How, if possible, can you determine the moral or spiritual validity of any belief system?

How, if possible, can you determine the moral or spiritual validity of any belief system?
by

1 Answer

Answer :

There is no objective criteria that can be used otherwise we would all believe the same thing. I would simply ask what harm might result from believing this and is it uplifting or beautiful.
by

Related questions

Is belief in a "higher power" a "spiritual strength"?

Description : Is belief in a "higher power" a "spiritual strength"?

Last Answer : Regardless of the existence of a deity, I think that belief makes people stronger. It’s not a “reliance”.. more like a foundation.

Can you link me to sites that focus on paranomal and/or spiritual questions?

Description : Can you link me to sites that focus on paranomal and/or spiritual questions?

Last Answer : talljasperman like a new age forum. Can you suggest one?

How do you like your boiled eggs? What are the psychological, philosophical and spiritual imlications of your preference?

Description : How do you like your boiled eggs? What are the psychological, philosophical and spiritual imlications of your preference?

Last Answer : I like them the way you like them. This means we must be together forever.

How are the validity of moral obligations objective?

Description : How are the validity of moral obligations objective?

Last Answer : answer:In my view, they can't possibly be. Moral views are almost by definition those of a particular person; not necessarily shared by society at large, and very seldom backed by objective evidence or ... obligations, and there isn't - and cannot be - universally shared views of a moral issue.

If the idea of a collective unconsious has any validity, with the same going for a collective super/higher or over-consious,does the internet represent a de facto collective consious?

Description : If the idea of a collective unconsious has any validity, with the same going for a collective super/higher or over-consious,does the internet represent a de facto collective consious?

Last Answer : For a question that uses the word unconscious so much, you might want to learn how to spell it correctly.

Why does individualism require validity from a collective?

Description : Why does individualism require validity from a collective?

Last Answer : answer:I think as people, we tend to have to put a label on everything. From that, even individualism has to be categorized so that we can feel better about it. It's more comfortable that way. ... someone who acts or does something in their own way, Therefor, everyone is an individual in some way.

Do you think that, a person, happy with their belief system would need to attack others?

Description : Do you think that, a person, happy with their belief system would need to attack others?

Last Answer : answer:Even if you are happy in your belief system, if people are attacking your beliefs and trying to change your beliefs often enough people tend to change their strategies from defending their beliefs into ... a belief constantly. That's my belief anyway, and I'll attack you if you disagree.

Is "a sincerely held religious belief or moral conviction” justification for bullying gays at school?

Description : Is "a sincerely held religious belief or moral conviction” justification for bullying gays at school?

Last Answer : What the fuck.

Can you please list as many of the different personality, belief or other, tests as you can?

Description : Can you please list as many of the different personality, belief or other, tests as you can?

Last Answer : Holland codes. I.Q. tests. Multiple intelligences, Emotional intelligence E.Q.. McDonald’s restaurants job placement test.

Have you ever changed a delusional belief?

Description : Have you ever changed a delusional belief?

Last Answer : Dude.. People can believe all sorts of things. The great gift that Western civilization got from Aristotle is a method of proving your beliefs have some reasonable chance of being coincident with reality. A ... when it comes to Santa, I wish I had never heard of Aristotle. I loved that delusion!

Do you think there is some innate feature of a person that can predispose them to certain belief patterns?

Description : Do you think there is some innate feature of a person that can predispose them to certain belief patterns?

Last Answer : if intelligence derives at least partly from genes, which I think it does, then yeah. Leary with his Eight Circuits model, Ken Wilber and his integral theory and the theory of Spiral Dynamics (which Wilber ... eventually adopts. (you can't adopt a belief if you can't understand it, for starters.)

Is belief involuntary?

Description : Is belief involuntary?

Last Answer : I believe this question needs to be phrased in a more coherent manner. Punctuation should be altered and more details could be added (eg. “We cannot if we try choose to disbelieve…. [Huh?]) .

How is behavioral psychology connected to belief?

Description : How is behavioral psychology connected to belief?

Last Answer : two incredibly broad topics – need more detail

What are the various ways to give my middle daughter support both moral or otherwise?

Description : What are the various ways to give my middle daughter support both moral or otherwise?

Last Answer : I think the best thing you can do is talk to her and listen to her. Find out what she wants out of life and encourage her to go after it. Be there for her and let her know that she can come to you when she needs help.

Where is your moral event horizon?

