What are your thoughts about assisted suicide for the mentally ill?

What are your thoughts about assisted suicide for the mentally ill?
by

1 Answer

Answer :

I don’t think I’m a good enough man to answer that. That’s going to take someone wiser than I am.
by

Related questions

Have you ever known anyone who actually came to realize and understand that he'd been affected mentally by using drugs?

Description : Have you ever known anyone who actually came to realize and understand that he'd been affected mentally by using drugs?

Last Answer : Can someone like him ever get to the place where he sees that he was wrong, those things never actually happened? With the help of therapy, possibly. But not possible by himself, or with you ... some extent with the help of therapy and meds, but obviously any serious damage may just be permanent.

Why are my anti-depressants making me mentally slow all the time?

Description : Why are my anti-depressants making me mentally slow all the time?

Last Answer : answer:This is a very common side effect for many of these medications. You are trading depression for zombie hood. Anti-depressants flat line your emotions, good and bad. A double edged sword. ... issues that's a whole different thing and I am not qualified to advise in that circumstance.

How do your choices compare to the things that Mentally Strong people avoid?

Description : How do your choices compare to the things that Mentally Strong people avoid?

Last Answer : Those items are often found on list of things to stop doing in order to grow emotionally. Not dwelling on the past, facing one’s fears, taking responsibility for one’s reactions. I wouldn’t call it “mentally strong” as much as “mentally healthy.”

Ever feel that you're decaying mentally?

Description : Ever feel that you're decaying mentally?

Last Answer : This is not normal for your age. Have you considered getting a check-up? Also, you need to talk to people. Join a meet-up group in one of your interests. Do puzzles.

Where do you think logic goes mentally when a person chooses to take their own life?

Description : Where do you think logic goes mentally when a person chooses to take their own life?

Last Answer : I think mostly they find there is no way out of the painful situation they are in, whatever it is. Having a child, she must have figured the child would be better off without her. (You don't know ... may not be obvious to you, but an intelligent person may reason that suicide is the best way to go.

Do you know how to help if you suspect someone is thinking of suicide?

Description : Do you know how to help if you suspect someone is thinking of suicide?

Last Answer : Thank you for sharing this information.

My friend blames himself for everything; now he is considering suicide...

Description : My friend blames himself for everything; now he is considering suicide...

Last Answer : You can't save him on your own. and I don't think we can really do anything to help you do that. If he is considering suicide, you need to get him professional help. Refer him to a therapist ... considering it Even if you are worried about him hating you/whatever. It's better to be safe than sorry

For those left behind after a suicide, how does one shed the guilty feelings?

Description : For those left behind after a suicide, how does one shed the guilty feelings?

Last Answer : I’m really sorry. I wish there was something I could say, but all I can come up with is that you have to realize that it isn’t your fault. This is a tragic thing. You are not at fault. I’m really sorry.

Have you ever had to deal with a friend's/family member's/acquaintance's suicide?

Description : Have you ever had to deal with a friend's/family member's/acquaintance's suicide?

Last Answer : Yes I have. It is confusing and leaves most people wondering why?

Thoughts on how this design will affect assisted suicide?

Description : Thoughts on how this design will affect assisted suicide?

Last Answer : I have read about this, and I am supportive of assisted suicide, and of a method that allows a peaceful end to extreme suffering.

What are your thoughts on assisted suicide?

Description : What are your thoughts on assisted suicide?

Last Answer : Yes, suicide can be justified. It’s my body, my life, why shouldn’t I be able to choose the time and manner of my own death?

What are your thoughts on euthanasia and assisted suicide?

Description : What are your thoughts on euthanasia and assisted suicide?

Last Answer : Everyone should be given a choice to end their life with euthanasia and assisted suicide so that they can choose to die with dignity and in peace instead of having to kill themselves in a painful way.

What are your thoughts about the medical model of disability VS the social model of disability?

Description : What are your thoughts about the medical model of disability VS the social model of disability?

Last Answer : The disconnect between the two is that the medical model does not and cannot address all aspects of a disbale persons life, nor can it comepnsate for impairments. For instance, ... Down syndrome cannot be addressed through medical means, but call for social and eductational interventions.

