If you or someone you know has or had breast cancer - what did the doctor say about eating soy products?

If you or someone you know has or had breast cancer - what did the doctor say about eating soy products?
by

1 Answer

Answer :

My Oncologist says always to err on the side of caution. His readings have left him telling his patients to eat it rarely or never. He believes that there haven’t been enough definitive studies done. I am a 13+ year survivor and skip the soy, except for raw edamame beans, which are not fermented.
by

Related questions

Do you know anyone positive for the BRCA gene who doesn't have a family history of breast cancer?

Description : Do you know anyone positive for the BRCA gene who doesn't have a family history of breast cancer?

Last Answer : Typically, the only reason to get tested for one of the BRCA gene mutations is if you have a family history of breast cancer or if you have breast cancer and want to know if it was inherited ... 't necessarily mean he/she carries a BRCA gene mutation. Only 15-20% of breast cancers are inherited.

What is stage three breast cancer?

Description : What is stage three breast cancer?

Last Answer : answer:Yes, it is in the lymph nodes. There are 3 categorizations for Stage 3 breast cancer, so it’s difficult for me to say what part of Stage 3 she has. Obviously, it’s great that the cancer was found and is being treated ASAP.

Small survey: Did you know men can get breast cancer?

Description : Small survey: Did you know men can get breast cancer?

Last Answer : Small Yes.

Do breast biopsies usually confirm cancer?

Description : Do breast biopsies usually confirm cancer?

Last Answer : I’m sure some of the doctors on here will be able to help you more, but from friends’ experiences, a biopsy does not always indicate cancer. There can often be benign cysts in the breast as well. Good luck!

If someone invented a pill to cut a cancer risk in half, would you take it?

Description : If someone invented a pill to cut a cancer risk in half, would you take it?

Last Answer : If I was a woman about to loose a breast(or both) and ovaries, I'd probably try the drug. But I'm sure there was a good reason why Ms. Birkhold chose not too. If I had cancer it couldn't ... on taking medications, because I have no illnesses. But if I did, it wouldn't hurt to try and help myself.

Eating soy products if one is a breast cancer survivor?

Description : Eating soy products if one is a breast cancer survivor?

Last Answer : Did your oncologist say why he thought you should limit eating soy?

In cases where a person has surgery to go from male to female should insurance companies be compelled to cover mammograms?

Description : In cases where a person has surgery to go from male to female should insurance companies be compelled to cover mammograms?

Last Answer : answer:Interesting question. Where it fails is that men are susceptible to breast cancer as well as women; it's just less common. If the transgender female has insurance, why shouldn't she be ... issue when it comes to getting a mammogram, especially if there is any concern about breast cancer.

Do you agree with the Susan G. Komen Foundation's decision to defund Planned Parenthood?

Description : Do you agree with the Susan G. Komen Foundation's decision to defund Planned Parenthood?

Last Answer : I am horrified by this. It will do enormous damage to the lives of countless young women, as well as promoting the entirely false idea that Planned Parenthood is primarily about abortion. What a stunning display of ignorance.

How should Raymond respond to this?

Description : How should Raymond respond to this?

Last Answer : Should this man be able to sue the government for discrimination? Yes.

Why are my breasts so sore?

Description : Why are my breasts so sore?

Last Answer : Could be mastitis.

Do mammograms really help?

Description : Do mammograms really help?

Last Answer : They say that early detection is the key. The earlier they detect it, the better they can treat it and therefore reduce the numbers of deaths. The best way to find these lumps is to ... have developed into something necessarily life threatening in the person's lifetime. But, why take that chance?

What is the risk of eating a lot of soy?

Description : What is the risk of eating a lot of soy?

Last Answer : I am not sure about studies, but I have always suscribed to the moderation theme for eating. I would say that if all you are eating all the time is soy, probably not the best thing for your health.

I stopped eating meat one year ago but still crave it all the time, especially burgers. I've tried all the different brands of soy and veggie burgers but none come close to the real thing. Please send me suggestions before I fall off the wagon. BBQ season is here....my torture! Help!

Description : I stopped eating meat one year ago but still crave it all the time, especially burgers. I've tried all the different brands of soy and veggie burgers but none come close to the real thing. Please send me suggestions before I fall off the wagon. BBQ season is here....my torture! Help!

