Is there really an advantage to eating small meals, every 3-4 hours, as opposed to only eating when you are hungry?

1 Answer

Answer :

answer:Technically there is. When you eat, your metabolism goes up. It follows that the more often you eat, your metabolism stays higher. So yes, there is a physiological advantage. There is also a psychological advantage because if you plan to eat small specific, healthy meals, you will not get hungry, crave donuts, go to the machine, buy them, eat them, and subsequently gain weight. You’ll know that you have an apple and a tablespoon of peanut butter in your desk/kitchen/wherever that are just waiting for you to eat them at 4:00, and you’re not THAT hungry, because you just ate a few hours ago. If you wait until you’re hungry to eat, sometimes you don’t realize how hungry you are, you binge, eat more than you mean to, and then you feel bad, and it can just lead to this whole chain of events derailing your diet. That is the gist of what I’ve read in textbooks, magazines, etc. On the other hand, you asked about personal experience. For me, the times in my life I’ve lost weight the most easily were when I worked waiting tables during the summers while I was in college. I would wake up late, around 10:00 or 11:00 am, eat a substantial meal, run errands or exercise, then eat a snack around 3:00 or 4:00 before I went to work, and I hardly ate anything else the rest of the day. The first few weeks I would be starving from smelling all that food and being used to eating dinner around 7:00, but once I got used to it, I didn’t even get hungry in the evenings. I lost about 10 lbs in 2 months both years I did it. (Of course I would gain it back over the course of the school year, so I never came out ahead in the end, but today I still weigh the same as I did when I was in high school, so I’m satisfied.) I doubt that that kind of schedule would work for everyone, but there’s the official line for you, and my personal experience. Best of luck figuring out what works best for you!

Related questions

Description : Do you eat meals by the clock? Or when you are hungry?

Last Answer : By my bodies clock, it tells me when I’m hungry.

Description : How can I go without eating for four hours without becoming hungry?

Last Answer : Eat consciously the whole day. Meditate. Go four hours without eating.

Description : What's worse: Eating when you're not hungry, eating right before sleep, or only eating one meal a day?

Last Answer : Eating 6 small portioned meals a day is considered the best way to stay lean. Eat breakfast, lunch, and dinner and have healthy snacks in between making it 6 meals. Try to eat at least 2 hours before you sleep.

Description : Why does eating properly make one more hungry?

Last Answer : You're accustomed to regular meals and your bod reacts accordingly. You should also consider that what you do or don't eat can significantly effect your mental and emotional state. I can tell immediately if my wife or ... away. Cause if you don't, you're gonna pay, at the hands of the one you love.

Description : How do I stop eating between meals and eating food that's bad for you?

Last Answer : Just count those “eating between meals” as meals themselves. Problem solved!

Description : How do I stop myself from feeling hungry at odd hours?

Last Answer : Instead of eating large meals, eat smaller ones throughout the day. Always have tiny snacks around to eat too.

Description : Is it possible to create a three meals a day menu that you could eat every single day?

Last Answer : answer:Yes, it could be done. And there are a lot of people who eat the same breakfast everyday, and the same lunch everyday. They could do that with dinner also. And it's not that hard to ... and calorie appropriate diet. My question to you is why would anyone want to live such a boring life?

Description : Is it better to have small snacks throughout the day, or separated large meals?

Last Answer : answer:Small bits throughout the day helps speed up one’s metabolism. But personally, I prefer the 3 big meals because I like the feeling of being comfortably full.

Description : What does it mean when you're really, really hungry but nothing sounds good?

Last Answer : Appetite is unpredictable and mercurial. For six weeks after my major surgery this fall, nothing seemed appetizing. The anesthia lingered on and on.

Description : Is there a strategic advantage to Russia attacking Ukraine in mid-winter, as opposed summer or fall?

Last Answer : Ras Putin is drawing on his own nations history as a cautionary measure. If his plan backfires and he starts a major war, and the NATO alliance gets any ideas about chasing his armies back to ... drops, but he has surface to air missile installations to rely on I'm sure. Just speculating here.

Description : Do we really need 3 square meals a day?

Last Answer : Actually, a lot of health-oriented folks suggest 5 small meals a day.

Last Answer : English Hunger is the best sauce.

Description : Why do some people fill hungry after eating an apple?

