The American Academy of Pediatrics just published a policy statement that states that the benefits of circumcision outweigh the risks. Do you still think it's child abuse?

The American Academy of Pediatrics just published a policy statement that states that the benefits of circumcision outweigh the risks. Do you still think it's child abuse?
by

1 Answer

Answer :

While I feel for the infants discomfort, I do not consider it child abuse. Different choices for different families and cultures. We could argue that spaying and neutering pets is a physically abusive procedure as well, even though the benefits outweigh the surgery, as is true for the circumcision procedure IMO.
by

Related questions

What do you think about child abuse ?

Description : What do you think about child abuse ?

Last Answer : Children are the only true innocents in this world. Anyone that can harm a child is below contempt. I could seriously harm someone that would hurt a child.

Is occasional hitting still abuse?

Description : Is occasional hitting still abuse?

Last Answer : Yes.

Why would the respondent in a sexual abuse case depose the petitioner?

Description : Why would the respondent in a sexual abuse case depose the petitioner?

Last Answer : A deposition is standard procedure in a court case. They are going to try to establish the facts as you present them. It can be intimidating to go through.

Say that a 16 year old male molests a 7 year old child, does he know what he's doing?

Description : Say that a 16 year old male molests a 7 year old child, does he know what he's doing?

Last Answer : Of course he does, and of course he could.

What would you do if your husband's therapist told your child you were a bad person?

Description : What would you do if your husband's therapist told your child you were a bad person?

Last Answer : It depends on how bad the parent is, but that is still pretty unprofessional on the doctors part.

"Child witches" in Nigeria: Whose responsibility?

Description : "Child witches" in Nigeria: Whose responsibility?

Last Answer : religion

Do we really have a "just" justice system?

Description : Do we really have a "just" justice system?

Last Answer : Our justice system is flawed, but it is all that we have, and it is better than many others.

Did anyone know this about Marion Zimmer Bradley?

Description : Did anyone know this about Marion Zimmer Bradley?

Last Answer : answer:I am aware that her husband had some dealings with a scandalously young man at some point. At the time of the affair the boy was above the age of consent (this would have been in the 60s(?), ... did help get the club started. No point in rewriting history - that was 49 years ago, after all.

Who should pay for the mental health care for the victims of the Penn State Defesnive Coordinator, Jerry Sandusky's victims?

Description : Who should pay for the mental health care for the victims of the Penn State Defesnive Coordinator, Jerry Sandusky's victims?

Last Answer : If a victim is independently assessed as needing counseling as a direct result of Sandusky’s actions, Sandusky should be liable for the cost.

Is it legal for a 23 year old to have a baby with a 15 year old?

Description : Is it legal for a 23 year old to have a baby with a 15 year old?

Last Answer : What state is this in? In my state it is illegal. In others it is not

What do you do if you know of a kid who's being neglected?

Description : What do you do if you know of a kid who's being neglected?

Last Answer : Contact the National Child Abuse & Neglect hotline – 1–800-4-A-CHILD (1–800-422–4453)

i need to know some topics i can write a reseach paper on in forensic psychology

Description : i need to know some topics i can write a reseach paper on in forensic psychology

Last Answer : What’s wrong with that topic? Has the professor given you an area to work in, or any specific suggested topics?

Do the risks of colon cleansing outweigh the benefits?

Description : Do the risks of colon cleansing outweigh the benefits?

Last Answer : Colon cleansing is a great way to promote prostate health. Sadly though if used to often it can result in many people not having enough bacteria in their intestines which is a bad thing.

Do the benefits of joining AARP outweigh the pissed-off-edness that comes with realizing you're old enough to join?

Description : Do the benefits of joining AARP outweigh the pissed-off-edness that comes with realizing you're old enough to join?

Last Answer : Auggie, I get the cards. It sucks, but what’s your other option?

Should ethics be overlooked in the field of technological advancements if the benefits outweigh the costs?

Description : Should ethics be overlooked in the field of technological advancements if the benefits outweigh the costs?

Last Answer : Why is it unethical to cause harm to a few so that many more may be kept free from harm? I would think that if the few did not make the sacrifice, then many others would suffer, instead. You may ... agree with you that the few should not suffer for the benefit of the many. Just what are you asking?

Why does the British Pound outweigh the US Dollar in value when it seems that the economy of the United States is far more powerful?

Description : Why does the British Pound outweigh the US Dollar in value when it seems that the economy of the United States is far more powerful?

Last Answer : answer:I think that, in general, it has something to do with the fact that the British economy is strong and reliable, and that the UK has always had very profitable trading agreements throught ... how the buying power of a coin is, supposedly, representative of its country's credit reliability)

What is the name of the quarterly magazine published by Bangla Academy ?

Description : What is the name of the quarterly magazine published by Bangla Academy ?

Last Answer : : Inheritance.

What is required for a degree in pediatrics?

Description : What is required for a degree in pediatrics?

Last Answer : Yes you do. There are many years of school you have to complete. You will have to complete 8 years of school.

What is the difference in the Adult and Pediatrics Medicines ?

Description : What is the difference in the Adult and Pediatrics Medicines ?

