Do Captioning companies condescend down to deaf people?

Do Captioning companies condescend down to deaf people?
by

1 Answer

Answer :

Yeah. They do it purposely to offend deaf people. A big part of the film experience is the music, for example, when it builds to crescendo in a scene to enhance the stress value. Spielberg used that quite effectively in Jaws. Describing this is an attempt to include the deaf in the experience—and for those who had seen the movie when they were still able to hear, will remember that thrilling, or romantic, music whereas they might not without the reminder. I think the deaf appreciate it and it either means something to them, or not. But the experience is described on screen in case they do.
by

Related questions

Listening to music if you're deaf?

Description : Listening to music if you're deaf?

Last Answer : answer:Sent this to member filmfann who may have some information for you. Welcome to Fluther!

Why is closed captioning always so f***ed up?

Description : Why is closed captioning always so f***ed up?

Last Answer : Isn't it voice recognition software that is used? That certainly has a long way to go I think it's kind of funny sometimes to see what comes up on the screen, as opposed to what was really said. But you' ... as well for me to stand up next to the TV and try to write things on a white board for him.

How does Closed Captioning work?

Description : How does Closed Captioning work?

Last Answer : On DVD’s it keeps SO from asking “what did they say?” every two minutes, so I can enjoy the movie. But he can’t keep up with it on TV, and they misspell alot.

Careers in Broadcast Captioning?

Description : Careers in Broadcast Captioning?

Last Answer : Broadcast CaptioningBroadcast captioners are the individuals who create the closedcaptioning text that runs along the bottom of television screensfor people with hearing difficulties and deafness. ... be captioned in realtime.Job Requirements and EducationIndividuals looking to become a broadcast

Does anyone know of any reputable online publishing companies?

Description : Does anyone know of any reputable online publishing companies?

Last Answer : answer:I have a friend who’s published a series of novels through Daniel & Daniel. He’s done well and is very please with them. Good luck and welcome to ask-public. [EDIT: I’m sorry. I just looked at their manuscript guidlines, and they don’t accept them via email. Sorry. My mistake.]

Where can I find peer-reviewed articles on the corporate social responsibility of gene therapy companies?

Description : Where can I find peer-reviewed articles on the corporate social responsibility of gene therapy companies?

Last Answer : answer:The best peer-reviewed articles are not going to be found freely online. If you are in college you might do well to check to see if your school subscribes to services like JSTOR or ... some large academic databases as well. Typically the kind of stuff you would otherwise have to pay for.

If you were going to sit down and try to write a book, what would it be about?

Description : If you were going to sit down and try to write a book, what would it be about?

Last Answer : If I decide to write about myself it would be an interesting story to read if not great!! I’ll share with you guys if I’m able to do so..)

What are other famous names/sayings like "Down the rabbit hole" which imply alternate reality or insanity?

Description : What are other famous names/sayings like "Down the rabbit hole" which imply alternate reality or insanity?

Last Answer : answer:Mind Screw is my favorite. TvTropes has a list, under Absurdity Ascendant.

Writers: can you just sit down and write or do you need inspiration first?

Description : Writers: can you just sit down and write or do you need inspiration first?

Last Answer : A little bit of both.

Is there a decent cheap pen that won't leak when upside down?

Description : Is there a decent cheap pen that won't leak when upside down?

Last Answer : get a pen with a cap?

Why can't they view the upside down text?

Description : Why can't they view the upside down text?

Last Answer : ˙ɹǝʇndɯoɔ ɹıǝɥʇ uo sǝıɹɐɹqıl ǝƃɐnƃuɐl/ʇuoɟ ʇɔǝɹɹoɔ ǝɥʇ ƃuıʌɐɥ ʇou ɯǝɥʇ ɥʇıʍ op oʇ ƃuıɥʇǝɯos sɐɥ ʎlqɐqoɹd — bɹo.ʇxǝʇdı1ɟ.ʍʍʍ ʇxǝʇ sdı1ɟ ʇɐɥʇ ǝʇıs ɹǝɥʇouɐ s,ǝɹǝɥ

How do I get down to writing when I don't feel like it at all?

Description : How do I get down to writing when I don't feel like it at all?

Last Answer : Hey James! I have never put much stock in inspiration'... for me it all starts with perspiration it is a discipline and lots of research usually the research sparks that 10% inspiration. I just wake ... has inspired many, many poems just get started - the juices WILL flow and so will the ink.

How do i just sit down and write?

Description : How do i just sit down and write?

Last Answer : Try using a tape recorder and do it verbally. A tape recorder can be much easier to take anywhere, when you get those brilliant writers thoughts, and not as cumbersome as a laptop. Then you can always play it back and type it out, or have someone type it out for you. Just a thought.

People who have been deaf since birth, how do you perceive music descriptions in subtitles (i.e. "epic music playing", "poignant music playing")?

Description : People who have been deaf since birth, how do you perceive music descriptions in subtitles (i.e. "epic music playing", "poignant music playing")?

