What criteria would you use to determine if someone has received the word/a message from God versus they are suffering from a mental disorder?

What criteria would you use to determine if someone has received the word/a message from God versus they are suffering from a mental disorder?
by

1 Answer

Answer :

I would say looking for other symptoms indicative of mental disorder, and consider how well they fit the standard in the DSM IV. I have no doubt that some past religious figures (including, but certainly not limited to, some saints) were just cases of different disorders glorified into religious fervor. If they are also exhibiting other symptoms, they would probably fit into your latter category.
by

Related questions

Which of the following terms has been defined by the American Psychiatric Association as a group of behavioral or psychological symptoms or a pattern that manifests itself in significant distress, impaired functioning, or accentuated risk of enduring severe suffering or possible death? a) Mental disorder The definition was adopted by the American Psychiatric Association in 1994. b) Emotional disorder There is no universally accepted definition of what constitutes an emotional disorder. c) Anxiety Anxiety is defined as fear of the unknown. d) Schizophrenia Schizophrenia is a specific disorder characterized by psychosis.

Description : Which of the following terms has been defined by the American Psychiatric Association as a group of behavioral or psychological symptoms or a pattern that manifests itself in significant distress ... of the unknown. d) Schizophrenia Schizophrenia is a specific disorder characterized by psychosis.

Last Answer : a) Mental disorder The definition was adopted by the American Psychiatric Association in 1994.

A child cannot distinguish between ’saw’ and ’was’, nuclear’ and ’unclear’. She/he is suffering from Options: A) dyslexia B) word jumbling disorder C) dyslexemia D) dysmorphemia

Description : A child cannot distinguish between ’saw’ and ’was’, nuclear’ and ’unclear’. She/he is suffering from Options: A) dyslexia B) word jumbling disorder C) dyslexemia D) dysmorphemia

Last Answer : B) word jumbling disorder

Suffering from severe panic disorder and derealization disorder. Can anybody relate?

Description : Suffering from severe panic disorder and derealization disorder. Can anybody relate?

Last Answer : Looks like you need some professional help.

A person showing unpredictable moods, outbursts of emotion, quarrelsome behaviour and conflicts with others is suffering from (a) addictive disorders (b) schizophrenia (c) borderline personality disorder (BPD) (d) mood disorders.

Description : A person showing unpredictable moods, outbursts of emotion, quarrelsome behaviour and conflicts with others is suffering from (a) addictive disorders (b) schizophrenia (c) borderline personality disorder (BPD) (d) mood disorders.

Last Answer : c) borderline personality disorder (BPD)

Due to increasing air-borne allergens and pollutants, many people in urban areas are suffering from respiratory disorder that cause wheezing due to (a) reduction in the secretion of surfactant by pneumocytes (b) benign growth on mucous lining of nasal cavity (c) inflammation of bronchi and bronchioles (d) proliferation of fibrous tissues and damage of the alveolar walls.

Description : Due to increasing air-borne allergens and pollutants, many people in urban areas are suffering from respiratory disorder that cause wheezing due to (a) reduction in the secretion of surfactant by ... of bronchi and bronchioles (d) proliferation of fibrous tissues and damage of the alveolar walls.

Last Answer : (c) inflammation of bronchi and bronchioles

Agammaglobulinemia is also known as a) Bruton’s disease. Bruton’s disease is a sex-linked disease that results in infants born with the disorder suffering severe infections soon after birth

Description : Agammaglobulinemia is also known as a) Bruton's disease. Bruton's disease is a sex-linked disease that results in infants born with the disorder suffering severe infections soon after ... of thrombocytopenia. d) Common variable immunodeficiency (CVID) CVID is another term for hypogammaglobulinemia.

Last Answer : a) Bruton’s disease. Bruton’s disease is a sex-linked disease that results in infants born with the disorder suffering severe infections soon after birth

My daughter is suffering from mental health problems

Description : Hello, I write at the outset that this topic is quite uncomfortable for me, but I do not know the advice and I need advice. I have a 20-year-old daughter who has been mentally ill since she was a little ... of it and unhappy about it. I don't know what to expect and therefore ask for advice.

Last Answer : This is a matter for professionals and not for counseling. I would personally recommend continuing school.

What and is defined as inflicting mental pain suffering or fear on an elder person through verbal or nonverbal actions?

Description : What and is defined as inflicting mental pain suffering or fear on an elder person through verbal or nonverbal actions?

Last Answer : Abuse.

A person suffering from carbon monoxide poisoning a) appears intoxicated. A person suffering from carbon monoxide poisoning appears intoxicated (from cerebral hypoxia). Other signs and symptoms include headache, muscular weakness, palpitation, dizziness, and mental confusion.