Description : Where is your moral event horizon?

Last Answer : I got one of those? It must be around here someplace. I have morals but the hell I know the kind of ones I have. I’m not really good or really bad. I’m kind of in the middle of everything.

The essence of the attest function is to a. Detect fraud. b. Examine individual transactions so that the auditor can certify as to their validity. c. Determine whether the client's financial statements are fairly stated. d. Ensure the consistent application of correct accounting procedures.

Description : The essence of the attest function is to a. Detect fraud. b. Examine individual transactions so that the auditor can certify as to their validity. c. Determine whether the client's financial statements are fairly stated. d. Ensure the consistent application of correct accounting procedures.

Last Answer : Determine whether the client's financial statements are fairly stated.

Is it possible to put a complex faux history or cosmology or spiritual system into a novel, or series of sci fi / fantasy novels?

Description : Is it possible to put a complex faux history or cosmology or spiritual system into a novel, or series of sci fi / fantasy novels?

Last Answer : Asimov did it with his Foundation series. Heinlein did it in some of his longer novels. And of course JK Rowling did it in all of the Harry Potter books. It’s certainly possible to do, but you have to spend an enormous amount of time on consistency and detail, or it all falls apart.

Is it possible to regress in my spiritual journey?

Description : Is it possible to regress in my spiritual journey?

Last Answer : Accepting yourself is key to relieving stress. That’s all I got.

Moral philosophies: A)are concerned with maximising the greatest good for the greatest number of people. B)are principles or rules that individuals use to determine what is right or wrong C)focus on the intentions associated with a particular behaviour and on the rights of the individual.

Description : Moral philosophies: A)are concerned with maximising the greatest good for the greatest number of people. B)are principles or rules that individuals use to determine what is right or wrong C)focus on the intentions associated with a particular behaviour and on the rights of the individual.

Last Answer : B)are principles or rules that individuals use to determine what is right or wrong

Moral philosophies A)are concerned with maximising the greatest good for the greatest number of people. B)are principles or rules that individuals use to determine what is right or wrong. C)focus on the intentions associated with a particular behaviour and on the rights of the individual. D)remain consistent in both work and family situations.

Description : Moral philosophies A)are concerned with maximising the greatest good for the greatest number of people. B)are principles or rules that individuals use to determine what is right or wrong. C)focus on ... and on the rights of the individual. D)remain consistent in both work and family situations.

Last Answer : B)are principles or rules that individuals use to determine what is right or wrong.

The practitioner makes a critical assessment of validity of audit evidence, with a questioning mind and being alert to conditions which may indicate possible misstatement due to error or fraud. a. Objectivity and integrity b. Professional c. Independence is mental attitude d. Sufficient appropriate evidence

Description : The practitioner makes a critical assessment of validity of audit evidence, with a questioning mind and being alert to conditions which may indicate possible misstatement due to error or ... integrity b. Professional skepticism c. Independence is mental attitude d. Sufficient appropriate evidence

Last Answer : Professional skepticism

How do you determine whether you are OCD about something?

Description : How do you determine whether you are OCD about something?

Last Answer : You know when the clocks go forward/back a couple of times a year? Right, good, keep up…..if you were to do this obsessively then you wouldn’t know if you were coming or going, very confusing i’d imagine. This took a little while to type because I couldn’t spell obsessively :¬)

What, if anything, can I determine about an individual from knowing their preferred movie monster?

Description : What, if anything, can I determine about an individual from knowing their preferred movie monster?

Last Answer : answer:Zombies: The person likes survival situations and can picture in their minds how they would survive such an apocalypse. They may even secretly yearn for one Vampires: The person sees ... off on realistically portrayed ghost videos and stories of things unusual. this is all random speculation

How does one determine that one's anxiety or sadness is beyond an ordinary reaction to circumstances and might require medication?

Description : How does one determine that one's anxiety or sadness is beyond an ordinary reaction to circumstances and might require medication?

Last Answer : Find a good therapist and talk over your issues. They are trained to make diagnoses and then refer you to a psychiatrist who can recommend an antidepressant.

Regarding Wanda being teased, Miss Mason was (a) in denial that such behaviour was possible by her students. (b) aware, but didn‘t want to discuss it with the students. (c) unaware that the students were frequently teasing Wanda. (d) of the belief that such behaviour was a normal part of growing up.