What are your thoughts on "trigger warnings?"?

Description : What are your thoughts on "trigger warnings?"?

Last Answer : answer:To share my own opinion, I feel that it would make sense and require little effort to put a warning if you're going to write something about abuse, extreme violence, or something else that is ... with my ostomy. I do not and can not expect anybody to put a trigger warning on their soap.

Ever hear of a form of OCD where the person constantly gets invasive thoughts?

Description : Ever hear of a form of OCD where the person constantly gets invasive thoughts?

Last Answer : sounds like a mix of schizophrenia, though I'm not a professional about mental disorders but I though schizophrenia was a disorder where you had invasive thoughts, or voices that were in your head. I've ... would imagine it would be treated in similar ways to a schizo patient, but I don't know.

How do you view assisted suicide?

Description : How do you view assisted suicide?

Last Answer : Are we talking about euthanasia?

Today's NYTimes had an article that suicides are at an all time high as a percentage of the population. (see link below) Does this make any sort of case for euthanasia (or assisted suicide)? Or are they disconnected?

Description : Today's NYTimes had an article that suicides are at an all time high as a percentage of the population. (see link below) Does this make any sort of case for euthanasia (or assisted suicide)? Or are they disconnected?

Last Answer : Are you seriously asking if we should consider offering assisted suicide as a “clean” solution to dire “economic conditions”?

If your State/Province held a referendum on assisted suicide..(rest in details)

Description : If your State/Province held a referendum on assisted suicide..(rest in details)

Last Answer : I will start off with a BIG YES!!!!!!!!

Are the anti-vaccine believers likely to be pro doctor-assisted suicide?

Description : Are the anti-vaccine believers likely to be pro doctor-assisted suicide?

Last Answer : I don’t think the two have anything to do with each other. The question doesn’t need to be asked.

If assisted suicide were legal, how would that affect the life insurance industry?

Description : If assisted suicide were legal, how would that affect the life insurance industry?

Last Answer : answer:I don't know about life insurance, but health insurance would likely be all for it. It can cost tens of thousands of dollars to keep someone critically ill alive for even just a few weeks ... have life AND health insurance, I'm sure that something will work out in assisted suicide's favor.

Lets try this a different way, if YOU were suffering from a terminal painful illness would you not want the option of assisted suicide?

Description : Lets try this a different way, if YOU were suffering from a terminal painful illness would you not want the option of assisted suicide?

Last Answer : answer:I would want the [legal] option. I understand that some disabled and elderly people may get pressure to choose assisted from family members, etc., but aren't those people in a living hell ... be given to people who have expressed an opinion before the option presents itself, much like DNR?

What question does the anti-assisted suicide side pose when polling the population?

Description : What question does the anti-assisted suicide side pose when polling the population?

Last Answer : Legitimate poll takers include the questions with the results.

Is assisted suicide (esp. doctor assisted) an oxymoron?

Description : Is assisted suicide (esp. doctor assisted) an oxymoron?

Last Answer : It’s not a selfish thing. It’s about trying to find a way to do it that will be successful and hopefully as pain-free as possible.

Doctor-assisted suicide is _________.

Description : Doctor-assisted suicide is _________.

Last Answer : …a basic human right.

Another person in the UK is refused the right to assisted suicide. Where do you stand on this topic?

Description : Another person in the UK is refused the right to assisted suicide. Where do you stand on this topic?

Last Answer : If I want to die, what’s it to you?

Why do people say assisted suicide and removing life support is murder?

Description : Why do people say assisted suicide and removing life support is murder?

Last Answer : I don't know why Kevorkian was ever indicted. I think if the person has to be on life support in order to stay alive, that that is not a life at all. I wouldn't ever want to have to be on ... by all means get someone to help them do it in a decent way. Much better than finding out of their suicide.

Do you think if assisted suicide was legal in the US the elderly would feel pressured to end their life to save others the expense of them being alive?

Description : Do you think if assisted suicide was legal in the US the elderly would feel pressured to end their life to save others the expense of them being alive?

Last Answer : This is a question that really doesn’t have an answer it’s really up to the person and everyone’s thoughts are different.

