vibrations caused due to unknown exciting force B Vibrations caused due to known exciting force C Vibrations which are aperiodic in nature D None of the mentioned

Description : Deterministic vibrations are A Vibrations caused due to unknown exciting force B Vibrations caused due to known exciting force C Vibrations which are aperiodic in nature D None of the mentioned

Last Answer : B Vibrations caused due to known exciting force

What are deterministic vibrations? a. Vibrations caused due to known exciting force b. Vibrations caused due to unknown exciting force c. Vibrations which are aperiodic in nature d. None of the above

Description : What are deterministic vibrations? a. Vibrations caused due to known exciting force b. Vibrations caused due to unknown exciting force c. Vibrations which are aperiodic in nature d. None of the above

Last Answer : a. Vibrations caused due to known exciting force

Which of the following vibrations are classified according to magnitude of actuating force? a. Torsional vibrations b. Deterministic vibrationsc. Transverse d. All of the above

Description : Which of the following vibrations are classified according to magnitude of actuating force? a. Torsional vibrations b. Deterministic vibrationsc. Transverse d. All of the above

Last Answer : b. Deterministic

What are deterministic vibrations? a. Vibrations caused b. Vibrations caused c. Vibrations which d. None of the above

Description : What are deterministic vibrations? a. Vibrations caused b. Vibrations caused c. Vibrations which d. None of the above

Last Answer : a. Vibrations caused

25. Operations Research models in which some or all values of variables are random in nature are called _____ a. Physical b. Symbolic c. Deterministic d. Probabilistic

Description : 25. Operations Research models in which some or all values of variables are random in nature are called _____ a. Physical b. Symbolic c. Deterministic d. Probabilistic

Last Answer : d. Probabilistic

Operations Research models in which values of all variables and all possible outcomes are known with certainty are called _____ a. Physical b. Symbolic c. Deterministic d. Probabilistic

Description : Operations Research models in which values of all variables and all possible outcomes are known with certainty are called _____ a. Physical b. Symbolic c. Deterministic d. Probabilistic

Last Answer : c. Deterministic

PERT technique of network analysis is mainly useful for (A) Small projects (B) Large and complex projects (C) Research and development projects (D) Deterministic activities

Description : PERT technique of network analysis is mainly useful for (A) Small projects (B) Large and complex projects (C) Research and development projects (D) Deterministic activities

Last Answer : (C) Research and development projects