Last Answer : My favorite is “pensive music”

Can deaf people who are mentaly ill hear voices? Can blind people hallucinate images?

Description : Can deaf people who are mentaly ill hear voices? Can blind people hallucinate images?

Last Answer : Someone correct me if I'm wrong, but when one has auditory hallucinations, they are not actually hearing anything through their ears. It's in the mind, so if that person was deaf when they were born ... not the senses. They are only translated in ways that make you think they come from the latter.

What do deaf people do to wake up?

Description : What do deaf people do to wake up?

Last Answer : I have an older version of this.

Where are some places where I can meet people of the Deaf Community?

Description : Where are some places where I can meet people of the Deaf Community?

Last Answer : I would start with your teacher. Ask them if there are any upcoming deaf events you could go to – maybe a play done in ASL, maybe a conference. Your teacher probably has some kind of handout for ways to get involved with the deaf community.

Can people, who were born deaf (100%), talk? [Details inside].

Description : Can people, who were born deaf (100%), talk? [Details inside].

Last Answer : answer:Yes, one of the girls I went to school was born deaf, but she could talk (and do sign language). She went to a speech therapist that taught her how to read lips so she could see ... . I think deaf people have varying degrees of success with spoken speech, whether they were born deaf or not.

Are some people born mute because they're deaf or are they're some people who are mute but can hear?

Description : Are some people born mute because they're deaf or are they're some people who are mute but can hear?

Last Answer : answer:Yes, some people are mute because they are born deaf, or become deaf in their early childhood, but even most deaf people can and do make sounds, including speech. Other people, who do ... the physical potential to be able to speak. You can read more about these causes under Selective Mutism

How can blind people communicate with the deaf?

Description : How can blind people communicate with the deaf?

Last Answer : By computer The same way a regular person can communicate.

How can deaf people think?

Description : How can deaf people think?

Last Answer : visually? you know, like, seeing the words, or pictures

Can deaf people understand textspeak?

Description : Can deaf people understand textspeak?

Last Answer : I’m sure they are familiar with how to pronounce letters and numbers, so yes.

How do deaf people think?

Description : How do deaf people think?

Last Answer : Most likely in the same way you think when you're reading something for the first time. I find it hard to believe you hear a specific person's voice when say, doing problems in a math textbook. Also, ... a deaf person might have a better sense of sight, a blind person a better sense in smell, etc.

How do deaf people know what a text version of a sound sounds like when using closed caption on TV?

Description : How do deaf people know what a text version of a sound sounds like when using closed caption on TV?

Last Answer : Don’t ask me, man. I watch sub anime and if I switch to dub to see something I’ll tell the tone of what they mean. Ex: in sub I might hear smth like “what are you talking about” and think it’s sarcastic then I switch to dub and it’s a genuine question

Deaf People Listen Helper Instrument Name What ?

Last Answer : Deaf People In the ear Listen Of the instrument Name ' Year Trumpet '

When a deaf child hears for the first time, how do they understand the words?

Description : When a deaf child hears for the first time, how do they understand the words?

Last Answer : They don’t. They only respond to the new sensation of sound.

What's the use of speaking Truth to Power if Power is deaf? Do you have other unanswerable questions like this?

Description : What's the use of speaking Truth to Power if Power is deaf? Do you have other unanswerable questions like this?

Last Answer : Who put the bomp, in the bomp sha bomp sha bomp? Does anyone really know?

I read an article that American Airlines marked a bag Deaf and Dumb, what do you think about it?

Description : I read an article that American Airlines marked a bag Deaf and Dumb, what do you think about it?

Last Answer : “The where f the bag was very upset, and now the employee who tagged it is going through sensitivity training.” What does this sentence mean? I can’t make it out.

Do musicians have a high chance of becoming deaf?

Description : Do musicians have a high chance of becoming deaf?

Last Answer : I spent one evening about 8 feet away from an incredibly large speaker, next to Eric Burdon. My hearing was gone for 3 days after. Many musicians have lost their hearing due to exposure of high volume sound. Take precautions.

Is there any type of like deaf or hard of hearing chat rooms that you can use?

Description : Is there any type of like deaf or hard of hearing chat rooms that you can use?

Last Answer : I have sent this to one of members who is deaf.

What jobs would you say would be good for deaf or hard of hearing?

Description : What jobs would you say would be good for deaf or hard of hearing?

Last Answer : What are your passions and skills? Being hearing imparted shouldn't make it to hard to pursue most careers except maybe a musician or phone bank worker. My first thought was accountant ... With Disabilities Act employers can't discriminate and are required to make reasonable accommodations for you.

Suggestions for befriending a deaf person?

Description : Suggestions for befriending a deaf person?

Last Answer : Am I to understand he does not speak? There are many good sign language classes at adult night school. It is very easy to learn, if explained well. Your friend may not want to sign with you. Talk to him about it.