What is the best reason that you have found to support physician-assisted suicide Please explain your reasoning for considering this the best reason. ?

Description : What is the best reason that you have found to support physician-assisted suicide Please explain your reasoning for considering this the best reason. ?

Last Answer : According to the American Medical Association physician assisted suicide (PAS).

Am I mentally ill?

Description : Am I mentally ill?

Last Answer : Nobody could tell you, over the internet, or from an internet post. No professional could or would even make any diagnosis from two issues that you outline above. If you think it's a problem, or ... in a negative way, seek out a therapist or a psychologist or a psychiatrist and speak with them.

Do you tell someone who's mentally ill that they're mentally ill?

Description : Do you tell someone who's mentally ill that they're mentally ill?

Last Answer : No. They probably already know. I finally do set boundaries now. Before I judge someone I try to check if my assertions come from being too judgemental. I would however like to be given a choice to fix my ... them, too F off, on a chat room. They called the cops on me and my life fell apart.

Are the mentally ill allowed to run for office?

Description : Are the mentally ill allowed to run for office?

Last Answer : Anyone can run for office. Other than age in some countries and some citizenship type requirements, there are no disqualification based on fitness. It’s up to the voters. By the way, NPD is not disqualifying for jobs, it just makes a person difficult to deal with.

Why does not believing that one is mentally ill a sign of illness?

Description : Why does not believing that one is mentally ill a sign of illness?

Last Answer : Why do so many people think they are great drivers, when in reality they suck beyond belief ? Why don’t more people know who Joseph Heller is ? Why would so many people still “like to have a beer with” George W Bush ?? (so many questions….)

If you found out that the sperm-donor father of your child was a mentally ill felon, would you sue?

Description : If you found out that the sperm-donor father of your child was a mentally ill felon, would you sue?

Last Answer : No . I would pay extra. WITH all the CRAP that he has been through , and he survived to be 39. I would congratulate him. It is nothing special getting a PH.D, and having an I.Q. of 160 isn' ... (hell I have an I.Q. of 165). Now living with disabilities and staying alive now that's something special.

Should people who knowingly keep loaded and unsecured firearms in the house, when there is a mentally ill person living in the house, be charged as an accessory if the mentally ill person goes on a rampage and kills a bunch of people?

Description : Should people who knowingly keep loaded and unsecured firearms in the house, when there is a mentally ill person living in the house, be charged as an accessory if the mentally ill person goes on a rampage and kills a bunch of people?

Last Answer : Good question. I’d say they should have some kind of responsibility. They should at least be charged with having no common sense. (For those that are going to tell me that’s not a crime, I know. It’s a joke)

Do you have to be mentally ill to kill people?

Description : Do you have to be mentally ill to kill people?

Last Answer : answer:Not necessarily. Being a self absorbed narcissist that feels like a victim because he is not getting what he thinks he deserves from his over inflated sense of entitlement is enough for some ... chicks sent him into a murderous rage. When adult children have temper tantrums people can die.

What is the term for example when a person cannot see they are becoming mentally ill?

Description : What is the term for example when a person cannot see they are becoming mentally ill?

Last Answer : Dissonance? Although cognitive dissonance isn’t that you can’t tell you’re becoming mentally ill. Cognitive dissonance is holding two or more beliefs that contradict each other. Well more to the point it’s a state of distress that stems from this.

How often do find yourself dealing with someone who is seriously mentally ill?

Description : How often do find yourself dealing with someone who is seriously mentally ill?

Last Answer : answer:I had a best friend for a few years who was mentally ill with multiple disorders that were controlled by meds. He dropped me summarily after some therapy. I know this doesn't really speak to your ... you feel this person is a danger to your staff, you may have to dismiss him as a client.

What would be your solution to the functional mentally ill?

Description : What would be your solution to the functional mentally ill?

Last Answer : There are many levels to mental illness. Group homes are ideal. I suggest you be less derisive & more educated frankly.

If you were put on psychotropic drugs, does that mean you are mentally ill?

Description : If you were put on psychotropic drugs, does that mean you are mentally ill?

Last Answer : The definition of Mentally Ill is very slippery. I would say if a person needed drugs to control their behavior, they are M I.

Does media influence your perceptions of the mentally ill?