Last Answer : answer:Try these. sorry, iwamoto, beatcha to it. ;-P Uh oh. Calling [at]iwamoto! I know you’ve linked those as being 100% vegetarian… but I cannot find a link to the actual product. Just a picture alone isn’t very helpful and so I hope you can pull my ass outta this fire I just jumped into.

Why do my soy products taste like fish?

Description : Why do my soy products taste like fish?

Last Answer : answer:Are you cooking with canola oil? Canola oil is high in omega 3 fatty acids, which makes things smell like fish (which are also high in the same fatty acids). You ain’t lived until you’ve tried waffles that smell like fish!

Does soy or soy products (such as tofu) contain gluten? Does soybean oil contain gluten?

Description : Does soy or soy products (such as tofu) contain gluten? Does soybean oil contain gluten?

Last Answer : answer:A soybean is exactly that a green bean. You can shell them from the pod and eat them raw as a delicious snack. The soybean plant is an annual plant native to Southeast Asia. It has oblong pods ... product a chewy texture. (You can do the research on how a soy bean becomes a block of tofu.)

Does anyone know where (or what companies) I can get fermented soy products?

Description : Does anyone know where (or what companies) I can get fermented soy products?

Last Answer : Have you tried a local Asian/Japanese food market? Are there any in your area? Barring that, look online for tempeh, miso, natto and pickled tofu and the name of your town. The local purveyors should pop up.

Has anyone ever run across info suggesting that soy products might actually be harmful?

Description : Has anyone ever run across info suggesting that soy products might actually be harmful?

Last Answer : answer:I've heard too much soy can cause increased estrogen levels, but I don't know how harmful that might be. I knew a guy who had a lot of soy in his diet and he became really emotional, most ... this a couple months back. Might want to try doing a quick search to see if anything pops up. :)

Are soy dairy products more expensive than regular dairy products?

Description : Are soy dairy products more expensive than regular dairy products?

Last Answer : I have no definitive answer, but typically healthy products, from small companies, do tend to be more pricey. If you miss cheese, the soy cheese is not going to do it for you. I'm lactose intolerant, ... tried soy cheese, it did not compare; in other words, it did not satisfy my craving. Good luck.

What soy milk is an appropriate substitute for dairy products?

Description : What soy milk is an appropriate substitute for dairy products?

Last Answer : Need answer

Where can I purchase soy products online?

Description : Where can I purchase soy products online?

Last Answer : There are many good places online to buy soy products. This is the website that my family and i use most often... http://www.stonyfield.com/ Good luck!

____ flour has been used for many products as a substitute flour for individuals with an allergy to wheat flour. a. Cake c. Bread b. Rice d. Soy

Description : ____ flour has been used for many products as a substitute flour for individuals with an allergy to wheat flour. a. Cake c. Bread b. Rice d. Soy

Last Answer : b. Rice

I have narrow stools, black blotches in my stool that is thick, sometimes just tarry stools. I have no weight loss though, I have had breast cancer. Does it sound like I have colon cancer?

Description : I have narrow stools, black blotches in my stool that is thick, sometimes just tarry stools. I have no weight loss though, I have had breast cancer. Does it sound like I have colon cancer?

Last Answer : I have narrow stools, black blotches in my stool that is thick and attached to the stool, sometimes just tarry stools. I have no weight loss though, I have had Breast cancer. Does it sound like I have colon Cancer?

I had my right breast and the sentinel node removed after a byopsy removed a mammory glad with cancer. The pathology report of the breast and node showed no cancer cells. I have some family cancer hist and my dr wants me to take chemo and I dont want to?

Description : I had my right breast and the sentinel node removed after a byopsy removed a mammory glad with cancer. The pathology report of the breast and node showed no cancer cells. I have some family cancer hist and my dr wants me to take chemo and I dont want to?

Last Answer : You go to an expert, assuming.... I go to SCCA in seattle. If they recommend something, I think you should do it. I have been a nurse for over 35 years... and have known people who did ... advice.. and go for several opinions. I am in chemo now and feel reassured my treatment will extend my life.

The nurse recognizes which of the following statements as accurately reflecting a risk factor for breast cancer? a) Mother affected by cancer before 60 years of age Risk for breast cancer increases twofold if first-degree female relatives (sister, mother, or daughter) had breast cancer.

