In what ways does vegetarianism support animal rights as much or more than eating ethically sourced meat?

1 Answer

Answer :

answer:A brief rundown with many omissions: There are two major philosophical schools of moral vegetarianism. The first is the utilitarian school. Utilitarianism is concerned with maximizing happiness for all sentient creatures capable of suffering. On this view, a creature isn’t an object of moral concern until it exists and is sentient. (Note: this is not unique to utilitarianism. Many moral philosophers believe that sentience is a necessary and sufficient condition for being an object of moral concern.) Utilitarians cannot find intrinsic value in the mere existence of a species. If you can show that it significantly undermines the happiness of the remaining species to let one go extinct, then they would say you have a reason to prevent the extinction. Otherwise, future non-existent cows are just as worrisome as all of the siblings I’ll never have because my parents weren’t constantly trying to churn out babies. The second is the deontological school, from which we get the term “animal rights.” Deontological vegetarians argue that the basis of rights is a set of cognitive abilities that are shared by human and non-human animals alike (or at least, many non-human animals). Though non-human animals cannot act as moral agents—that is, they cannot assert their rights, and often lack a deep understanding of ethics—the same can be said of many human animals (infants being the most obvious example). So long as an animal—human or not—is a bearer of rights, it cannot be killed for no reason or owned by anyone else (life, liberty, and self-ownership being considered basic rights that a being must have if they have any at all). But notice again that this is based on individuals. There is no place for attaching value to the species itself, which is not a being (and thus cannot be the bearer of rights).* That the two major schools cannot—or at least do not—place any weight on the species itself has led to at least one other approach, known as deep ecology. This approach rejects all efforts to understand the moral value of animals in terms of the ways in which humans get their value. That is, it takes animals to be valuable in themselves even if they do not share any of the qualities that make humans valuable in themselves. Indeed, deep ecologists typically find moral philosophy to be irredeemably shallow, arguing that it is anthropocentric and based on a fundamental misunderstanding of the world. Ethics, they say, must be holistic. The real question is how to promote the well-being of the system—the planet, or possibly the whole universe—understood as a single functioning unit. Though some beings have no other choice but to prey on other beings, those that can appreciate the intrinsic value each being has are obligated to respect them all and promote their continued existence. —————————— * Note that there is another deontological school that holds closely to Immanuel Kant’s views about animals and what we owe them. According to the Kantians, animals are not morally considerable at all; however, we are required to treat them compassionately in order to prevent ourselves from becoming immoral beings. The idea is that allowing oneself to be cruel to animals will eventually erode our character to the point that we start acting cruelly to other human beings. For whatever reason, Kant didn’t think this prevented us from killing and eating other animals.

Related questions

Description : Does the following statement about meat and vegetarianism make sense?

Last Answer : No, that statement does not make sense.

Description : Does eating meat make you a hypocrite when you're fighting for animal rights?

Last Answer : I suppose it depends on exactly which rights one thinks they have; but generally speaking, I would say it does not. Believing that there is something wrong with torturing animals does not entail ... saprotrophs just as surely as any other creature becomes food for us. That's life-quite literally.

Description : How important is it to you, for your food to be locally sourced and/or organic?

Last Answer : I mostly eat freezer pizzas and macaroni and cheese. So I don't really care. My sister has three kids and she pays a little bit more for organic stuff. But we have tons of organic places around ... of fuel some of the locally grown stuff is the same price as the stuff they ship from California.

Description : Pro-choice jellies: Do you support (ethically) a girl using first-trimester abortions as a form of birth control? Why/not?

Last Answer : answer:Pro Choice means I support a person making their own choice based on their individual needs. It also means I don’t decide for them. My favorite motto is Make your choice before you made a baby.

Description : Is vegetarianism a morally and spiritually evolved practice?

Last Answer : No. Because depending on the type of vegetarianism, they can still eat eggs, fish and crabs, and they are just as much animals as cows, pigs, sheep, chicken and dogs. Veganism is.

Description : How can I talk to my parents about my vegetarianism?

Last Answer : If they’re concerned but willing to listen, do some research. Find a few reliable sources that show that you won’t suffer any nutritional deficiencies. Things like alternate sources for calcium and protein that you can show them.

Description : WHy is it vegetarians can force vegetarianism?

Last Answer : I’ve never had a vegetarian try to force vegetarianism on me. shrug

Description : How much meat would you eat if you had to kill the animal yourself before eating it?

Last Answer : If you’re going to eat meat shouldn’t you be willing to kill it yourself?

Description : What is the maximum current that can be sourced or sunk by an Arduino board?

Last Answer : The maximum current that can be sourced or sunk by an Arduino board varies depending on the specific model, but generally ranges from 20 mA to 40 mA per pin.

Description : What is the maximum current that can be sourced or sunk by an Arduino pin?

Last Answer : The maximum current that can be sourced or sunk by an Arduino pin is 20mA.

Description : What all can be sourced from tool hire companies?