Description : A person suffering from carbon monoxide poisoning a) appears intoxicated. A person suffering from carbon monoxide poisoning appears intoxicated (from cerebral hypoxia). Other signs and symptoms include headache, ... pink to cherry red to cynanotic and pale and is not a reliable diagnostic sign.

Last Answer : a) appears intoxicated. A person suffering from carbon monoxide poisoning appears intoxicated (from cerebral hypoxia). Other signs and symptoms include headache, muscular weakness, palpitation, dizziness, and mental confusion.

If we believe in the dualistic theory of the mind versus body nature of an, have to arrive at the consequence that Options: A) Education is mechanization in process and theoretical in development B) Learning is purely a matter of material changes in the behaviour of man C) Learning an education should cater to observable behaviour of man D) Education is purely a matter of mental training and development of the self.

Description : If we believe in the dualistic theory of the mind versus body nature of an, have to arrive at the consequence that Options: A) Education is mechanization in process and theoretical in development B) ... behaviour of man D) Education is purely a matter of mental training and development of the self.

Last Answer : D) Education is purely a matter of mental training and development of the self. 

If God is Love then why do we have suffering in the world?

Description : If God is Love then why do we have suffering in the world?

Last Answer : We suffer because of Adam and Eve disobey God. God send his only son to save us from our sins. But if you commit a sin you already disobey God so that where the suffering comes from. And there are ... If you believe in God but you are not doing his will, then you are not saved when Jesus returns.

What is a mental health disorder where one sees less than is in reality called?

Description : What is a mental health disorder where one sees less than is in reality called?

Last Answer : Distortions of reality are parts of many mental health disorders. I’m not a practitioner but I would imagine there is not just one disorder that has that as a symptom.

Why is pedophilia considered a mental disorder, but homosexuality isn't?

Description : Why is pedophilia considered a mental disorder, but homosexuality isn't?

Last Answer : Why should homosexuality be considered a mental disorder?

Does Anthony Weiner have a mental disorder?

Description : Does Anthony Weiner have a mental disorder?

Last Answer : answer:Narcissist immediately comes to my mind. And what is Huma thinking? Does she have self esteem issues? No jury in the world would convict her if she cut his weiner off while he was sleeping. At least she was smart enough to not take his name.

At what age were you or a family member diagnosed with a mental disorder?

Description : At what age were you or a family member diagnosed with a mental disorder?

Last Answer : My grandfather didn't seek a diagnosis until he was in his 40s. He got some help but didn't share the process with anybody, so nobody in the family was aware of it until his daughter ... and treatment when the symptoms became apparent. Some disorders have a definite genetic link. Bipolar is one.

Does musical genius correlate to mental disorder?

Description : Does musical genius correlate to mental disorder?

Last Answer : No. There are a load of people with mental disorders out there with no musical abilty and there are a lot of people with fantastic musical abilty and no mental disorder.

Is being a masochist considered a mental disorder?

Description : Is being a masochist considered a mental disorder?

Last Answer : answer:There’s a few disorders here, I think. But, might as well work with what you’ve got. lol, “is masochism a mental disorder or a fetish?” I hope you realize how awkward that question is.

Need advice with a mental disorder i don't know what to do anymore?

Description : Need advice with a mental disorder i don't know what to do anymore?

Last Answer : Pray. It’ll give the peace you want. Or you can just do your hobby and forget that you had this thing in the first place.

Is this a mental disorder?

Description : Is this a mental disorder?

Last Answer : No You’re just being silly

Is bipolar disorder a problem with chemicals in the brain, or a mental illness?

Description : Is bipolar disorder a problem with chemicals in the brain, or a mental illness?

Last Answer : I imagine it would affect insurance policies, but other than that it doesn’t really matter. The last half of your question confused me a bit, could you clarify?

Can I be evicted from my appartment because I have a mental Disorder?

Description : Can I be evicted from my appartment because I have a mental Disorder?

Last Answer : I’m pretty sure that’s illegal. I’d contact Social Services and start asking questions. You may need the info backup. Sorry this is happening. That really sucks. Good luck!

What are the manifestations of mental disorder ?

Description : What are the manifestations of mental disorder ?

Last Answer : Mental disorders include mental disorders , lack of intelligence , nervous psychosis , criminal tendencies.

Mental disorder in which the patient is preoccupied with body functions and sensations

Description : Mental disorder in which the patient is preoccupied with body functions and sensations

Last Answer : Mental disorder in which the patient is preoccupied with body functions and sensations A. ... traumatic stress D. Attention - deficit disorder

What mental disorder make you believe you are being sent subliminal messages?