Description : The nurse recognizes which of the following statements as accurately reflecting a risk factor for breast cancer? a) Mother affected by cancer before 60 years of age Risk for breast cancer increases ... in women who consume even one drink daily and doubles among women drinking three drinks daily.

Last Answer : a) Mother affected by cancer before 60 years of age Risk for breast cancer increases twofold if first-degree female relatives (sister, mother, or daughter) had breast cancer.

Pain in Breast: When to Call the Doctor?

Description : Pain in Breast: When to Call the Doctor?

Last Answer : Breast pain is one of the most common complaints women talk to their doctors about. Pain in breasts, also known as mastalgia, is a common pain that can either be cyclical in nature or non-cyclical. It ... do a full exam and order tests such as a mammogram to rule out serious causes of your pain.

What is Breast Cancer?

Description : What is Breast Cancer?

Last Answer : Be aggressive in seeking treatment from your doctor for this. We had to go through hospice care with my s/o’s mother. Not nice for anyone. Get screening for it, clinical breast exams, and be diligent.

Inflammatory Breast Cancer: Paranoid or Careful?

Description : Inflammatory Breast Cancer: Paranoid or Careful?

Last Answer : Do your boobs usually get sore around your period? You said it started today, so it seems to me that that is really likely to be the cause. I know it's different for me every month, some months I ... . I would stop googling it if I were you, that will probably help. Hope you feel better about it.

Have you ever done a Breast Cancer Walk or other walk for charity, and if so, how was it?

Description : Have you ever done a Breast Cancer Walk or other walk for charity, and if so, how was it?

Last Answer : answer:I did one of the three-day walks a few years ago (approx. 60 miles in three days). Yes, there were hundreds of people, maybe thousands, who participated, and it was very exhilirating. It was ... . To complete such a task was very rewarding, and I felt a real connection to it. Good luck!

Is the Susan G. Komen for the Cure campaign putting a dent in breast cancer statistics?

Description : Is the Susan G. Komen for the Cure campaign putting a dent in breast cancer statistics?

Last Answer : The president of the foundation makes a half a million dollars per year, according to Charity Navigator. That’s a whole lot of money and that’s why I won’t donate to that organization or go out of my way to purchase products with the pink ribbon.

Is it true that epilepsy kills as many people per year as breast cancer?

Description : Is it true that epilepsy kills as many people per year as breast cancer?

Last Answer : answer:Okay. It took some detective work, but I think the short answer is: epilepsy actually kills more. If you trust this wikipedia table, epilepsy accounted for 0.22% of all human deaths ... global deaths simply because in many countries, women are unlikely to live long enough to get it.

Should women take chemo drugs to prevent breast cancer even when they're healthy?

Description : Should women take chemo drugs to prevent breast cancer even when they're healthy?

Last Answer : Unnecessary medication rarely ends well. :\

Does breast cancer get too much publicity now?

Description : Does breast cancer get too much publicity now?

Last Answer : answer:You probably wouldn’t think so if you had it. or lost a mother/sister/daughter/aunt/friend/wife to it

What are the first symptoms of Breast Cancer?

Description : What are the first symptoms of Breast Cancer?

Last Answer : There is Paget's disease that starts as a rash on the breast, but is cancer. I have very limited knowledge on the subject. It is fairly rare, but that does not mean someone can't have it. I ... checked. Although, if it is small and round like a typical mole I doubt it is something to worry about.

So, what does the collective think about the new guidelines for detecting breast cancer?

Description : So, what does the collective think about the new guidelines for detecting breast cancer?

Last Answer : I am concerned that it opens the door to insurance companies denying payment for mammograms to those who still wish to take a more proactive stance or who have high risk factors and wish to begin regular screening earlier.

Turning a disability into a gift - What do you think about employing blind people to help detect breast cancer?

Description : Turning a disability into a gift - What do you think about employing blind people to help detect breast cancer?

Last Answer : Sounds amazing. If it works, then they should use it as much as possible.

I just found out my aunt has breast cancer. What is the best way to show my support?

Description : I just found out my aunt has breast cancer. What is the best way to show my support?

Last Answer : Tell her you're thinking about her, and that you're there for her if there's anything you can do. Don't tell her it will be all right-you can't guarantee that. Don't tell her that ... moves on with their life and the person winds up feeling abandoned at a time when they really need support.

Will you get breast cancer by wearing a bra to sleep?

