What would you say to your boss if he’s crazy about an idea, but you think it stinks?

What would you say to your boss if he’s crazy about an idea, but you think it stinks?
by

1 Answer

Answer :

TRAPS: This is another question that pits two values, in this case loyalty and honesty, against one another.

BEST ANSWER: Remember the rule stated earlier: In any conflict between values, always choose integrity.

Example: I believe that when evaluating anything, it’s important to emphasize the positive. What do I like about this idea?” 

“Then, if you have reservations, I certainly want to point them out, as specifically, objectively and factually as I can.” 

“After all, the most important thing I owe my boss is honesty. If he can’t count on me for that, then everything else I may do or say could be questionable in his eyes.” 

“But I also want to express my thoughts in a constructive way. So my goal in this case would be to see if my boss and I could make his idea even stronger and more appealing, so that it effectively overcomes any initial reservation I or others may have about it.” 

“Of course, if he overrules me and says, ‘no, let’s do it my way,’ then I owe him my full and enthusiastic support to make it work as best it can.”   
by

Related questions

What negative thing would your last boss say about you?

Description : What negative thing would your last boss say about you?

Last Answer : "He/She wouldn't say anything bad, but he/she may point out I could improve in a certain area, and I've taken steps to become better at those skills"

What are three positive things your last boss would say about you?

Description : What are three positive things your last boss would say about you?

Last Answer : Hopefully they would have hundreds of positive things to say about you! Just pick the top three. Then explain why!

What negative thing would your last boss say about you?

Description : What negative thing would your last boss say about you?

Last Answer : This question is about your weaknesses. In fact, it is a very hard question for a candidate to answer as it is very difficult to be honest with oneself and say out loud about negative ... have learn since then the skill to delegate and cooperate with others to complete the job more effectively.

What negative thing would your last boss say about you?

Description : What negative thing would your last boss say about you?

Last Answer : Interview questions: What negative thing would your last boss say about you? Answer tips/answer samples: This question is about your weaknesses. In fact, it is a very hard question for a ... learn since then the skill to delegate and cooperate with others to complete the job more effectively.

What do you think of your previous boss?

Description : What do you think of your previous boss?

Last Answer : Do not belittle or talk badly of your last boss - it will come o as being petty. Instead, talk about the positive lessons you were able to learn from your last boss.

What do you think of your previous boss?

Description : What do you think of your previous boss?

Last Answer : Bad answer: He was completely incompetent, and a nightmare to work with, which is why I've moved on   Remember: if you get the job, the person interviewing you will some day be your ... no-nonsense attitude pushed me to work harder, and to meet deadlines I never even thought were possible.  

Does your boss know you're here today?

Description : Does your boss know you're here today?

Last Answer : Usually, you probably haven't told your boss for obvious reasons. So it's ok to say that they do not. You don’t want to upset the balance at your current job after all and nothing is guaranteed in an interview. The interviewer should understand this stance.

Who was your best boss?

Description : Who was your best boss?

Last Answer : Answer tips/answer samples: The interviewer wants to know that whether you blame or judge badly about your previous boss by asking the question Who was your best boss and who was the worst? Best ... keep in touch. Truly speaking, I have learned something from each boss that I have worked for.

Tell me about any issues you've had with a previous boss?

Description : Tell me about any issues you've had with a previous boss?

Last Answer : Arrgh! If you fall for this one you shouldn't be hired anyway. The interviewer is testing you to see if you'll speak badly about your previous supervisor. Simply answer this question with extreme tact, diplomacy and if necessary, a big fat loss of memory. In short, you've never had any issues.

Have you ever had a conflict with a boss or professor? How was it resolved?

Description : Have you ever had a conflict with a boss or professor? How was it resolved?

Last Answer : Note that if you say no, most interviewers will keep drilling deeper to find a conflict. The key is how you behaviourally reacted to conflict and what you did to resolve it. For example: ... . . . Focus your answer on the behavioural process for resolving the conflict and working collaboratively.

What qualities do you look for in a boss?

Description : What qualities do you look for in a boss?

Last Answer : Be generic and positive. Safe qualities are knowledgeable, a sense of humour, fair, loyal to subordinates, and leads by example All bosses think they have these traits.

Tell me honestly about the strong points and weak points of your boss (company, management team, etc.)…

Description : Tell me honestly about the strong points and weak points of your boss (company, management team, etc.)… 

Last Answer : TRAPS: Skillfull interviewers sometimes make it almost irresistible to open up and air a little dirty laundry from your previous position. DON'T BEST ANSWER: Remember the rule: Never be negative. ... company. This question is your opportunity to demonstrate your loyalty to those you work with.    

Who was your best boss?

Description : Who was your best boss?

Last Answer : Interview questions: Who was your best boss? Answer tips/answer samples: The interviewer wants to know that whether you blame or judge badly about your previous boss by asking the question Who was ... keep in touch. Truly speaking, I have learned something from each boss that I have worked for.

How do you handle it if the boss is wrong?

Description : How do you handle it if the boss is wrong?

