How can I give a sound argument described here concerning racism?

1 Answer

Answer :

answer:1. Differences in groups of people aren’t just genetic. Other influences include, diet, circumstances, culture, and education. 2. You wrote “The only reason different ethnic groups appear different is because they adapted to the environment.” but that’s an overstatement. Mutations happen randomly, and though there may be some tendency for conditions to favor certain traits over others, there are also just drifting trends that aren’t because of any adaptation or selection reasons. 3. Yes diet does affect height. Yes height can be both an advantage and a disadvantage. It’s different. There are also genetic influences. All these things are true, and I don’t see what argument is to be had about it. 4. Pygmies have their advantages. If the world were all pygmies, we wouldn’t be worried about terrorist attacks, global climate change, pollution, habitat destruction, extinction of species, GMO pollution, NSA spying, nor corrupt banks and corporations trying to own the world. 5. Just because there are differences, doesn’t mean that he or popular conceptions are correct about what they are. 6. One massive error is thinking that our concept of race is an accurate description of genetic or cultural or other kinds of traits. There are plenty of sub-groups, cross-groups, and above all every person is unique, and there are plenty of counter-examples to any trend. It sounds like this person may be overstating trends in an effort to prove a way of thinking that also overstates and misrepresents the actual relationships that the examples he chooses seem to show. I’d recommend trying to remove the argumentation aspect from it. Try to have a rule that anyone who tries to say they’re right and the other person is wrong is automatically off-base and loses a point. Stick to objective facts and statistics.

Related questions

Description : What type of adjective is highlighted Jane and Todd were involved in an argument concerning the car.?

Last Answer : Feel Free to Answer

Description : Which of the following statements concerning perioperative nutrition is true concerning the above-described patient? a. Since the patient's weight had been stable with no preoperative nutritional deficit ... feeding catheter should be placed at the time of surgery for postoperative enteral feeding

Last Answer : Answer: a Most patients undergoing elective operations are adequately nourished. Unless the patient has suffered significant preoperative malnutrition, characterized by weight loss greater than ... gastrointestinal surgery, this technique would not appear indicated in the patient described above

Description : A 16-year-old boy suffers a mid-gut volvulus with massive loss of small intestine. Which of the following statement(s) is/are true concerning his nutritional requirements and management? a. If ... above may decrease the cost of care d. TPN needs will increase after discontinuation of growth hormone

Last Answer : Answer: a, b, c Prior to the availability of TPN, most patients developing short bowel syndrome from either surgery or catastrophic event died. In selected patients, however, with ... the growth hormone did not increase TPN needs in patients once they had undergone successful gut rehabilitation

Description : Would you deem this statement, "This is our continent we were here first" as a good or bad argument for one trying to defend that there is no such thing as an illegal alien?

Last Answer : answer:In my opinion, no one group of people can lay claim to any nation-sized tract of land. Earth belongs to God, who has chosen the human race as husbandmen ( which has largely turned out to have ... a nation, is to be held in trust for future generations of mankind, not for just our own progeny.

Description : The following argument:  “ All mammals have wings.  All reptiles are mammals.  Therefore all reptiles have wings ”. A) Inductive  B) invalid  C) sound  D) Valid. 

Last Answer :  D) Valid. 

Description : A deductive argument is sound if and only if it is A) valid and all its premises are true B) invalid and all its premises are true C) is valid and one of the premise is false D) is valid and its conclusion is false. 

Last Answer : A) valid and all its premises are true 

Description : A valid deductive argument with true premises is called a ------ argument. A) sound B) unsound C) fallacious D) dilemma.  

Last Answer : A) sound 

Description : If it is possible for the premises of a deductive argument to be true and its conclusion to be false, that argument is A) Valid B) Invalid C) Indescribable D) Sound.  

Last Answer : B) Invalid

Description : The falsehood of a valid deductive argument’s conclusion guarantees that A) the argument is sound B) atleast one of the premise is false C) premises are true D) the validity is uncertain. 

Last Answer : B) atleast one of the premise is false 

Description : Which of the following statements are true? Choose from the codes given below. 1. Some arguments, while not completely valid, are almost valid. 2. A sound argument may be invalid. 3. A cogent argument may have a probably false ... Codes: (A) 1 and 2 (B) 1, 3 and 4 (C) 4 alone (D) 3 and 4

Last Answer : (D) 3 and 4

Description : Which of the following statements is correct concerning the circuits in a sound powered telephone system? A. The ringing circuit is composed of only one common wire to ground. B. The common ... connected to each station. D. The talking and calling circuits are electrically dependent upon each other.