Last Answer : there are so many differences. It depends upon the size of the body and the physiology of the adult and children. A major difference between a Pediatric and an adult medicine is that the ... be considered. In a sense, Pediatricians have to ask their parents before treating the children.

What are ways of reducing the risks of abuse on social?

Description : What are ways of reducing the risks of abuse on social?

Last Answer : Feel Free to Answer

If you suffered sexual or physical abuse as a child, as an adult, do you have anything to do with your abuser (assuming that he or she is still alive)

Description : If you suffered sexual or physical abuse as a child, as an adult, do you have anything to do with your abuser (assuming that he or she is still alive)

Last Answer : For a long time, I did, because he was always at family events. At some point, though, I realized it was making me crazy, and I finally said no more! If he was attending, I didn't go. ... I missed having Christmas at my grandparent's house and such, but it was definitely better for me to cut ties.

What is the training process for the Policy Academy?

Description : What is the training process for the Policy Academy?

Last Answer : The Police Academy training is usually around 700 hours long, teaching a multitude of subjects. First you must have a background check and be selected.

Max has applied to the United States Air Force Academy that is just north of Colorado Springs?

Description : Max has applied to the United States Air Force Academy that is just north of Colorado Springs?

Last Answer : Max has applied to the United States Air Force Academy that is just north of Colorado Springs. proper noun

Max has applied to the United States Air Force Academy that is just north of Colorado Springs?

Description : Max has applied to the United States Air Force Academy that is just north of Colorado Springs?

Last Answer : Max has applied to the United States Air Force Academy that is just north of Colorado Springs. proper noun

Do the needs of the many outweigh the needs of the few?

Description : Do the needs of the many outweigh the needs of the few?

Last Answer : Only on paper and in video games. In real life we are all important.

What can I do about my extremely emotional cat whose need of love seems to outweigh what I can realistically give him?

Description : What can I do about my extremely emotional cat whose need of love seems to outweigh what I can realistically give him?

Last Answer : He knows you’re stressed & he knows your current health condition @deni. It sounds to me as if he’s extremely concerned over you.

Do Obama ads significantly outweigh Romney ads on all FaceBook accounts?

Description : Do Obama ads significantly outweigh Romney ads on all FaceBook accounts?

Last Answer : Obama has more unencumbered money available. Until the Republican convention is over much of Romney’s funding is restricted. Then Romney can start using the money he raised for the general election freely and the ad time will even out.

Does the cost of laser eye surgery outweigh the costs of dealing with glasses?

Description : Does the cost of laser eye surgery outweigh the costs of dealing with glasses?

Last Answer : Laser eye surgery over time will help reduce the cost of replacing glasses over time. The cost of the surgery though is easily thousands of dollars.

Olympic Games and Stuxnet - What do you think about the just published book "Obama's Secret Wars and Surprising Use of American Power" ?

Description : Olympic Games and Stuxnet - What do you think about the just published book "Obama's Secret Wars and Surprising Use of American Power" ?

Last Answer : I think it is a disgrace. But it is also nothing new.

Was this child abuse or just stupidity?

Description : Was this child abuse or just stupidity?

Last Answer : Is this a true story or apocryphal? Do you have a link?

Is the incidence of sexual child abuse on the rise, or is it just that a greater percentage are being reported?

Description : Is the incidence of sexual child abuse on the rise, or is it just that a greater percentage are being reported?

Last Answer : I think people just talk about it more now, I don’t think it is on the rise. Back about 25 years ago there were a lot of reports that wound up to be false, false memory. Some of that still happens, but for the most part I believe what is reported is true.

What are your thoughts on circumcision?

Description : What are your thoughts on circumcision?

Last Answer : [deleted]

Is circumcision on infants necessary?

Description : Is circumcision on infants necessary?

Last Answer : answer:Nope. Back in the day, it was considered to be optimal for reasons of hygiene and disease prevention. Parents worked with the best information that they had. Nowadays the consensus is that it isn't ... religious purposes, that is not my place to judge. I personally would not do it to a child.

In your opinion what are the pros and cons for circumcision on the male?

Description : In your opinion what are the pros and cons for circumcision on the male?

Last Answer : I was told it is more to clean things up as the excess skin can problematic, suppose just hygiene purposes. I don’t even remember being circumcised when I was little.

How do you feel about circumcision?

Description : How do you feel about circumcision?

Last Answer : I think that it is mutilation. Nowadays there is no reason for it other than to serve some religious reason. Back in olden times when folks didn’t bath regularly circumcision may have stopped infections.

Where can I find organizations dedicated to fighting Female Circumcision?

Description : Where can I find organizations dedicated to fighting Female Circumcision?

Last Answer : Excellent Q. IFMSA (International Federation of Medical Students Association) has a project on female genital mutilation. Also check out the Amnesty International page on it (side links refer to how you can help). You can also get involved with Unicef on this issue.

If God made man in his own image why does Judaism (and no doubt other religions) insist on circumcision as a religous practice? Do they believe man has to improve on God's design?

Description : If God made man in his own image why does Judaism (and no doubt other religions) insist on circumcision as a religous practice? Do they believe man has to improve on God's design?