Last Answer : It is surely related to having an acidic stomach. If a person has this stomach condition, he or she will be feeling hungry just consuming the apples. The best thing is to let them eat something before having this fruit. This is common for those who have 'peptic ulcer.'

Description : Why there is pain after eating fatty meals?

Last Answer : because

Description : If a restaurant requires its customers to pay for their meals before eating the customer must .?

Last Answer : prepay, for study island

Description : Eating Smaller Meals on a GERD Diet ?

Last Answer : Gastroesophageal reflux disease (GERD) is a disease that causes patients to suffer from chronic heartburn. While there are standard foods, such as fried or acidic foods, to avoid on a GERD diet, ... large quantities of stomach acid. Many smaller meals reduce this risk and result in more comfort.

Description : Losing Weight By Eating Weight Watchers Meals?

Last Answer : Weight Watchers is one of the most popular diet plans out there and has been around for decades. The diet plan consists of a points system, which allows a person to eat a set amount of food each day ... it easy to find food that you will actually enjoy. Unlike most other diet plans, you do not

Description : When you are hungry, do you always eat as soon as possible, or do you often wait several hours?

Last Answer : If I have a snack available at the time, I’m gonna hit that, you bet. I try to keep something handy when I’m away from home because it’s really a pain when the shakes come and you got nothing and are forced to hang on until a more substantial meal is possible. Even a small bag of peanuts will work.

Description : As opposed to being born that way, how does a person become allergic to nuts? Can it be from eating too many of them?

Last Answer : I don’t think people become allergic to nuts by eating too many nuts.

Description : What are the pros and cons of eating canned vegetables as opposed to fresh or frozen?

Last Answer : To clarify .any veggies are better than no veggies. Beyond that, veggies in a can will frequently have some kind of additive to preserve or stabilize it for the longevity that you mention. Salt is ... from fertilization process). All-in-all there really isn't a problem w/ canned veggies, however .

Description : Every famine begins with me. Each fight I'll be the first you see. Though food can never come without, what forest fire beginnings are all about. Fears begin with me it is true, and when I come I'll bring ... with the hungry I wont be found. Yet with each new life I'll be around. What am I? -Riddles

Last Answer : The letter F.

Description : Angry and Hungry are two words ending in 'gry' There are three words, (Using popular terminology) in the English Language, that end in 'GRY'. . What is the third word? The word is something that everyone uses every day. If you have listened carefully, I have already told you what it is. -Riddles

Last Answer : Answer is terminology. (It's the third word ending in gry. Usin(g) popula(r) teminolog(y)

Description : McDonald's and KFC satisfy hungry consumers in every hemisphere. This is an example of VU Cafeteria A)globalisation. B)customisation. C)internationalisation. D)regionalisation.

Last Answer : A)globalisation.

Description : Have you ever been so hungry that you couldn't eat?

Last Answer : No.

Description : Why would a person keep encouraging their babies or kids to eat after the kids indicated they were no longer hungry?

Last Answer : I hope you weren't at McDonalds and it was their salty fries he was trying to stuff down a 9 month old. I think babies sometimes play a little game where they turn their head away and giggle and ... are still hungry. This patent sounds like he went a little overboard. Maybe he's a first time dad.

Description : Have you ever been hungry with no means of satisfying your need?

Last Answer : No, luckily.

Description : Are you hungry?

Last Answer : (burp) No, I’ve just eaten…

Description : In a typical month how many nights do you go to bed hungry?

Last Answer : I think that what the majority of us thing of as “hunger” is not what real hunger is. I think what we experience is not the same as what someone (for example, a prisoner in North Korea) who is truly hungry experiences.

Description : Do you eat at a certain time or do you eat when hungry?

Last Answer : A little of both. I typically eat when I’m hungry, but then we have dinner when I get home from work, so that is sort of at a certain time. But on weekends, I most certainly don’t have eating schedules.

Description : When is the last night that you have gone to sleep hungry, or wanting more food?

Last Answer : answer:Almost every night, but for neither reason. It's simply a lifestyle thing. I never get hungry mid-day. Unless I'm meeting a friend, I don't eat lunch. This isn't deliberate; my body sends ... hungry, but I won't eat that late. The hungry sensation isn't strong enough to keep me awake.

Description : Reality compassion check: when was the last time you personally fed a hungry homeless person?

