Is psychotherapy a money making scam?

1 Answer

Answer :

It’s not exactly a scam, but it is pretty expensive and can often not have any results. But for some people it can be very valuable and worth it. At least they didn’t prescribe you mind-altering drugs. ;-) Whether it’s “worth it” really depends on the patient and the psychiatrist and the situation and who’s paying for it and how much. Apart from people who do need medication or other situations, my understanding (especially from reading the preface to the book Focusing by Eugene Gendlin, which says as much), people who make psychological progress from psychotherapy (one of the main things psychiatrists do, but not everything they do), are mainly processing their own material themselves, which is something that a good patient-therapist match can facilitate, but that can also be done alone or with others. The good psychiatrists I have seen have been useful and valuable for their professional expertise as smart balanced impartial uninvolved listeners who will let you say practically anything and occasionally offer insights or information, but are mainly giving great safe listening and attention. I appreciate that, but won’t spend $100+/hour for it now because I’m no longer depressed/upset/etc and I have learned various other techniques and resources for processing my material, which cost less, or nothing, and/or that I can do myself. I particularly like that Focusing book as an easy intro to something you can do yourself. Also learning Holistic Peer Counseling. And Feldenkrais awareness through movement classes.

Related questions

Description : How long is psychotherapy?

Last Answer : It lasts as long as you want it to.

Description : How do you relax?

Last Answer : Go outside and walk around . I am on my computer too much at times and my upper back, neck and shoulders start to hurt, due to bad posture and leaning into the computer. ( apparently the ... up Balance is important in ones life otherwise too much inactivity will have negative effects on one's body.

Description : Do you know of any reliable online therapy service?

Last Answer : My daughter uses betterhelp.com. She has had good experiences with it. She has had a few therapists, and she said changing therapists is easy. That is important, because it sometimes takes a few ... virtual therapy can work, but you've got to be even more involved than in the traditional setting.

Description : Is it unethical for a licensed therapist to have a weekly show on YouTube?

Last Answer : Forgive me for not understanding the point here, but why would that be unethical?

Description : What punishment, should a person who groped someone receive?

Last Answer : I think that AT&T bears some of the blame for groping. For years, they had the advertisement Read Out and Touch Someone , which may have tacitly implied that unwanted touching was an acceptable ... start getting into penalties, let's try and classify the offenses in some cogent and consistent way.

Description : Have you tried any Hypnosis session?

Last Answer : Yes. Both my wife and I went to a hypnotist, nutritionist. We both lost about fifty pounds each and got off most of our meds.

Description : Just so you know I finally got a therapist so I'm starting to get real help with all the BS so this might mean bye or no?

Last Answer : Why would this mean bye? You can still come here and ask or answer questions. You can become a valued member of our community.

Description : Heard any Trump jokes lately?

Last Answer : Someone here called Drumpf a genius.

Description : Do you believe in past life regression?

Last Answer : Where I have a big problem with it is that people who say they are in touch with their previous lives are all precious snowflakes that have been chosen, and the rest of us are just unfortunate slobs.

Description : What are some things a client should NOT say to a Licensed Social Worker?

Last Answer : This lifestyle difference absolutely won’t dampen the therapy process if she is at all a competent practitioner. If a personal belief difference is so dramatic as to affect the therapy, she will refer you to another person.

Description : Do you know of anyone diagnosed with any form of cancer who decided to go it alone with no conventional therapy?

Last Answer : answer:I knew 2 people who didn't go with conventional medical treatment after diagnosis. One drank wheat grass juice, ate sparingly an organic vegan diet and passed in six months. The other chose not ... , I imagine they were diagnosed in late stages anyway, and were likely too far gone to treat.

Description : Has anyone else lied to their therapist?

Last Answer : Ask your therapist what would be best for you. They unusually have a feel for what works and what doesn’t.

Description : How do you know if you should go to therapy/couple therapy?

Last Answer : answer:I'm pretty sure that most people who go to therapy occasionally feel like their problems are petty and they should be able to handle them on their own. I've been trying to cut down on seeing ... at all. But after that, I lucked out and found a wonderful therapist who has been very helpful.

Description : Do you see the necessity in couples staying together for the sake of the children?

Last Answer : If the couple is really toxic, I feel divorce is better.

Description : How do you "fire" your therapist?

Last Answer : answer:I have done this, and this is how I went about it. Sit down with a pencil and paper, and come up with as many WH as you can. Ask How did you decide to get into this field? ... inform your prospective therapist that you want to interview him or her, and ask if this would be a good time.