Last Answer : Answer: B

Description : Has anyone else here ever heard Trump or Cruz described as elitists?

Last Answer : Well, you know my answer but I'll provide context. It was by a good friend who is a self described socialist and calls neocons and hard line right wingers elitist. Other times it was in ... that both follows the definition and is detogatory towards the rich upper class and the academic upper crust.

Description : What kind of trade barrier is being described here?

Last Answer : no description given**

Description : Which social science is described here Enter the correct number in the answer box. Individuals working in this discipline apply social theories to real life situations.?

Last Answer : Sociology would be the social science that applies social theories to real life situations.

Description : belt of silk runs over two metal pulleys, one of which is surrounded by a hollow metal sphere. Two electrodes, in the form of comb-shaped rows of sharp metal points, are positioned ... potential is applied to the upper pulley. A simple version of which equipment is being described here?

Last Answer : Van de Graaff generator.

Description : Malcolm has come up with the idea of a well -devised system for picking up peoples' cars while they are at work, washing and waxing them, and returning them for a fee. Having been a big ... : A)direct marketing. B)franchising. C)door-to -door retailing. D)licensing. E)speciality retailing.

Last Answer : B)franchising

Description : "To understand communication in a meeting, we need to investigate the roles, personalities and values of every participant, as well as review the minutes taken and actions resulting from previous meetings." Which ... here? (a) Socio-phychological ; (b) Cybernetic ; (c) Psychosocial ; (d) Pragmatic

Last Answer : ; (d) Pragmatic

Description : What is the difference between xenophobia and racism?

Last Answer : Xenophobia is the distrust or hatred of people who come from different countries. Racism is the distrust or hatred of someone of another ethnicity

Description : Is turning off the mic while a US veteran credits Black Americans on Memorial Day an act of racism or not?

Last Answer : Yes. Evidence of structural racism where a reference to Black contributions to American heritage is considered “distracting”.

Description : Is it possible to legislate systemic racism out of the US system?

Last Answer : “Systemic racism” is by definition something that is within the realm of legislation. Are you sure you’re asking about “systemic racism”? Do you know what that means?

Description : Is racism a public health threat?

Last Answer : Yes, for the victims of it.

Description : How seriously should we take this British royalty racism scandal?

Last Answer : Member’s of royalty are human too. Being human is a chronic fatal condition. In the end when are all rotting bones in the graveyard. -Ozzy Osbourne’s lyrics. Aladdin and Princess Jasmine both felt trapped. Anyone can feel trapped too.

Description : what do you think about western people's undercover racism?

Last Answer : [deleted]

Description : Do you think the Oscars have been awarded to black people as often as to white people (no racism intended)?

Last Answer : No. Last night two Academy Awards were awarded to black people in categories that had never had a minority recipient before. A look at recipients over time shows a tendency for white male protestants to win disproportionately more.

Description : What do you guys think about the following scenario? (alien vs racism, explained inside)

Last Answer : This doesn’t really sound like a question? Just putting a question mark at the end of a sentence doesn’t make it a question? Sounds more like a statement? In my opinion?

Description : Is racism valid?

Last Answer : Is racism, a defensible position?

Description : What if Starbucks underplayed (the racism or "racism" case) and France (the Malian hero case) events?

Last Answer : I’m not referring to the blatantly racist people by the way, of course they would be critics.

Description : What’s the worst example of racism you’ve seen in public?

Last Answer : My mother was giving some things to her cleaner’s husband and the police came and questioned him because they thought he was stealing.

Description : Are the UCLA basketball players, who shoplifted in China, also guilty of racism.

Last Answer : They thought they might not get caught in China. That’s the only explanation I can see here for such a stupid act. It has nothing to do with racism I think.

Description : What is the difference between racism and bigotry?

Last Answer : One is a subset of the other.

Description : Are you surprised at the amount of racism in the U.S.?

Last Answer : Not at all. But having lived this long, and witnessed the strides in my lifetime, I truly believe the shelf life of this particular stupidity to be predictably limited.

Description : Is racism ever justifiable?

Last Answer : I don't think it would be justifiable (meaning right, or good, or correct) but it can be understandable. If a person grows up in a neighborhood where almost everyone he sees or knows is ... kind of crap happens in all kinds of communities in which the circumstances I just mentioned are similar.

Description : Is racism just another American tradition?

Last Answer : LOL. It’s hardly uniquely American. It is everywhere on globe, including the most liberal countries. It is universal.

Description : Is lead, Pb, in drinking water truly a case of Environmental Racism?