Last Answer : God suggested it, as a sign of the Covenant. You could look it up.

Why isn't male circumcision as abhored (and illegal) as any type of female genital mutilation?

Description : Why isn't male circumcision as abhored (and illegal) as any type of female genital mutilation?

Last Answer : Um, religion? My sisters have both circumcised their sons, for no other reason than so he'll look like everyone else . And I've heard the hygiene reasoning, but I don't buy it. Female genitalia ... and they spend the rest of their lives trying to make up for the loss of that exquisite sensitivity.)

How much is circumcision ? What ?

Description : How much is circumcision ? What ?

Last Answer : Sunnat of ablution: 1. Starting with Bismillah. -Sunan Abu Dawood Ha. 101 2. At the beginning of ablution, wash both hands up to the wrists three times. 3. Coolie and runny nose. 4. Exhale with the ... 159 In another hadith: ... Paradise will become obligatory for him. ' -Sahih Muslim Ha. 234

What are the two types of circumcision ?

Description : What are the two types of circumcision ?

Last Answer : If there are two types of circumcision , Sunnat Muakkada and Sunnat Zayda.

How many types of circumcision ?

Description : How many types of circumcision ?

Last Answer : Sunnat 2 types.

How much is the duty of Hajj ? How much is circumcision and how much is obligatory ? What ? What is Hajj ?

Description : How much is the duty of Hajj ? How much is circumcision and how much is obligatory ? What ? What is Hajj ?

Last Answer : The lexical and technical meaning of Hajj: Hajj is an Arabic word. Money intended , to visit , to resolve, to intend, to go , to wish , to promise , to wish for some great deed. And in ... circumcisions between different periods , its mention is in the right place. Source: Nurul Ijah , 1 / 74-75

What is the provision and measurement of beard ? My beard has become a fist by the grace of God. Now my question is , how much is circumcision and how much is obligatory to keep ? And can I now lighten the size of the beards ?

Description : What is the provision and measurement of beard ? My beard has become a fist by the grace of God. Now my question is , how much is circumcision and how much is obligatory to keep ? And can I now lighten the size of the beards ?

Last Answer : Dear religious brother , beard is a great and great blessing of Allah. Considered as a symbol of Islam. Beard means masculinity , it is the identity of masculinity, the beauty of Muslim. This is one ... been kept , there will never be any reward. May Allah give you the correct understanding. Amen.

headline _ _ It often happens that I go to the mosque and see that the congregation of Fajr prayer has started. But my circumcision was not read. What do I do then ? I will not read the circumcision before the congregation ?

Description : headline _ _ It often happens that I go to the mosque and see that the congregation of Fajr prayer has started. But my circumcision was not read. What do I do then ? I will not read the circumcision before the congregation ?

Last Answer : Fajr circumcision is very important. It has been narrated in the hadith that the Prophet (peace and blessings of Allaah be upon him) said , Do not leave the sunnah of Fajr . Although the army chases ... , but the Sunnah should be recited. But like most jurists , that is what has been said above.

What is the circumcision method for keeping hair ?

Description : What is the circumcision method for keeping hair ?

Last Answer : It is sunnat for men to have curly hair. Because , the general habit of Rasulullah (SAW) was to keep Babri hair. It can be done in three ways. One. Along both shoulders. Two. In the middle of the neck ... course, there is no problem even if it is not cut. (Tirmizi Sharif 1/162 , Muslim Sharif 1/146

I'm afraid of circumcision :(

Description : I'm afraid of circumcision :( it's probably waiting for me: /

Last Answer : Sometimes it's inevitable, but it's relatively easy to survive. It's nothing major

Circumcision?

Description : I'm 14 years old and I won't stretch my foreskin when I get an erection. I've read something about it and they write everywhere about going for circumcision, but I find it embarrassing ... I feel like going to my parents at 14 and telling them I want a circumcision?

Last Answer : Adam, you should definitely discuss this issue with your dad. Or don't you have an uncle or a doctor you trust? Don't worry, find someone to look at you and advise you. The mistake was probably that you ... slowly drag to loosen, she stretched. If it doesn't work out in time, you have to find help.

what happens to the cut off foreskin after circumcision?

Description : is it biological waste and is it going to the incinerator? or is there a skewer fairy and the foreskin is stored somewhere (in alcohol, dried as a bookmark in the Torah, ...)? or does the surgeon take her home as a trophy? or ...? (tuxedo)

Last Answer : Even a doctor can't answer that, I asked about another part of the human body

What if I don't go to circumcision?

Description : The doctor sends me for the procedure. But I'm terribly scared. What if I don't go for it? Can I have any complications one day? Jirka 11 years old

Last Answer : Don't worry, it's nothing painful. If the doctor recommends it, be sure to go. If you have a recommendation, sooner or later serious complications would certainly occur.

Circumcision?

Description : Circumcision?

Last Answer : Circumcision is the treatment to remove the foreskin from the head of men's private part. This treatment is for babies and in some conditions, adults have also needed this treatment. For Circumcision in Vizag, you can contact VJ's Transgender Clinic that specializes in providing this treatment.