Description : What mental disorder make you believe you are being sent subliminal messages?

Last Answer : madness

What is the time period covered by the question about whether the Service member has had a past diagnosis for any mental health problem such as PTSD depression anxiety disorder or alcohol abuse or sub?

Description : What is the time period covered by the question about whether the Service member has had a past diagnosis for any mental health problem such as PTSD depression anxiety disorder or alcohol abuse or sub?

Last Answer : One year

What is the time period covered by the question about whether the Service member has had a past diagnosis for any mental health problem such as PTSD depression anxiety disorder or alcohol abuse or sub?

Description : What is the time period covered by the question about whether the Service member has had a past diagnosis for any mental health problem such as PTSD depression anxiety disorder or alcohol abuse or sub?

Last Answer : One year

Clinical symptom in urea cycle disorder is (A) Mental retardation (B) Drowsiness (C) Diarrhoea (D) Oedema

Description : Clinical symptom in urea cycle disorder is (A) Mental retardation (B) Drowsiness (C) Diarrhoea (D) Oedema

Last Answer : Answer : A

Dyslexia is associated with (A) mental disorder (B) behavioural disorder (C) reading disorder (D) writing disorder

Description : Dyslexia is associated with (A) mental disorder (B) behavioural disorder (C) reading disorder (D) writing disorder

Last Answer : (C) reading disorder

What criteria are being used to determine the roll-out of Twitter's new Lists feature?

Description : What criteria are being used to determine the roll-out of Twitter's new Lists feature?

Last Answer : I don’t have it but my guess would be user id, rewarding the oldest users.

What criteria determine which engine is the “critical” engine of a twin-engine aeroplane? a. The one with the center of thrust farthest from the centreline of the fuselage b. The one with the center of thrust closest to the centreline of the fuselage c. The one designated by the manufacturer which develops most usable thrust d. The failure of which causes the least yawing moment

Description : What criteria determine which engine is the critical engine of a twin-engine aeroplane? a. The one with the center of thrust farthest from the centreline of the fuselage b. The one ... the manufacturer which develops most usable thrust d. The failure of which causes the least yawing moment

Last Answer : b. The one with the center of thrust closest to the centreline of the fuselage

“Three gods, A, B, and C, are called, in some order, True, False, and Random. True always speaks truly, False always speaks falsely, but whether Random speaks truly or falsely is completely random. You must determine the identities of A, B, and C by asking three yes-or-no questions, and each question must be posed to exactly one god. The gods understand English but will answer all questions in their own language. In their unknown language, the words for “yes” and “no” are “da” and “ja,” in some order. You do not know which word means which.” -Riddles

Description : Three gods, A, B, and C, are called, in some order, True, False, and Random. True always speaks truly, False always speaks falsely, but whether Random speaks truly or falsely is completely random. You must ... are da and ja, in some order. You do not know which word means which. -Riddles

Last Answer : We're willing to bet that your brain feels pretty busted at this point. If you're ready to throw in the towel and hear the solution, we won't tell! Here are the three questions you ... start sorting out the solution with this 2008 paper, which claims to have the easiest answer to the brainteaser.

Three gods, A, B, and C, are called, in some order, True, False, and Random. True always speaks truly, False always speaks falsely, but whether Random speaks truly or falsely is completely random. You must determine the identities of A, B, and C by asking three yes-or-no questions, and each question must be posed to exactly one god. The gods understand English, but will answer all questions in their own language. In their unknown language, the words for 'yes' and 'no' are 'da' and 'ja', in some order. You do not know which word means which. So, which questions would you ask to identify each god? And no, it’s not a trick question. As a matter of fact, there are multiple ways to get the correct answer. -Riddles

Description : Three gods, A, B, and C, are called, in some order, True, False, and Random. True always speaks truly, False always speaks falsely, but whether Random speaks truly or falsely is completely random. ... a trick question. As a matter of fact, there are multiple ways to get the correct answer. -Riddles

Last Answer : 1. To god A: Does da' mean yes' if and only if you are True and if and only if B is Random? (We supposed A said, ja, making B True or False). 2. To god B: Does da mean yes' if and ... only if A is Random? Since B's True, he must say da, which means A is Random, leaving C to be False.

What lines from the inferno best reflect Dante message that god is an ordered and fair god?

Description : What lines from the inferno best reflect Dante message that god is an ordered and fair god?

Last Answer : From there we reached the border that divided / The second fromthe third ring, and there / I witnessed the horrendous art ofjustice. (Canto IX, lines 4 - 6)

What OT message of what by Jeremiah in ancient Israel was that god was planning on destroying the Hebrew people?

