answer:inside the box: 4 apples (wrong, unless I gave the other 8 away – that would be outside the box) 8 apples (right, but I’d eat one while I’m picking which 8 I take, then 7 or 8 depending on if I decide to replace the one I ate) a little outside the box: 12 apples, in two groups way outside the box: applesauce (I have no “apples”), because that’s why I bought all those apples in the first place.