Description : Regarding Wanda being teased, Miss Mason was (a) in denial that such behaviour was possible by her students. (b) aware, but didn‘t want to discuss it with the students. (c) unaware that the students were frequently teasing Wanda. (d) of the belief that such behaviour was a normal part of growing up.

Last Answer : (c) unaware that the students were frequently teasing Wanda.

Which of the following is a violation Confidentiality rule of the Code of Ethics? a. The CPA, in response to a court subpoena, submits auditor-prepared workpapers as evidence of possible illegal acts perpetrated by the client. b. The CPA discloses to the board of directors a scheme concocted by top management to intentionally inflate earningsc. The CPA warns Client B as to theinadvisability of acquiring Client A.The CPA bases this warning onknowledge of Client A's financialcondition and a belief that themanagement of Client A lacksintegrity. This knowledge wasobtained by the CPA as a result ofauditing Client A during the pastseveral year is.d. The CPA, when questioned in court,admits to knowledge of certain illegalacts perpetrated by the client.

Description : Which of the following is a violation Confidentiality rule of the Code of Ethics? a. The CPA, in response to a court subpoena, submits auditor-prepared workpapers as evidence of possible illegal ... CPA, when questioned in court, admits to knowledge of certain illegal acts perpetrated by the client.

Last Answer : The CPA warns Client B as to the inadvisability of acquiring Client A. The CPA bases this warning on knowledge of Client A's financial condition and a belief that the management of Client A lacks integrity ... was obtained by the CPA as a result of auditing Client A during the past several year is.

If spiritual healing is false, how come stress is related to many illnesses?

Description : If spiritual healing is false, how come stress is related to many illnesses?

Last Answer : I think Dawkins is a smart guy, but he is so devoted to science that he fails to identify those areas of science that aren't set in stone. For instance, there have been ... temperature or consuming a liquid that has certain chemical properties that may be beneficial for some physiological issues.

What is emotional or spiritual pain and suffering?

Description : What is emotional or spiritual pain and suffering?

Last Answer : I'm still reeling, from my latest debacle of an attempted relationship, with a red head girl. I cost myself a lucrative job, and a girl I foolishly really liked I suppose it's all my fault. My brain had her ... had the girl, and the job of my dreams I guess I at least had those couple days .....

Does the Dalai Lama have the spiritual authority to refuse to be the next Dalai Lama after he dies?

Description : Does the Dalai Lama have the spiritual authority to refuse to be the next Dalai Lama after he dies?

Last Answer : Here is him mentioning that he may not want to Based on other quick research I did, it seems that yes, he has the authority to refuse. He is the highest spiritual authority so I think he has all the ... that was written by Howard C Cutler, M.D and the Dalai Lama. Is a very interesting read so far

Should those who comment on faith or spiritual matter (especially concerning the God of Abraham, Isaac, and Jacob) educate themselves on the subject before commenting as if they know?

Description : Should those who comment on faith or spiritual matter (especially concerning the God of Abraham, Isaac, and Jacob) educate themselves on the subject before commenting as if they know?

Last Answer : Yes. But a layman’s opinion can get interesting and provide some new perspective too.

If you aren't religious, do you have a source of spiritual growth?

Description : If you aren't religious, do you have a source of spiritual growth?

Last Answer : I don’t believe in religion as it pertains only to humans, but I’m very spiritual. If an animal gets killed on my road, they get a prayer from me to the Great Spirit. Call me nuts, but I like my views.

Where can I learn about super spiritual gifts?

Description : Where can I learn about super spiritual gifts?

Last Answer : There is only one thing you need to know. There is no such thing.

What has practicing yoga done for your spiritual life?

Description : What has practicing yoga done for your spiritual life?

Last Answer : answer:For me, I started yoga for the physical benefits, but I found the mental benefits akin to what @thorninmud explains on your meditation question. Yoga is undertaken as a practice, it is something that ... it can do and accept what it can't have also been beneficial to my overall well-being.

Have you ever had a Spiritual teacher?

Description : Have you ever had a Spiritual teacher?

Last Answer : Yes. More than one. Too many. Like cooks, too many spoil the soup. My 8th grade science teacher took me where I needed to go, but it was reality based, not spiritually based.

Where can I find spiritual pictures and web pages?

Description : Where can I find spiritual pictures and web pages?

Last Answer : I like thegodarticle.com. If you’re looking for pictures and quotes there are a lot of pages you can follow on Facebook.

What religious, spiritual or just plain life lessons did your father teach you?