Description : What OT message of what by Jeremiah in ancient Israel was that god was planning on destroying the Hebrew people?

Last Answer : Need answer

Had anyone received a Google Message about Google security drive update for July 26 2021 and how this will affect one's Files ?

Description : Had anyone received a Google Message about Google security drive update for July 26 2021 and how this will affect one's Files ?

Last Answer : Procedure sounds complicated to follow.

Uh... Have you received a friendship request (love message) from any brand new fluther members lately?

Description : Uh... Have you received a friendship request (love message) from any brand new fluther members lately?

Last Answer : Yes. I told her to take her spam elsewhere.

How can I replay a received text to landline message?

Description : How can I replay a received text to landline message?

Last Answer : I’m not sure I understand the question…can you explain more?

Has anyone ever received a blank text message from 6689?

Description : Has anyone ever received a blank text message from 6689?

Last Answer : do you have Sprint?

Has anyone received this message?

Description : Has anyone received this message?

Last Answer : everybody got the message, it is from Andrew, one of the founders of ask-public. It is just another way of interacting with ask-public meaning you can ask questions from IM. Why not try it and see what you think. Then let ask-public know so they can improve it.

What is the funniest text message you have received?

Description : What is the funniest text message you have received?

Last Answer : for me... it was the 3 am "u up?" text from a shady sleeze i was avoiding. i'm pretty sure he sent them out to 30 girls each night.

Have you ever seen a "bad fortune" cookie message? Have any messages (good or bad) you have received, come true?

Description : Have you ever seen a "bad fortune" cookie message? Have any messages (good or bad) you have received, come true?

Last Answer : thats all ridiculous!!

What is the usual path of message received by the body from the environment?

Description : What is the usual path of message received by the body from the environment?

Last Answer : sense organ-nerves-spinal cord-brain

The _______ is used by a router in response to a received leave report. A) general query message B) special query message C) membershipreport D) noneof the above

Description : The _______ is used by a router in response to a received leave report. A) general query message B) special query message C) membershipreport D) noneof the above

Last Answer : special query message

In the question a part of the sentence is given in BOLD. Alternatives to the BOLD part are given which may improve the construction of the sentence. Select the correct alternative. He has received no other message than an urgent telegram asking him to rush his village immediately. (a) asking him to have rush his village (b) asking him to rush to his village (c) asked him to rush his village (d) No correction required

Description : In the question a part of the sentence is given in BOLD. Alternatives to the BOLD part are given which may improve the construction of the sentence. Select the correct alternative. He has received no other ... him to rush to his village (c) asked him to rush his village (d) No correction required

Last Answer : (b) asking him to rush to his village

The message “CHECK” to an aircraft means that you should: a. Confirm that you received and understood the last message b. Pass the required information to ATC c. Stay where you are d. Examine a system or procedure

Description : The message “CHECK” to an aircraft means that you should: a. Confirm that you received and understood the last message b. Pass the required information to ATC c. Stay where you are d. Examine a system or procedure

Last Answer : d. Examine a system or procedure

The message “CHECK” to an aircraft means that you should: a. Confirm that you received and understood the last message b. Pass the required information to ATC c. Stay where you are d. Examine a system or procedure

Description : The message “CHECK” to an aircraft means that you should: a. Confirm that you received and understood the last message b. Pass the required information to ATC c. Stay where you are d. Examine a system or procedure

Last Answer : d. Examine a system or procedure

Why should a benchmark statement be included in advertising objectives? A)The shareholders always like to see where a company is in relation to competition. B)It gives an indication of how the advertising message might best be presented. C)Without a reference point, it is difficult to determine to what degree the objectives have been accomplished. D)The objectives become more easily attainable when such a statement is included.

Description : Why should a benchmark statement be included in advertising objectives? A)The shareholders always like to see where a company is in relation to competition. B)It gives an indication of how ... have been accomplished. D)The objectives become more easily attainable when such a statement is included.

Last Answer : C)Without a reference point, it is difficult to determine to what degree the objectives have been accomplished.

7.How does traceroute work? A. It uses an ICMP destination-unreachable message to elicit the name of a router. B. It sends a specially crafted IP packet to a router to locate the number of hops from the sender to the destination network. C. It uses a protocol that will be rejected by the gateway to determine the location. D. It uses the TTL value in an ICMP message to determine the number of hops from the sender to the router.

Description : 7.How does traceroute work? A. It uses an ICMP destination-unreachable message to elicit the name of a router. B. It sends a specially crafted IP packet to a router to locate the number of hops from ... the TTL value in an ICMP message to determine the number of hops from the sender to the router.

Last Answer : D. It uses the TTL value in an ICMP message to determine the number of hops from the sender to the router.