Description : How do you get your inner child to grow up?

Last Answer : You don’t. The whole point of having an inner child is to keep you from turning into an sad old man (person).

Description : What would you look for in a therapist?

Last Answer : answer:I ask them what their philosophy is. Where do they fit in the pantheon of psychology. I ask them how they relate to their patients-looking for a sense of how they interact, how cool or close they ... meeting. I just expect to figure out if I'm willing to try a few more sessions with them.

Description : Are there any therapy clinics or retreats that help straight people be gay?

Last Answer : No, because there is no social premium on straight people becoming gay so there would not be any customers.

Description : Does anyone have any experience with "conscious discipline"?

Last Answer : answer:Just a warning, research the meds they want you to give your son THROUGHLY before you give them to him. So many just take the pills a doctor orders without second thoughts. ... discipline here is some information in video format: http://video.google.com/videoplay?docid=-4482433245240650484#

Description : Have not been Able to Fully Bend knees since year 2000, Is it good to keep Trying or dangerous?

Last Answer : oh man….go and see a physiotherapist. I think it would be dangerous to keep trying without the correct supervision and prescribed exercised to strengthen your muscles.

Description : How to start a successful therapeutic (mental) business?

Last Answer : Step 1— lots and lots of school then Collage than University. Family therapy sooo your 13 now?, you should be good to go to step-2 by the time your 30–40

Description : Does hypnosis really work as a therapy?

Last Answer : It really varies depending on the individual, but yes, some people find it helpful. Hypnosis by a hypnotherapist didn’t do much for me, but I do use a form of self-hypnosis to deal with anxiety and panic attacks.

Description : What has your experience been with formal psychoanalysis?

Last Answer : Formal Freudian analysis? Yes, six sessions in the late 1970s. I found them to be a complete waste of time, nothing more than verbal sparring matches , Thirty five years later I was ... talking methods require some level of trust and autistic-types will seldom offer that trust to anyone.

Description : How do you find a good therapist?

Last Answer : Ask your primary care physician. They are used to making referrals and usually know of quality clinicians. You could also contact the psychiatric unit at a hospital. They will have recommendations for individual clinicians or outpatient clinics that specifically treat anxiety disorders.

Description : Has anyone heard of/used hypnotherapy to stop "living in the past"?

Last Answer : I don't know about hypnotherapy specifically for this issue, but I think that anything that helps you move through your thoughts, feelings and issues having to do with the past can help you live in the ... can write, therapy, Rx drugs, yoga, AND hypnotherapy. Fight hard, girl! You can do this!

Description : Does anyone here have BPT?

Last Answer : Marsha Linehan at the University of Washington. It's not easy, and it's expensive, because if you can get into the program at all, you must have a lot of attention: groups, your own therapist ... quickly. But this program truly helps. And nothing else has ever done so very consistently. Good luck.

Description : What do you look for in a therapist?

Last Answer : answer:Intellectual acuity and mental agility; if this is someone I’m going to be spending some time with, I want him or her to appreciate wordplay and thoughtplay. Empathy and understanding for the situations I’m likely to be struggling with.

Description : How should a therapist advertise to you?

Last Answer : answer:Tough question. So much of the advertising process is word of mouth and the temperature of the first session or two. Plus, whether the patient is new to therapy or has done it before is a ... marketing for a large, integrated delivery system, so that's where a lot of this is coming from.

Description : Has anyone heard of, or successfully utilitzed, the book, Getting the Love You Want?

Last Answer : I just googled it and it’s all over google and amazon if you want a copy. I’m just a research nerd, I haven’t read it. The previews for it look great though! I hope that helped.

Description : How do people pay for therapy?

Last Answer : Lots of therapists have a sliding scale for people without insurance- also, people licensed as PhDs charge much more than professional counselors, mental health counselors, or social workers. Those people ... the same education level as PhDs, and just didn't pursue the higher level of licensing.

Description : How do you stop an addiction?

Last Answer : You stop, suffer the withdrawal, and take care not to relapse.

Description : Do you believe in the concept of repressed memories?

Last Answer : answer:I have a dear friend whose entire family was torn apart by a repressed memory her older brother had. He somehow hooked up with a psychologist who convinced him that awful things happened to him ... the same since. My short answer? No, I do not believe in the concept of repressed memories.

Description : What are legitimate ways to make online money Nothing like those scam apps that you play and have a small chance of making money.?