Last Answer : Interview questions: Answer tips/answer samples: The best answer is to tell it depends on certain situations , but after that, you should debate some situations with the interviewer which are based on your practical ... there is a lot of things one doesn't know, me, too, and my boss is, too.

What qualities do you look for in a boss?

Description : What qualities do you look for in a boss?

Last Answer : What qualities do you look for in a boss? Answer tips Be generic and positive. Safe qualities are knowledgeable, a sense of humor, fair, loyal to subordinates and holder of high standards. All ... can control his team & team members. He has capacity to lead the team according to circumstances.

I have a friend who thinks business owners should be able to turn away customers for any reason, and choose who they want to do business with. Do you think he's crazy?

Description : I have a friend who thinks business owners should be able to turn away customers for any reason, and choose who they want to do business with. Do you think he's crazy?

Last Answer : I’m almost inclined to agree with him just so these business owners can feel the consequences of their ignorance.

Someone you know writes a book, and it stinks. What do you say to him or her?

Description : Someone you know writes a book, and it stinks. What do you say to him or her?

Last Answer : I would tell him/her/it that it sucks. I may be more or less diplomatic about it.

Creative ways to deal with crazy boss?

Description : Creative ways to deal with crazy boss?

Last Answer : Keep a log and document dates and times of any potentially important conversations (especially something online that would time-stamp). Then if something like this comes up again, you politely and non- ... during the day .For your convenience, I've attached my notes from our conversation of

Give me a specific example of a time when you sold your supervisor or professor on an idea or concept. How did you proceed? What was the result?

Description : Give me a specific example of a time when you sold your supervisor or professor on an idea or concept. How did you proceed? What was the result?

Last Answer : What was the idea, how did you present it to your supervisor, what were the results once the idea was implemented?

Tell of a time when your active listening skills really paid o for you -- maybe a time when other people missed the key idea being expressed.

Description : Tell of a time when your active listening skills really paid o for you -- maybe a time when other people missed the key idea being expressed.

Last Answer : This could be an example from work or from school. Explain how you actively listen and what you do to remember (e.g. taking notes).

Tell me about the most difficult or complex idea you have had to explain to someone?

Description : Tell me about the most difficult or complex idea you have had to explain to someone?

Last Answer : Once again, the employer is more interested in the tools you use to effectively communicate a complex idea, rather than the idea itself. Points to bear in mind when explaining your ... encourage questions and if somebody is having difficulty understanding, you are quick to adapt your style.

Why do people who misunderstand what you say for something absurd; then decide it is a good idea to discuss how crazy what they thought you had said was?

Description : Why do people who misunderstand what you say for something absurd; then decide it is a good idea to discuss how crazy what they thought you had said was?

Last Answer : I’m sure McKenna had to deal with that all the time.

If I were to give you this salary you requested but let you write your job description for the next year, what would it say?

Description : If I were to give you this salary you requested but let you write your job description for the next year, what would it say?

Last Answer : It should say the same thing - after all - if you think this salary is fair then it should suit the responsibilities!

It is said among my people that some things are improved by death. Tell me, what stinks while living, but in death, smells good? -Riddles

Description : It is said among my people that some things are improved by death. Tell me, what stinks while living, but in death, smells good? -Riddles

Last Answer : A Pig.

If I asked your current employer to tell us about your accomplishments, what do you think he would say?

Description : If I asked your current employer to tell us about your accomplishments, what do you think he would say?

Last Answer : He would probably talk about the time he asked me to present a new marketing campaign to one of our more difficult clients. I spent over a week preparing for that presentation. Since I knew this ... breaks one of the cardinal rules of job interviewing - to never speak negatively about a former boss.

A good friend of mine is thinking about going back to school to become an elementary school teacher (he's 37). Bad idea? Too old?

Description : A good friend of mine is thinking about going back to school to become an elementary school teacher (he's 37). Bad idea? Too old?

Last Answer : Well I am going to be 45 when I do my student teaching! I’m planning to teach special education in high school. I’ll be following this question looking mostly for pros!!

What would your friends say is your biggest weakness?

Description : What would your friends say is your biggest weakness?

Last Answer : Whenever my friends and I travel together, I do a lot of advanced planning. Most of my travel companions appreciate it, but some find it annoying. We just went to the Southwest, and three months before ... they say about all work and no play. A little time away from the office is good for everyone.

Top 10 Things Not to Say on a Job Interview

Description : Top 10 Things Not to Say on a Job Interview

Last Answer : 1. That suit looks expensive! How much money do you make, anyway? 2. What will my salary be? My rent is very high! 3. I've never heard of this company before. What type of business is this? 4. ... see what happens. 10. I'll really need to have my own office. I don't like working with other people.

What would you say are the major technical skills needed for this position?

Description : What would you say are the major technical skills needed for this position?

Last Answer : This depends on how much technology knowledge and skills you'll need for the job role. Make sure the level correlates to the job. For example, if you're an IT administrator, you'll probably need really ... If you're filing papers in the back, chances are you won't need such strong technical skills.

What would your supervisor say about you?

Description : What would your supervisor say about you?