Description : What religious, spiritual or just plain life lessons did your father teach you?

Last Answer : answer:You get more when you need less. And keep enjoying the good things.

Is it more spiritual to be Republican or Democrat?

Description : Is it more spiritual to be Republican or Democrat?

Last Answer : I think it is more spiritual to be apolitical. Spiritual people KNOW none of this worldly ego stuff matters. They may have preferences for what changes they wish to see transpire but they are ... wrong polarities and making harsh judgments about them is about as far from spiritual as it gets.

What if aliens are spiritual beings and not like Hawking said?

Description : What if aliens are spiritual beings and not like Hawking said?

Last Answer : answer:Then if hey are spiritual, they will reach out to us. What hawking was saying was that if they truly are alien, then it would be a mistake to think that they think like we do.

Enlighten us with a spiritual haiku.

Description : Enlighten us with a spiritual haiku.

Last Answer : Tarot cards and beads Crosses, stars, holy water All hopeless nonsense

Tips on helping my relationship reach spiritual potential?

Description : Tips on helping my relationship reach spiritual potential?

Last Answer : answer:Welcome to Fluther. The only advice to give you here is the same response we give to countless other questions about How can I get him / her to ? You can't. You can't change anyone else. ... X for her and just let her find her own way? Decide whether you can or not, and choose accordingly.

How would one begin to form a non-profit spiritual organization eligible for grants and government assistance?

Description : How would one begin to form a non-profit spiritual organization eligible for grants and government assistance?

Last Answer : Step 1: Get people behind you who will support you and maybe even finance you.

Where should I begin my research on founding a Spiritual Organization in Hawaii?

Description : Where should I begin my research on founding a Spiritual Organization in Hawaii?

Last Answer : answer:Do you want your organization to be a non-profit? If so, you will need to apply for 501©3 status through the IRS. Here are the steps for Hawaii.

How has the Internet affected your spiritual life?

Description : How has the Internet affected your spiritual life?

Last Answer : It hasn’t affected it at all.I know how I think :)

Did you ever have a spiritual experience that changed your life?

Description : Did you ever have a spiritual experience that changed your life?

Last Answer : Yes.Amazing.I wish I could tell you about it but I cant.:)

What's your spiritual practice?

Description : What's your spiritual practice?

Last Answer : sleeping…

The Devil made me do it??? What basis does Sanfords "Spiritual Advisor" have in saying that he was "Gripped by Darkness"?

Description : The Devil made me do it??? What basis does Sanfords "Spiritual Advisor" have in saying that he was "Gripped by Darkness"?

Last Answer : Sanford's Spiritual Advisor, whatever that is, needs first to learn about mixed metaphors. The fog may walk on litle cats' feet, but I don't think darkness can grip. Here's an excellent explanation, ... com/2009/06/29/opinion/29kenney.html?th&emc=th Disclosure; Kenney is a writer..often a funny one.

Time-tested guidelines for ethical living - Are spiritual people more healthy?

Description : Time-tested guidelines for ethical living - Are spiritual people more healthy?

Last Answer : A hospital survey published here (Australia) a year or so ago, claimed surprisingly that both the extent and the recovery rate of devout people was far less that that of atheists. That even surprised me. ... basically it seems that if you trust in God, you don't try as hard in other directions.

The coming age of 'spiritual machines' - When will computers exceed human intelligence?

Description : The coming age of 'spiritual machines' - When will computers exceed human intelligence?

Last Answer : Did you hear about this recent discovery by a robot? Supposedly, the robot formulated a hypothesis and then devised a set of test to prove the hypothesis completely independent from its creators. That's ... t loaded in this particular case, but it does seem to point towards a very different future.

What Daily (Spiritual or Meaningful) Rituals do You Particpate In?

Description : What Daily (Spiritual or Meaningful) Rituals do You Particpate In?

Last Answer : Having coffee with my husband every morning calling my mom every morning emailing my daughter every morning when I do not see her calling my son every day (very briefly, promise) Having a solitary cup of tea with a book

Have you had any spiritual experiences (good or bad)? If so, what happened?

Description : Have you had any spiritual experiences (good or bad)? If so, what happened?

Last Answer : I did the light as a feather thing once at a slumber party, that was pretty cool I have to admit. I have had a few personal experiences, I won't share them because people tend to think you're a ... insight into life and death, and that death is nothing to fear, it's just a change in your existence.