Description : Does media influence your perceptions of the mentally ill?

Last Answer : answer:Not really. I know too many people who have mental illness to let a TV show really influence it. I think the most negative thing happening right now in the media regarding mental illness is ... a lot, they get dismissed or not paid attention to when they are under stress and having trouble.

How to tell a parent that you are mentally ill?

Description : How to tell a parent that you are mentally ill?

Last Answer : answer:It sounds like your need to minimize your contact with your mother. Create that healthy distance. Do you have a therapist you're currently talking to? If so, do they know ... to talk to your therapist about exploring this relationship - specifically about anxiety, control, and codependency.

Where does the line between "eccentric" and "mentally ill" cross?

Description : Where does the line between "eccentric" and "mentally ill" cross?

Last Answer : To me, the point at which eccentricity becomes mental illness is when it significantly and negatively impacts your quality of life or makes you a danger to yourself and/or others. Eccentricity strikes me as harmless, while mental illness is harm-ful.

Do the term "Mentally ill" and "Mass Shootings", automatically go hand in hand?

Description : Do the term "Mentally ill" and "Mass Shootings", automatically go hand in hand?

Last Answer : Wow. Certainly most mass murders may be committed by mentally ill folk but that doesn’t mean that most mentally ill people are mass murderers! There are all different kinds and degrees of mental illness and most of them do not correlate with violent behaviour.

Stemming from the massacre in Newtown CT: What do you think should be done about the issue of the severely mentally ill receiving treatment for their illness, both for their own sake and for the benefit of society?

Description : Stemming from the massacre in Newtown CT: What do you think should be done about the issue of the severely mentally ill receiving treatment for their illness, both for their own sake and for the benefit of society?

Last Answer : answer:I'm not sure what should be done, because I'm not a mental health expert. But I would caution against some sort of he doesn't want treatment, so let's lock him up mentality. ... /disorder/syndrome or another. Mostly minor, and mostly well compensated for, but-none of us are without issues.

When a state court decides a perpetrator is mentally ill does the state then become the legal guardian of this person?

Description : When a state court decides a perpetrator is mentally ill does the state then become the legal guardian of this person?

Last Answer : Not necessarily. Mental illness does not necessarily mean you can’t make your own decisions.

What are some arguments for and against the rights of mentally ill voters.

Description : What are some arguments for and against the rights of mentally ill voters.

Last Answer : answer:No, because they do not have all of their faculties with which to make a voting decision. They could be easily swayed by unscrupulous people trying to manipulate the outcome of the election.

Do you think Dignitas in Switzerland should be available for the mentally ill?

Description : Do you think Dignitas in Switzerland should be available for the mentally ill?

Last Answer : I think that for those individuals with enduring mental health problems then they should be given the option. Many people spend their entire lives in & out of secure hospitals, basically stumbling from one ... a more lucid period of their lives & documented in the same way as a Living Will.

Why are addicts their addiction while the mentally ill are not their disorder?

Description : Why are addicts their addiction while the mentally ill are not their disorder?

Last Answer : I think it's because addicts choose to take that first step. You did not choose to be bipolar but the heroin addict chose to put the needle in his/her arm the first time. They may not have chosen to be ... , if you keep it in check by whatever means, then, no, I don't think you are your disease.

Was Charles Lutwidge Dodgson (aka Lewis Carol) mentally ill when he wrote "Alice['s Adventures] in Wonderland"?

Description : Was Charles Lutwidge Dodgson (aka Lewis Carol) mentally ill when he wrote "Alice['s Adventures] in Wonderland"?

Last Answer : I did hear he was on drugs, not sure what though. I love the story either way and can’t wait for the new movie.

If you were seriously inconvenienced by a suicidal/mentally ill person do you honestly think you could remain compassionate (please read details)?

Description : If you were seriously inconvenienced by a suicidal/mentally ill person do you honestly think you could remain compassionate (please read details)?

Last Answer : As much as I am all right with suicide (which is not very much- I think it's a legitimate answer in Right-To-Die fatal illness scenarios, but not as an answer to, say, teen angst), people who do ... and easy to clean up, I get less angry at than those who go in public, messy, and upsetting ways.