Last Answer : Be honest because your supervisor may be called as a reference. Highlight good attributes that your supervisor would say about you. Would he/she hire you again if he/she could?

What would your co-workers say about you?

Description : What would your co-workers say about you?

Last Answer : Be honest because your co-workers may be called as a reference. Highlight good attributes that your co-workers would say about you.

What five words would you say describe you best?

Description : What five words would you say describe you best?

Last Answer : Choose these words carefully, and only choose five (if you don't follow instructions the company will frown on your answer). Choose words that describe attributes that you want the interviewer to know about you.

If you could oer suggestions on how to improve our company, what would you say?

Description : If you could oer suggestions on how to improve our company, what would you say?

Last Answer : Examine the trends of the company and also where there may be some weaknesses (news articles often document this on public companies or look at their competitors to see how they're positioning it ... you have that knowledge, think creatively on how you could improve upon that weakness for them.

If someone had to say something negative to you, what would they say?

Description : If someone had to say something negative to you, what would they say?

Last Answer : Again, be honest about sharing a story here about someone who may not have gotten along with you in the oce here and explain how you were able to fix that relationship or change your attitude/action to be a better person / coworker.

If your previous co-workers were here, what would they say about you?

Description : If your previous co-workers were here, what would they say about you?

Last Answer : Ok, this is not the time for full disclosure. If some people from your past are going to say you're a boring A-hole, you don't need to bring that up. Stay positive, always, and maybe have a ... or even better "John Doe has always said I was the most reliable, creative problem-solver he'd ever met."

What would your previous supervisor say your strongest point is?

Description : What would your previous supervisor say your strongest point is?

Last Answer : Again another chance to reinforce your positive traits - There are numerous good possibilities: Loyalty, Energy, Positive attitude, Leadership, Team player, Expertise, Initiative, Patience, Hard work, Creativity, Problem solve

The credit card machine is broken. What do you say to the customers?

Description : The credit card machine is broken. What do you say to the customers?

Last Answer : Sub: Free Retail interview questions and answers Interview questions: The credit card machine is broken. What do you say to the customers? Answer tips/answer samples: Credit card machine is a ... while keeping the goods; in addition, I will say sorry to the customers for the inconvenience.

What would your previous supervisor say your strongest point is?

Description : What would your previous supervisor say your strongest point is?

Last Answer : What would your previous supervisor say your strongest point is? Answer samples There are numerous good possibilities: Loyalty, Energy, Positive attitude, Leadership, Team player, Expertise, Initiative, Patience, Hard work, Creativity, Problem solver.

What do co-workers say about you?

Description : What do co-workers say about you?

Last Answer : This is another great chance to self yourself without coming across as being over confident. Be prepared with a quote or two from co-workers. Either a specific statement or a paraphrase will work. Jill ... worker she had ever known. It is as powerful as Jill having said it at the interview herself.

My bathroom STINKS! Do you have any suggestions?

Description : My bathroom STINKS! Do you have any suggestions?

Last Answer : Sewer gas is likely. Have your traps and vent stack checked. If there is a sink you have not used run water in it to fill the trap. You likely have a trap not holding water.

6 year old Helix piercing stinks?

Description : 6 year old Helix piercing stinks?

Last Answer : In my experience, all piercings stink and bad. Especially if they are gauged.

How could you know if your breathe stinks?

Description : How could you know if your breathe stinks?

Last Answer : Lick your wrist trying to get as much tougne to skin as possible. Count to ten and then smell.

They don't want sympathy, they don't want to hear it stinks. What else is there?

Description : They don't want sympathy, they don't want to hear it stinks. What else is there?

Last Answer : Just take him some chicken noodle soup and don’t say anything.

My refrigerator stinks like rotten meat...

Description : My refrigerator stinks like rotten meat...

Last Answer : I think so.

My husbands health insurance stinks , we need to get our own individual insurance..Help in PA?

Description : My husbands health insurance stinks , we need to get our own individual insurance..Help in PA?

Last Answer : Tell him to talk to his HR department and see if he can change his plan. That might be less costly than buying your own.

What does "PU" stand for in that "PU" that stinks?

Description : What does "PU" stand for in that "PU" that stinks?

Last Answer : it’s not “p” “u”.....it’s pew.

is this a weed ? It stinks!

Description : is this a weed ? It stinks!

Last Answer : no picture, does it look like cabbage.......shunk cabbage or stink weed

what is the name of a plant that stinks when you pull it out?

Description : what is the name of a plant that stinks when you pull it out?

Last Answer : Not enough information. You seem to be describing stoloniferous behavior of the plant - one that spreads by specialized roots called stolons. When you say the leaves come up through the surface do you mean that ... a leaf (rub it between your fingers) or do you need to pull it out of the ground?

Goat stinks?

Description : Can I disturb my neighbors if I keep a goat?

Last Answer : Only the goat goat Here's a little + info

air conditioning in a car stinks

Description : What to do when the air conditioning at Monde started to stink?

Last Answer : It is good to have the air conditioning cleaned by a workshop on a regular basis.