Are "thinkers" less religiously faithful?

1 Answer

Answer :

answer:This research is based on the “2 systems” understanding of how the mind works: that we process experience first on an intuitive level, and then go on to engage our analytical tools to either build a case for our intuitive conclusions or (more rarely) check the validity of the intuitive conclusion. The religious impulse originates on the intuitive level. I don’t think there’s any dispute about that. People just have “a sense” of an underlying mystery associated with a feeling of awe. What happens next is that the other system, the analytical one, gets recruited to provide a rational basis for that feeling. That rational system operates by seeing if it can construct a coherent story that accounts for the intuition. Studies show that if a story emerges that seems to hang together in a fairly satisfactory way and provides a pretty good causal explanation in support of the intuition, then our inclination will be to accept it as truth. All religions are, in my view, the various stories that have emerged from this process. But, as I said up top, there is yet a further degree to which the rational system can become involved, and that is to actually undertake a rigorous check of the validity of the story. The research that the article mentions is part of a much larger body of research that confirms this fact of human nature: we rarely take this step. We are usually satisfied with having arrived at some kind of plausible story, and are then loathe to challenge it any further. We do this in all kinds of domains, not just the religious. But in the context of religion, there is immense resistance to seeing the story as just a story and challenging it. The stories get enshrined as unassailable. I think that the tragedy in all this is that the basic intuition of sacred awe is a collateral casualty. That intuition is a magnificent aspect of what it means to be human. But because the stories we spin to explain it don’t hold up well to analysis, we often determine that the intuition itself is invalid and to be ignored. But I think that’s a big mistake. Whether or not we buy into the stories of “god” or “heaven” or “nirvana” or “soul”, this basic sense of mystery that is out of reach to cognition is at the core of our being and drives most of what we consider “good” about humanity.

Related questions

Description : Why would anyone vote for a religiously fundamentalist politician that is actively rooting for end times?

Last Answer : What a scary prospect that would be. The environment, income inequality, decaying infrastructure, global war? Bring it on. Eat, drink and be merry for the rapture will soon be upon us.

Description : Do you think religiously run institutions should be mandated to cover birth control in the health insurance they offer?

Last Answer : answer:As a Roman Catholic, I say yes. Catholic Health Services cover a large percentage of the local hospitals, to deny parts of necessary health care to people is unconscionable. A very high percentage of Catholics use birth control of one sort or another.

Description : Do you have any friends or acquaintances who are less than faithful to the truth?

Last Answer : Ya. My sister. She people pleases by stretching the truth. It is very frustrating for me. Also in my community story telling is cultural and traditional so whenever someone tells a story I have to wonder ... to tell the story as is only but nowadays people just want to be good story tellers.

Description : Do you think women married to military men today or more or less faithful?

Last Answer : It depends on the person, and their beliefs really. But in my opinion it would be difficult to stay with someone I hardly ever see. It’s more tempting to cheat on your spouse when you aren’t around them as much. And it’s way to easy to lose interest.

Description : What term other than "the faithful" would you suggest to refer to people who belong to some religion or participate in a religious event?

Last Answer : Members of religious denominations.

Description : What faithful lady has reached 30,000 lurve?

Last Answer : CONGRATS @Judi! Finally the mansion has snagged a really awesome and vivacious blond bombshell as one of its residents!

Description : Can an unfaithful husband/boyfriend ever be faithful again and always?

Last Answer : They can, but the odds are not that hot. Of course every person is different so any sort of ‘yes’, ‘no’ or ‘maybe’ means jack squat.

Description : Is it "faithful day" or "fateful day"?

Last Answer : Fateful

Description : What do you think of this video? Are americans getting way to paranoid or is it now "fashionable & cool" to flex your ultra-liberal muscles and show off to the "internet faithful"?

Last Answer : I think that video is ridiculous. The man shows no respect for people who are merely doing their job. The officer was much more respectful and understanding to him than he was to her so he shouldn’t have any complaints.

Description : Which Public Sector bank’ emblem figures a dog and the words ‘faithful, friendly’ in it? -Do You Know?

Last Answer : answer:

Description : Which Public Sector bank’ emblem figures a dog and the words ‘faithful, friendly’ in it? -Do You Know?

Last Answer : answer:

Description : "Is ""Hamilton"" entirely faithful to history?"

Last Answer : Answer: No. There is evidence to prove that several founding fathers shown in the play, including Hamilton himself, were slave owners.

Last Answer : The most trusted animal is the dog.

Description : Are men faithful to their wives in Honduras?

Last Answer : This is up to discussion. Faithfulness is everywhere and so ischeating. There is no country on Earth that isn't filled withpeople who have cheated or have been cheated on wherever you are nomatter if you are in a certain country or not, I am positive thereare cheaters there.

Description : What is the difference between a faithful servant and a maid servant?

Last Answer : The difference is the maid servant is cooks and cleans more were as a faithful servant is always remaining loyal and sticks to the true facts.

Description : The narrator followed the strange aeroplane like a) A faithful friend b) An obedient child c) A subordinate d) An invigilator

Last Answer : b) An obedient child

Description : Which quantizationlevel results ina more faithful reproduction of the signal? A) 2 B) 8 C) 16 D) 32

Last Answer : 32

Description : Which of the following ethical principles refers to the duty to do good? a) Beneficence Beneficence is the duty to do good and the active promotion of benevolent acts. b) Fidelity Fidelity refers to the ... not to inflict, as well as to prevent and remove, harm; it is more binding than beneficence.

Last Answer : a) Beneficence Beneficence is the duty to do good and the active promotion of benevolent acts.