Last Answer : answer:The issue of Environmental racism doesn't arise from those who have replaced previous generations of residents. It has more to do with efforts to mitigate lead only in white and middle class ... switching water sources to save money. The previous water source did not have a lead problem.)

Description : How do you define racism? Can a BuzzFeed community post be racist?

Last Answer : answer:Pretty sure the most racist thing on that post is the commenter who referred to black people as “Darkies”. The rest of it is just typical stupid clickbait bullshit. I really, really, REALLY don’t care which men you’re attracted to. At all.

Description : Is there any proof that the violence and racism surrounding many of Trump's rallies could be a direct result of the horrible things he's said during those rallies?

Last Answer : Proof? Fuck, man. Watch the tapes. He incites these guys like Hitler did at his rallies. What more proof does one need?

Description : Oscar nominees, people of color, affirmative action, quality acting - Do you think this is institutionalized racism?

Last Answer : answer:”If so – would that be tokenism? Voting based on the color of the actor’s skin, and not on the quality of their work?” The charge against the academy is that that they ARE voting based on the colour of the actor’s skin, and not on the quality of the work, just in the reverse.

Description : Anyone else heard enough about racism, gayness and Obama?

Last Answer : answer:Really? Racism and gay rights are at the core of day to day life for a large segment of our population, and what's been happening is important. Nothing small about it. I suppose you ... first graders, chat about the best cookie brands. Our an old folks home, compare pains and medications.

Description : Do you think this is the right way to deal with racism in the workplace?

Last Answer : answer:The man was being a total jerk, that is true. But he responded (instead of reacting emotionally) to him in a BUSINESSLIKE manner. In my husband's business he runs into this type all the ... irritation in anyway to this type of person only feeds the fire. Tell your friend good job from me!

Description : Is it possible to honor Confederate history in the US without glorifying racism? [Details]?

Last Answer : No, it is not. Just as it is not possible to honour the 3rd Reich without glorifying the Holocaust. You can not just ignore the 11 million people that were murdered in the ... the primary reason for the secession in the declaration of causes' by various southern states, including Missouri

Description : What do you think would be one of the best steps we could take toward ending poverty and racism around the world?

Last Answer : You left world peace and curing cancer off the list. I don't think there is any easy answer. Short of making every single human experience what it feels like to be on the wrong side of racism and ... teaches racism, which is going to be a stronger influence? Poverty is an even tougher nut to crack.

Description : So, is it racism if you bash your own race?

Last Answer : answer:Of course it is. I also think people take offense too easily. Anything said with hatred is bad, but making genuine jokes about a race (your own or otherwise) can result in comedy gold. Dave Chappelle is a great example. People should laugh more instead of being insulted by everything.

Description : Is there a word or a phrase for when a person sees racism where there is none?

Last Answer : Conditioned reflex?

Description : Is racism an educational failure?

Last Answer : In a way, it's a lack of education, but it's more passionate than that. If someone had never learned to read, and someone offered to teach them, they would be happy and grateful for ... person has to admit wrong in themselves and their parental figures, and be willing to change their own beliefs.

Description : Is anyone bothered by anti-white racism not being taken seriously?

Last Answer : answer:You can be a bigot toward a white person, but not racist. Bigotry is annoying and inconvenient, racism is insidious, systematic, and permeates all aspects of a society. This ... a humorous take on the issue: http://blackgirldangerous.org/new-blog/2012/11/27/9csnr2cmsrexpoxro1f16csj18zgcy

Description : Can racially tolerant whites help end racism?

Last Answer : answer:Funny, I had a similar situation to the linked video recently. Except the customer was wrongly taking offense. At a corner store, I (white guy) was behind two black teens in line. They ... to end racism. We can lessen it, but unfortunately people are easily led by emotion and tribalism.

Description : What do you think about this example of racism? Is it racism?

Last Answer : answer:I will answer the last question first. Is there really any difference? Yes and no. Yes, because the contexts are different: making fun of the way those black people speak' has a different ... from being equal. Otherwise, she, like many people in this society, is just a prejudiced dumbass.

Description : How do you define racism?

Last Answer : I have a low threshold, I consider all your examples racist. I would define racism as opinions or actions based on the assumption that certain “races” are superior to others, regardless of whether that race is your own.

Description : Racism- alive or dead in your area?

Last Answer : If you’re Hispanic, you’re targeted in my new town. In my last two homes, there were a lot of people friendly with the KKK or what they stood for.

Description : Do you think racism will ever go away?

Last Answer : It's interesting you are ranting against people who generalize about race but then you go on to say you think People in general are stupid. That may not be technically racist but it ... process gain respect and acceptance into the greater community. That goes for everyone regardless of their race.