Last Answer : There has been some miscommunication with my college and their students. Because of this now, I need to build up a good amount of money by mid-December. So now I need to be able to make that ... every 30 minutes!" sort of deal. Does anybody have any reasonable ways to make money online from home?

Description : Is psychotherapy useless?

Last Answer : answer:It’s helped me. Those “problems locked away in my mind” wouldn’t stay locked and were causing me a great deal of pain. I’d much rather talk through those problems than medicate them away. Psychotherapy, in it’s various permutations, saved my life.

Description : Can someone who went on a shooting spree let's say, refuse psychotherapy and still get out of the mental institution?

Last Answer : Are you referring to Michael Meyers?

Description : For those of you who underwent psychotherapy (talk therapy), how did it help you?

Last Answer : It taught me how to eliminate old thought patterns that were destructive. It gave me a very valuable insight into the person who had set those patterns (and installed those pesky buttons). It taught me a ... inside. So much more, but that's the basic stuff. It essentially saved my quality of life.

Description : What are some low cost options for psychotherapy?

Last Answer : NAMI.org has resources for sliding scale, low or no-cost services. Hospitals have clinics and charity care. Medicaid covers medications, but I’m unsure about therapy. Support groups are another option.

Description : Which diseases require psychotherapy ?

Last Answer : Psychotherapy has to be given for all the complications of mental illness.

Description : Which of the following is used in the treatment of cancer? (1) Physiotherapy (2) Chemotherapy (3) Electrotherapy (4) Psychotherapy

Last Answer : (2) Chemotherapy Explanation: Chemotherapy (or CTX) is a category of cancer treatment that uses chemical substances, especially one or more anti-cancer drugs (chemotherapeutic agents) that are given as ... act by killing cells that divide rapidly, one of the main properties of most cancer cells.

Description : Which of the following is used in the treatment of cancer? (1) Physiotherapy (2) Chemotherapy (3) Electrotherapy (4) Psychotherapy

Last Answer : (2) Chemotherapy Explanation: Chemotherapy (or CTX) is a category of cancer treatment that uses chemical substances, especially one or more anti-cancer drugs (chemotherapeutic agents) that are given as ... act by killing cells that divide rapidly, one of the main properties of most cancer cells.

Description : Using Teleconferencing to deliver psychotherapy is termed as i) Telepathology ii) Telepsychiatry iii) Telepsychology iv) Psychology

Last Answer : ii) Telepsychiatry

Description : Which of the following is used in the treatment of cancer ? (1) Physiotherapy (2) Chemotherapy (3) Electrotherapy (4) Psychotherapy

Last Answer : Chemotherapy

Description : Is there actually any proper non scam way to make money online?

Last Answer : answer:You can make money, but only by coming up with your own business. Any of those make money from home sites are going to be scams that only make money for the people running the site. Learn ... require hard work, skills/talent etc. Anything that requires no skill isn't going to be worth it.

Description : How long has this "internet money laundering" scam been going on?

Last Answer : Its a 419 scam (probably from Nigeria). You give them your bank details – they take your money.

Description : I just started to dive into online money..which ways can I make money while I sleep Is this even possible or just a bunch of people trying to scam you?

Last Answer : 2Ti 3:1  Know also this, that in the last days shall come dangerous times. Contact UsGlobe:+63 915 189 7007Smart:+63 918 438 8988Sun:+63 943 411 [email protected]

Description : Is the Money Market Accounts program a scam?

Last Answer : No, Money Market accounts are not a scam. MMs are actually a very safe investment, offering a small, yet steady, rate of interest.

Description : if India ever falls under US jurisdiction, what punishment do you think we should give to the scam-callers?

Last Answer : Isn't falling under American jurisdiction punishment enough????

Description : Is selling discounted US stamps a scam or not?

Last Answer : I Googled and got my Are discount postage stamps legitimate? Postal officials warn that deeply discounted postage stamps may be a scam. ... The number of counterfeit stamps being sold online is ... are peddling them on social media, through e-commerce and third-party vendors.Jan 7, 2022

Description : Is Publishers Clearing House a scam operation?

Last Answer : Probably just someone fraudulently identifying themselves as a PCH representative. Like the idiots who call and text people claiming to represent the IRS or Social Security Administration.

Description : Can I be charged for a sexting scam?

Last Answer : Did the girl say she was under age when you were texting her? I wouldn’t pay the father for anything. That’s blackmail.