Description : Multiple checkpoints in the eukaryotic cell cycle ensure that division occurs only after sufficient growth and faithful DNA replication, and only when favorable conditions exist. Of the many proteins involved in ... CDKs) are among the most important. How do CDKs function to control the cell cycle?

Last Answer : CDKs phosphorylate various protein substrates that are required for cell cycle progression. Some of the important substrate proteins that CDKs phosphorylate include condensin proteins, which are essential ... which form a stabilizing network under the nuclear membrane that assembles during mitosis.

Description : Shall we make a joint writing course for conspiracy thinkers/writers/inventors?

Last Answer : You mean like Viral Troll School? Only if we figure out a way to monetize it. I’m not letting some tumpstunned wingnut bunker rat rip off my creativity without paying.

Description : Is the internet causing students to become complacent thinkers?

Last Answer : answer:I, for one, don't see the logic in that reasoning. How does the availability of information discourage thinking? That's an argument against libraries and encyclopedias as well, isn't it? ... own interests only factor in very rarely. This is what breeds complacent thinkers, in my opinion.

Description : Do you feel that people who are into conspiracy theories are "deep thinkers?"?

Last Answer : I also find conspiracy theorists to be irrational ,paranoid and delusional but the fact remains that some conspiracies are real,

Description : Why Scientists and real Thinkers got paid very low in this capitalism system?

Last Answer : How much do you think scientists get paid? How much do you think they should get paid?

Description : Name great thinkers/inventors/etc who had "breakthrough" during movements?

Last Answer : The original “Eureka!” man—Archimedes—was stepping into a bath.

Description : Why did so many of the great thinkers of the Age of Enlightenment not question the reality of a deity?

Last Answer : What they said in their public writings and what they felt personally may have been two different things. Perhaps it was not politically wise, when one had a career.

Description : ‘Print popularised the ideas of the Enlightenment thinkers.’ Explain. -SST 10th

Last Answer : (i) Collectively, the writings of thinkers provided a critical commentary on tradition, superstition and despotism. (ii)Scholars and thinkers argued for the rule of reason rather than custom, and ... these books saw the world through new eyes, eyes that were questioning, critical and rational.

Description : How did the print popularize the ideas of the enlightened thinkers? -SST 10th

Last Answer : (i) In 1517, the religious reformer Martin Luther wrote Ninety Five Theses' criticising many of the practices and rituals of the Roman Catholic Church. (ii) Due to writings of Martin Luther ... brought about a new intellectual atmosphere and helped spread the new ideas that led to reformation.

Description : Explain the role of thinkers and philosophers in the French Revolution. -History 9th

Last Answer : During 18 th century , France had many revolutionary thinkers.Among them were Voltaire , Rousseau , Montesquieu and Dederot .Their revolutionary ideas helped the people to fight for their rights . ... without guilt.(4) John Locke propounded the ideas refuting divinity and absolute rights of monarch.

Description : Who is Bangladesh's Top 100 Thinkers of the Decade in US-based Foreign Policy Magazine ?

Last Answer : Prime Minister Sheikh Hasina (in Defense and Security category).

Description : ‘Live as if you were to die tomorrow, learn as if you were to live forever’ Mahatma Gandhi. Collect some quotes on education by famous thinkers.

Last Answer : ‘Live as if you were to die tomorrow, learn as if you were to live forever’ Mahatma Gandhi. Collect some quotes on education by famous thinkers.

Description : How did the writings of Enlightenment-era thinkers like John Locke and Baron Charles de Montesquieu influence the American Revolution?

Last Answer : Apex : C.These writings challenged traditional, social, religious, and political values.

Description : What do you call the eighteenth century thinkers who believed that wisdon reason and knowledge could bring justice equlity and freedom?

Last Answer : Enlightenment thinkers/ philosophy.

Description : When in enlightenment thinkers question traditional ideas what was the result?

Last Answer : Feel Free to Answer

Description : What was a main belief of Enlightenment thinkers that influenced the colonies?

Last Answer : Feel Free to Answer

Description : Why were Ancient Greek know as great thinkers?

Last Answer : Feel Free to Answer

Description : What Thinkers of the scientific revolution believed that?

Last Answer : Feel Free to Answer

Description : What two European Enlightenment thinkers influenced Latin America and revolutionary leaders?

Last Answer : Need answer

Description : What social institution did Renaissance thinkers connect with the goths in order to imply that it was backwards and barbaric?

Last Answer : The two time periods are not connected. The Renaissance tookplace from 1300-1700. The Goth invasion of Rome took place in 410 .There is over a1000 years difference between them.

Description : What was the result when the enlightenment thinkers questioned traditional ideas?

Last Answer : They began to use reason and knowledge to explain beliefs. ~22s~

Description : When enlightenment thinkers thinkers questioned traditional ideas what was the result?

Last Answer : They began to use reason and knowledge to explain beliefs. ~22s~

Description : Socialist thinkers advocate the extension of the right to equality in – (1) Political sphere (2) Economic sphere (3) Social sphere (4) Legal sphere

Last Answer : (2) Economic sphere Explanation: Socialism is an economic system characterized by social ownership of the means of production and cooperative management of the economy, and a political philosophy ... focusing on a common set of values emphasizing social cooperation, universal welfare, and equality.

Description : When describing Organizational Culture, some Mgt Thinkers use expressions such as ------- the way things are around here . In relation to this statement, which of the following is the ... in Control Systems so that the culture changes D. To make structural changes so that the culture changes

Last Answer : To investigate the taken-for-granted aspects of the culture