Last Answer : HRs and Recruiters use a number of tools to fill the positions or hire potential employees. There are hundreds of tools in the market, however, we can categorize them as followings- Social media: ... most of them and can connect you the person of interest without wasting time on trivial things.

Description : How is space activity generally sourced?

Last Answer : Need answer

Description : Compared to fresh Water, the freezing point of sea water is - (1) Higher (2) Lower (3) Same (4) Depends on the sea from which the water is sourced

Last Answer : (2) Lower Explanation: Ocean water freezes just like freshwater, but at lower temperatures.

Description : Pro-carnivorism versus anti-carnivorism, or is it pro-vegetarianism versus anti-vegetarianism?

Last Answer : It is pro-murder and anti-murder.

Description : What is your opinion on vegetarianism & veganism?

Last Answer : I tried it in university. I lost 100 lbs and was put in the emergency room. I failed out of university. That’s the last time that I fool with my diet.

Description : Is total global vegetarianism a realistic idea?

Last Answer : No. And that’s coming from a vegetarian. People are too entrenched in their IMO barbaric worldviews…

Description : Is there something wrong with vegetarianism?

Last Answer : 1. There is nothing wrong with vegetarianism, but it is a personal choice. 2. Yes, seeing what happens to our animals in large factory settings is always awful, but 3. that is why you ... might choose to wait on supporting cruelty-free until they can know that their meat is actually raised well.

Description : Can eating more meat/not eating enough fruits and vegetables cause these problems?

Last Answer : Well yeah :P Just from personal experience, an out-of-whack diet can cause lots of issues. Especially in the bathroom.

Description : What are your thoughts about eating emu meat?

Last Answer : Never had it, but I’m certainly willing to try it.

Description : The government of Canada is voting (right now) for horse to be an acceptable food source. What do you think about eating horse meat?

Last Answer : Hmmmm. Any dissent would be purely emotional. We tend to identify with horses more than cows. I mean, how many cows have won the Triple Crown? How many cows have even been given a name? How many ... Hollywood movie? Ever seen a cow dance on his hind legs, or jump through burning hoops at a circus?

Description : Do you think one day eating meat will be viewed upon as barbaric and primitive?

Last Answer : answer:I suspect the middle and lower parts of society will come to think of it as barbaric. The rich will continue to consume it as a status symbol.

Description : Would you vegans-of-principle be alright eating vat-grown meat?

Last Answer : As a meat eater, I would be afraid of that!!!

Description : Is eating a lot of meat bad?

Last Answer : answer:Free range organic meat is best. Hunt your own or find an organic- grass fed cattle ranch to buy meat from. I agree to an extent with Dr Oz. All the additives and hormones and steroids added to most commercial meat animals cannot be good for us.

Description : Does anyone else sometimes feel guilty about eating meat, but can't stop eating it because it tastes so good?

Last Answer : Yep, and I quit eating the meat that made me feel that way. I wouldn't say I felt guilty exactly, rather that I didn't quite agree with the processes in place and so I didn't want ... feel guilty. At least further research the industry and decide if you're comfortable with what exactly takes place.

Description : If red meat was 70%- 90% of someone's diet, would they get sick if they all of a sudden stopped eating it?

Last Answer : I don’t see how that couldn’t but improve your health. People are not meant to consist on such a diet.

Description : If the thought of eating flesh is so wrong, who do vegetarians try to make their food taste like meat?

Last Answer : I don’t, not all vegetarians do. And what exactly do you mean by that?

Description : Has Anyone Read "SKINNY B!TCH" And Is Still Eating Meat?

Last Answer : This girl I work with read it, and has been a vegetarian now vegan, since October. She keeps spreading the book around my work, I’m avoiding it. I like meat.

Description : The ethical roots of the classical model of corporate social responsibility are found in which statement: A. The idea that the interests of stakeholders are as important as the interests of a corporation' ... C. The ethical imperative to cause no harm. D. The ethical imperative to prevent harm.

Last Answer : B. The free market theory which holds that managers are ethically obliged to ace as much money as possible for their stockholders because to do otherwise would undermine the very foundations of our free society.

Description : Ethically, the auditor could: a. Advertise only as to his expertise in preparing income tax returns. b. Base his audit fee on a percentage of the proceeds of his client's stock issue. c. Perform ... at less than his customary fees. d. Own preferred stock in a corporation which is an audit client.

Last Answer : Perform an examination for a financially distressed client at less than his customary fees.

Description : Which statement correctly describes the relationship between philosophical ethics and ethos? (a) Individuals who obey the conventions, mores, and rules of their cultures are already acting ethically. No ... mores and customs of one's culture is a more dependable way to make moral decisions.

Last Answer : (b) Philosophical ethics distinguishes what people do value from what they should value. (c) What people do value and should value are, for all practical purposes, the same?

Description : Which statement correctly describes the relationship between philosophical ethics and ethos? A. Individuals who obey the conventions, mores, and rules of their cultures are already acting ethically. No further ... and customs of one's culture is a more dependable way to make moral decisions.