As a teenager, would you care if someone was deaf?

Description : As a teenager, would you care if someone was deaf?

Last Answer : Nope, I grew up with a deaf friend. We didn’t make any more or less fun of him than the rest of the gang. He was the best center fielder and clutch hitter on the little league team.

Is anyone here Deaf?

Description : Is anyone here Deaf?

Last Answer : Guess not. ,

Where did the idea that "hearing impaired" is more PC than "deaf" come from?

Description : Where did the idea that "hearing impaired" is more PC than "deaf" come from?

Last Answer : I'm not sure it is a PC term. There are degrees of hearing impairment from slight impairments that might require no intervention or help to a hearing impairment that might require some type of hearing ... he needed hearing aids. He was hearing impaired, or hard of hearing as they used to say.

How does being deaf impact a person's ability to work?

Description : How does being deaf impact a person's ability to work?

Last Answer : answer:i don't really know at all but i would think that working in a factory may be off limits. any job that would require you to be alert and aware of sounds so that you don't get hurt, otherwise ... . i don't know what i would do if my world was silent, my thoughts would probably drive me insane

Does being blind (or deaf, or in any way missing a sense) give insights that the rest of us don't have?

Description : Does being blind (or deaf, or in any way missing a sense) give insights that the rest of us don't have?

Last Answer : My wife is deaf (and has no sense of smell, either). Her deafness caused her no to learn some of the ways hearing people bullshit others. I have noticed this all over the deaf community. There is a total absence of bullshit among them.

Would you rather be deaf or blind?

Description : Would you rather be deaf or blind?

Last Answer : Deaf, my great grandmother was blind and it was awful for her. She went blind in her 30s and lived a pretty solitary life because of it. She never saw her grand children, she never saw her great grand children, and she felt so isolated it was heart breaking.

How do the deaf and blind interact with technology, especially telephony?

Description : How do the deaf and blind interact with technology, especially telephony?

Last Answer : Deaf people use TTY. Blind people do the same thing you do.

Deaf or Blind?

Description : Deaf or Blind?

Last Answer : My wife is deaf, and she functions quite well in the hearing world. Closed captioning, text messaging and lip reading combined for her success. I have been temporarily blind, and wouldn't want to repeat that. ... concert, where I stood 4 feet from a speaker), and got thru it. (great concert, btw)

Anyone here Deaf or studying Deaf Ed.?

Description : Anyone here Deaf or studying Deaf Ed.?

Last Answer : I’m pretty def.

How would you describe "music" to a deaf person?

Description : How would you describe "music" to a deaf person?

Last Answer : How do you describe colors to a blind person?

Whats the best way to train a deaf dog?

Description : Whats the best way to train a deaf dog?

Last Answer : I congratulate you on keeping this pup and would guess that you might need a professional animal trainer. Good luck.

Seeing blind? Deaf hearing?

Description : Seeing blind? Deaf hearing?

Last Answer : 5/10 of your answer.

Can you go deaf from going to too many concerts?

Description : Can you go deaf from going to too many concerts?

Last Answer : Yes it can, but it would get harder every time you go because the loud music would take less of a toll for everyone you go to.

Do you know if it is still possible to go into Computer Science when u r going totally deaf?

Description : Do you know if it is still possible to go into Computer Science when u r going totally deaf?

Last Answer : It seems to me that there are very few occupations that cannot be performed by a deaf person. Computer-based positions seem especially deaf-friendly.

Am I deaf or is my iPod screwy?

Description : Am I deaf or is my iPod screwy?

Last Answer : Invest is some decent isolating headphones. My current choice are Ultimate Ears. I never turn the volume up above 25%. They block out the noise of the tube (which believe me is an impressive feat alone ... they sound awesome, I mean out of this world different to the buds they provide with the ipod.

Is it true that all white boxers are deaf?

Description : content:

Last Answer : Only a small percentage of white Boxers are deaf, about 12-14%. They are also not albino, but a natural coloring. Deafness is due to a lack of pigmentation of hair cells in the ear.

Can you train a deaf dog?

Description : There's a really sweet dog at the shelter that I'm considering adopting. He's young, large and he's deaf. If I adopt him, will I be able to train him? I only want to teach him basic training. Is it possible to train a deaf dog?

Last Answer : Dogs can be born deaf or lose their hearing through illness, injury or old age. But deaf dogs can be trained, you just have to adjust your methods and be kind and patient. There are vibrating ... training. Never scold or punish. The dog only learns to fear you and will not respond to training.

How can I tell if my cat is deaf?

Description : We've has our cat for 3 months. I'm not sure if my cat is deaf or just ignoring me. I call for him to come, but he never does. He never responds at all when we call his name. How can I be sure?

Last Answer : You can try to check for deafness by standing behind your cat, making sure he's not watching you and clap your hands, bang on a pot or call his name. If your cat responds, he's probably not deaf ... , the best way to tell if he is deaf is through special testing that your vet can advise you about.