Last Answer : answer:He’s sitting on the couch playing Wii with my son, right now. Chicken soup today.

Description : Why am I so hungry ALL THE TIME?

Last Answer : Could it be that it’s because some foods are designed to actually make you hungrier?

Description : Microwaveable White Castle cheeseburgers. How hungry do people have to be to actually eat this?

Last Answer : These Guys

Description : How can I be still hungry after spending $800 a month for food?

Last Answer : answer:Congratulations of the weight loss. However, I suggest your approach isn't balanced. Eat breakfast in two sessions, one half when you wake up and one half for a snack. Get regular sleep and ... green leafy vegetables and a little more fruit (one or two pieces a day) and still lose weight.

Description : When you get hungry, do you eat right then and there, or do you fix something that takes a while to be ready?

Last Answer : answer:I used to delay eating, but mostly because I was either lazy or somehow hoping it would go away so I wouldn't then feel guilty about eating crap. But that usually ensured I'd eat ... 't satisfy me because I'm craving the crap. Probably an answer completely irrelevant to what you asked.

Description : Do you like feeling a little hungry?

Last Answer : I have a complicated and profound relationship with food, because I love it but the type 1 diabetes means I (ideally) have to be very mindful of what I eat, and how much of it, and how many grams of ... who just consider food to be fuel. I think it's one of the most basic pleasures of being alive.

Description : I'm a 23 year old female who's ALWAYS hungry! Help?

Last Answer : Do you possibly have Sensory Perception Disorder ? I have heard of kids that have fifths also commonly have SPD. SPD many to either have zero hunger cues or an abundance of hunger cues or a mix of both in adulthood.

Description : Why is it I'm hungry for certain foods at different times?

Last Answer : Cravings and hunger are not the same thing.

Description : What does it mean when I've eaten plenty, but my stomach's telling me I'm still hungry?

Last Answer : answer:Sounds like most fast food meals, especially McDonald's - but not limited to. You really get hungry after Chinese, but again, not limited to. The current thought is it is due to certain types of ... give you a lot more energy, while at the same time keeping you full. (Source: the Internet)

Description : Why am I always so hungry in the morning when I eat late at night?

Last Answer : Plummeting blood sugar levels?

Description : What do you do when it's time for a meal but you're not hungry?

Last Answer : I don’t eat. I’ve skipped dinner when I haven’t felt like it. Hasn’t caused any harm so far lol.

Description : Hungry, but no appetite for weeks now... is it in my head?

Last Answer : Oh, I was all ready & primed with the pregnant hit, dash it all ;¬} Maybe you crave a radical change in your diet. Just a thought.

Description : Should you eat regularly even if you aren't hungry?

Last Answer : answer:I’m not a medical expert, but it’s probably a good idea. My appetite doesn’t match my body’s needs, I get headaches that remind me. When I was cooking for others the imposed schedule kept me on track. Welome to ask-public!

Description : Why do I get hungry so early in the day?

Last Answer : Try having a bowl of oatmeal and a piece of fruit for breakfast.That keeps me going for quite awhile:)

Description : Hungry (peaceful) aliens have landed. You're in charge of organising a banquet to showcase the finest cooking on earth. What's on the menu and who is cooking it?

Last Answer : It blatently has to be Heston Blumenthal, one of his crazy feasts like the ones he does on channel 4. Maybe a full sized Hansel and Grettel house or something along those lines. mmmmm

Description : Do you ever get so hungry but you don't know what you're hungry for?

Last Answer : No, usually I know what I’m craving and know that I shouldn’t be having any of it, :).

Description : I'm a wee bit hungover (and the tummy is a little queasy), but, I'm hungry. Is it safe to eat Mexican?

Last Answer : Well, it almost looks thee same going down as it will coming up! (I think I might wait a bit.)

Description : Do any of you ever feel hungry after putting away a big ol' plate of pasta?

Last Answer : Not any more. I can remember feeling that, though. Now if I get hungry I just munch on a helpless fetus that I forced a grandmother to abort.

Description : What can you cook right now if hungry unexpected company comes over?

Last Answer : Ha, we had chinese food last night! We aways order enough for leftovers so come on over.

Description : Why do I get FITS OF RAGE when I am extremely hungry?

Last Answer : its called low blood sugar