Last Answer : B. Philosophical ethics distinguishes what people do value from what they should value. C. What people do value and should value are, for all practical purposes, the same? D. Philosophical ethics is too abstract to be useful in everyday life situations. Following

Description : Are zoos ethically justified?

Last Answer : answer:For the most part, zoos are not the educational resource they were in a less enlightened time. Some, but few, serve a purpose in protecting species that are close to extinction. The San ... good example. But for every SD Zoo, there are fifteen more that are inhumane prisons for animals,

Description : Where is a place in Africa where I can ethically see lions?

Last Answer : Kruger National Park in South Africa. I spent some time in SA about 15 years ago and visited the park for a couple of days. I drove my rental car through the park and was with the animals. It was ... take pictures make sure you look all around you - and above and below. It's a jungle out there.

Description : Library ethics. Is it ethically correct for the staff person to take a best-seller before the plebeians?

Last Answer : answer:Sure. Why not? What’s the alternative here? Should s/he put it on the shelf, then immediately pick it up again and check it out? Edit: Stupid me. Didn’t read the question correctly (the part about the reserve queue). Yes, I still don’t see any problem with it – certainly no ethical problems.

Description : Do you think it's morally or ethically acceptable for seniors to hide their financial assets to then become Medicaid eligible, and eligible for other government aid?

Last Answer : answer:I think if they've been paying into Medicaid all their lives, they have the right to draw from it when they are of an eligible age. I also think it's utter bullshit that this is a ... our elders. YES we should take care of all of our citizens, regardless of their age and income status.

Description : Is PETA acting ethically when they're offering to pay Octomom to advertise on her front lawn in exchange for mortgage payment?

Last Answer : Phhhtt. PETA exploits all the time. I despise, despise, despise that woman that exploits her kids. I sooooo want to punch her in the face. And then give her a tubal ligation while she’s unconscious.

Description : Is it ever ethically alright to use nuclear weapons?

Last Answer : I think killing is wrong for any reason. A bunch of wimps can drop a bomb from a plane and kill 100k. A murder is a murder. A nuke is the same as a million soldiers shooting bullets. Both are fucked up.

Description : Which statement does not reflect the idea of ethical relativism: A. All opinions are equal; no one can say what is ethically right or wrong. B. One's culture, society, or personal feelings are ... D. Philosophical ethics is simply a process of clarifying values, not a process of justifying them.

Last Answer : C. Determining what is ethically right or wrong is a process of arguing from an appeal to values and principles that justify and legitimize an opinion.

Description : Which statement does not reflect the idea of ethical relativism: A. All opinions are equal; no one can say what is ethically right or wrong. B. One's culture, society, or personal feelings are ... . D. Philosophical ethics is simply a process of clarifying values, not a process of justifying them.

Last Answer : C. Determining what is ethically right or wrong is a process of arguing from an appeal to values and principles that justify and legitimize an opinion.

Description : Are you eating too much meat?

Last Answer : Love meat. Enjoy it. Don’t eat many carbs.

Description : I am sick, and have been eating a bunch of junk food, any ways to improve my immune system?

Last Answer : load up on vitamin C. drink lots of water, eat some fruit and veggies and stop eating junk food.

Description : Have you ever looked at meat, and found yourself feeling sick, or even disgusted, at the idea of eating it?

Last Answer : Yes. Also just at seeing it, without even thinking about eating it.

Description : Why did you change from vegan to eating meat and dairy?

Last Answer : I decided to go vegan a few years ago, but I just couldn’t give up turkey and salmon.

Description : What do you think of eating meat?

Last Answer : I am an omnivore by biology. I was designed to eat meat, and I enjoy eating meat.

Description : Will the most recent study showing that red meat is bad for your health influence your eating habits?

Last Answer : answer:There’s a new study every other day. Nope.

Description : For those vegetarians/vegans who refuse to eat meat out of moral conviction, would you start eating meat if it came from a replicator?

Last Answer : answer:I look at it this way: if my eating the meat will in any way create conditions that might lead to more animals being slaughtered, I don't want anything to do with it. If I eat a conventional piece of ... so it's not as if this would be some dream come true. But yeah, I'd consider eating it.

Description : if you found out that all animals are self aware, would you quit eating meat?

Last Answer : haha metal? G-d gave us dominion over all plants and animals. but i believe we indulge in meat too much. i used to be a very strict vegetarian, but now i've begun eating meat a few ... different depths, especially about factory farms and the harm done to the environment b/c of the meat industry.

Description : Can a dog catch rabies from eating warm or hot meat?

Last Answer : never have heard of such a thing…

Description : I stopped eating meat one year ago but still crave it all the time, especially burgers. I've tried all the different brands of soy and veggie burgers but none come close to the real thing. Please send me suggestions before I fall off the wagon. BBQ season is here....my torture! Help!

Last Answer : answer:Try these. sorry, iwamoto, beatcha to it. ;-P Uh oh. Calling [at]iwamoto! I know you’ve linked those as being 100% vegetarian… but I cannot find a link to the actual product. Just a picture alone isn’t very helpful and so I hope you can pull my ass outta this fire I just jumped into.