Description : Will you get breast cancer by wearing a bra to sleep?

Last Answer : I’m a doctor and I can tell you that there is no evidence supporting this theory. I am aware of some controversial studies and a book that make this claim, but the studies are flawed and not supported by the medical literature. For example, here is a link from a trusted breast cancer website.

What does everyone think about Christina Applegate's decision regarding her breast cancer?

Description : What does everyone think about Christina Applegate's decision regarding her breast cancer?

Last Answer : It doesn’t run in my family…But if it did, I’d do EXACTLY the same thing.

What to do to keep yourself free from breast cancer ?

Description : What to do to keep yourself free from breast cancer ?

Last Answer : Compared to the last 25 years, the number of patients with breast cancer has been increasing day by day. Currently, the number of patients with breast cancer is the highest. More women get ... breast cancer. So try to lower your cholesterol levels and stay away from foods that contain cholesterol.

Are men also more likely to get breast cancer ?

Description : Are men also more likely to get breast cancer ?

Last Answer : Women have the highest mortality rate from breast cancer. The risk of developing this cancer is usually highest in people over the age of 50. Surprisingly, there has been a lot of pressure on women to ... 41,000 women are diagnosed with breast cancer in the UK each year , compared to only 300 men.

I want to know the details about breast cancer. ?

Description : I want to know the details about breast cancer. ?

Last Answer : Breast cancer is a terrible but easily treatable disease and 90% of cases can be completely cured if it is detected at an early stage. And the easiest way to detect early stage breast cancer is to get tested ... a bath , as it is convenient to check that the skin is wet and slippery at that time.

What are the symptoms of breast cancer ?

Description : What are the symptoms of breast cancer ?

Last Answer : There is a lot of writing on our favorite.com site about breast cancer. You can get an idea about this by reading them. Find out what are the symptoms of breast cancer and what to do to treat it. ... . And it won't cost too much to do the checkup. For this you can search in government hospitals.

What is Breast Cancer ? Want to know the symptoms and cure of breast cancer ?

Description : What is Breast Cancer ? Want to know the symptoms and cure of breast cancer ?

Last Answer : What is breast cancer ? The symptoms and remedies are given below: - 7 Breast cancer is 100% curable if detected early. According to the World Health Organization, more than 15,000 people are diagnosed ... comment . References: - https://www.google.com/amp/s/www.bbc.com/bengali/amp/news-50254200

How to recognize breast cancer?

Description : Will there be a visible sign?

Last Answer : It doesn't have to. Only experts after the examination will know. A certain signal may be a feeling of a lump inside

side effects of radiaion for breast cancer

Description : side effects of radiaion for breast cancer

Last Answer : The same as the side effect from radiation for other cancers. There are actually two kinds of side effects from radiation therapy -- early and late. Early side effects, such as nausea or ... specific to the site being treated. http://www.webmd.com/cancer/what-to-expect-from-radiation-therapy

Can hickeys in breast cause breast cancer?

Description : Can hickeys in breast cause breast cancer?

Last Answer : No. They are bruises and ugly but don’t cause cancer.

Did Hilter's mom have breast cancer?

Description : Did Hilter's mom have breast cancer?

Last Answer : Yes. Either Breast cancer or the after effects of surgery forbreast cancer.

Breast cancer?

Description : Breast cancer?

Last Answer : DefinitionBreast cancer is a cancer that starts in the tissues of the breast.There are two main types of breast cancer:Ductal carcinoma starts in the tubes (ducts) that move milk from the ... that has not yet invaded nearby tissues. It may progress to invasive cancer if untreated.Lobular carcinoma

What are the effects of chemotherapy when it is used as treatment for breast cancer?

Description : What are the effects of chemotherapy when it is used as treatment for breast cancer?

Last Answer : Nausea, hair loss, vomiting, fatigue, easy bruising, and mouth sores are all common side effects of chemotherapy, no matter what the chemothereapy is used for. One of the best medicines to combat a ... is marijuana, so check your state laws to see of medical marijuana is legal in your state.

60 year old woman & breast cancer survivor for 15 years. now diag. with stage 4 colon cancer. what is her life expectancy normally.?

Description : 60 year old woman & breast cancer survivor for 15 years. now diag. with stage 4 colon cancer. what is her life expectancy normally.?

Last Answer : There are too many factors that determine life expectancy to say.